On Monday 24 August 2009 12:51:49 Jacob Meuser wrote: > could we move the support for win32/real/qtx codecs to a flavor? > > currently, one has to have machdep.userldt enabled to play WMV/WMA > files, even if mplayer doesn't really need to load the codecs to > play the files. this is because when mplayer is built with support > for the binary codecs, it tries to probe the codecs when opening > a WMV/WMA file. then mplayer exists asking you to enable > machdep.userldt. this doesn't happen if mplayer is built without > support for the binary codecs. it just plays the files.
Why does it not surprise me that MPlayer has such a poor default behavior. The other multimedia players will play WMV/WMA just fine with the native codec via FFmpeg before even attempting to fallback and load any binary codecs. I thought maybe when MPlayer was updated to have a newer copy of FFmpeg it would have a more sane behavior but it seems they haven't "fixed" that yet. After I update FFmpeg I'll be removing the support from VLC and Xine-lib. The last thing I have ever needed to use win32-codecs for over the years was for RealVideo 3/4 and that's taken care of now with FFmpeg. Porters I have spoken to also seemed to be interested in doing the same for MPlayer when it was updated. The FFmpeg developers are very interested in receiving any files that do not work properly with anything reasonably new (obviously our in-tree FFmpeg is a bit old now). -- This message has been scanned for viruses and dangerous content by MailScanner, and is believed to be clean.