On 2026/11/11 16:55, Marc Espie wrote:
> One point I wish to make about the name is that doing anything that
> doesn't simply manipulate the pkgname stem would mean cascading changes
> all over the ports infrastructure.

yes.. I think my favourite option would be something like
stem-version-flavors.dbg.tgz but I see why that is trickier.

> The very simple structure of having a stem, followed by a dash,
> then a version number that starts with a digit and extends up to a possible
> dash followed by flavors markers is pervasive, both in bsd.port.mk, and in
> all the ports tree tools.
> 
> If you do anything else, like having debug packages treated like another 
> flavor, would require special coding for conflict markers and stuff like
> that.
> 
> I feel that that stuff is already complicated enough.
> 
> It's worthwhile choosing a stem-extension that's not confusing.
> 
> We could also make it .dbg, since it's the name of the files used in the
> package proper ?
> 
> e.g., stem.dbg-version[-flavors] ?
> 
> I don't find it either less confusing or more confusing than any other 
> proposal
> so far.
> 

I am happy with these, in decreasing order of preference for me,
but I'd be ok with any of them:

stem.dbg-version[-flavors]
stem.dbgsym-version[-flavors]
stem-dbgsym-version[-flavors]
stem.debuginfo-version[-flavors]
stem-debuginfo-version[-flavors]

I don't really like stem-dbg-version, stem-debug-version, or stem.debug-version

Reply via email to