http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Korea/LI15Dg01.html

 Sep 15, 2010


Sun sets on Indonesia's North Korea ties
By Jeffrey Robertson 



North Korea's eroding relationships are not news. The steady decline in 
countries interested in maintaining relations with the wayward nuclear wannabe 
is as accepted as it is expected. There remain a standout few, stubborn to the 
last, marked by their repeated refusals to support resolutions condemning North 
Korean human-rights abuses - China, Russia, Cuba, Egypt and ... Indonesia. But 
for how long? 

The sinking in March of the South Korean naval vessel, the Cheonan, saw South 
and North Korean diplomats rush around the region to obtain support for their 
version of events. Both countries saw Indonesia as a key diplomatic 
battleground. 

In July, two Indonesian fishermen who died during efforts to recover the 
Cheonan were awarded the National Security Medal and their families compensated 
for the loss in a compassionate ceremony, which was welcomed in the Indonesian 
domestic press. In early August, North Korean Foreign Minister Pak Ui-chan 
visited Indonesia for five days in an attempt to bolster support. Yet reverting 
to convention, Pak departed without giving a single press conference. South 
Korea's well-handled diplomacy may have been the winning act. 

The next leader of North Korea may be the first to feel a new coldness in the 
North Korea-Indonesia relationship. After years of the coziness felt between 
leaders who can disregard domestic and international opinion, the relationship 
is on the brink of a long, cold stasis. 

Economic change 
An historian would mark change in the North Korea-Indonesia relationship as 
beginning in September 1973, when Indonesia established diplomatic relations 
with South Korea. An economist would say that this change occurred three years 
later when South Korea's gross domestic product (GDP) passed that of North 
Korea. 

Early trade between North Korea and Indonesia consisted of shipments of 
plywood, paper, tobacco products and packing materials going from Indonesia to 
North Korea and returning with organic chemicals, steel and machinery. Today, 
North Korea's needs for Indonesia's raw material inputs into the manufacturing 
process - plywood, paper and packing materials - has ended. Its ability to 
export the final products of these manufacturing processes has also ended. 

In contrast, South Korea-Indonesia trade is booming. A recount of recent 
economic deals paints a clear picture. In August 2010, South Korea's POSCO 
announced that it would commence construction of a steel mill in Indonesia. The 
joint venture with Indonesia's largest steelmaker, Krakatau, will have an 
annual capacity of 3 million tons. 

Power for the plant could well be sourced from a 120 megawatt coal-fired power 
plant being built by South Korea's Daewoo Engineering and its Indonesian 
partner, Merak Energi. Even the trucks that carry supplies between the two will 
probably be South Korean Hyundai's, running on tires made by Hankook, which in 
August announced plans for a US$1.2 billion investment to build a tire 
manufacturing plant in Indonesia. 

In 2009, bilateral trade between Indonesia and South Korea was valued at $15.3 
billion. South Korea is the sixth-largest investor in Indonesia. 

Political change
North Korea and Indonesia established diplomatic relations in 1964 - a time 
when young countries, as they both were then, could excuse authoritarianism in 
the interests of decolonization and economic development. Economic development 
could even be set aside for the political coziness of shared political 
preferences for centralized and military-dominated governance and shared 
dislikes of democratic idealism and Western interference. 

Perhaps reflecting a longing for these early beginnings, North Korea routinely 
marks every bilateral visit with a statement recalling the April 1965 visit of 
Kim Il-sung and Kim Jong-il to Jakarta. On that often-mentioned occasion, Kim 
Jong-il travelled by plane rather than in the armored train to which the modern 
reader today has become accustomed to associating with the North Korean leader. 

President Sukarno presented his North Korean visitors with an orchid from the 
Bogor Botanical Gardens, which would subsequently become a national symbol of 
North Korea, the kimilsungia. But all good things come to an end. Sukarno was 
thrown out of office by an ambitious major-general and left to live out his 
life under house arrest. 

Sukarno's usurper, Suharto, also shared certain political preferences for 
centralized and military-dominated governance - so the political relationship 
bumbled along until May 1998, when Suharto was forced from office amidst 
strikes, demonstrations and economic collapse. The beginning of Indonesia's 
progress towards democracy after 32 years of Suharto rule effectively ended the 
political rational for maintaining a relationship with North Korea. 

Strategic change 
Indonesia once looked at North Korea as a fellow member of the Non-Aligned 
Movement and as a partner for strategic cooperation. Today its strategic future 
is tied up with the 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), 
which has blossomed into an important regional actor and is more likely to 
cooperate with South Korea, Australia and other regional middle-powers, as 
evidenced by coordination at the Group of 20 and the ASEAN Regional Forum. 

While Indonesia once looked at North Korea as a source for defense procurement, 
it today looks to South Korea. Indonesia is poised to increase its defense 
spending from its current level of 0.8% of gross domestic product (GDP) to 1.5% 
of GDP in 2014. This will include a 20% stake in the development of Korea's 
next generation fighter, known as the KFX or "Boramae", and potentially the 
purchase of South Korean submarines, training jets and armored personnel 
carriers. 

If there ever was a strategic rationale for Indonesia to maintain relations 
with North Korea, it too has ended. 

Human rights as a final nail in the coffin? 
In June 2010, the United Nations Human Rights Council appointed Marzuki 
Darusman as special rapporteur on human rights in North Korea. Darusman 
replaced Thailand's Vitit Muntarbhorn, who for six years detailed a litany of 
human rights abuses despite not being allowed entry into North Korea. Darusman 
is a former attorney-general of Indonesia, a member of the United Nations 
Independent Commission for Investigations and co-chairman of the working group 
for an ASEAN human rights mechanism. Like Muntarbhorn, it is unlikely that he 
will let himself be silenced or sidelined. 

Indonesia has experienced the human rights abuses that can occur under an 
authoritarian government. It is a country that is now increasingly speaking out 
against flagrant abuses of human rights in Myanmar, despite its commitment to 
the ASEAN way of cooperation, conflict avoidance and consensus. 

When the United Nations Human Rights Council met in March 2010 to discuss North 
Korea, Indonesia voted against a resolution condemning the country's human 
rights violations, alongside China, Russia, Cuba and Egypt. 

At the time, a chorus of voices in the Indonesian domestic press questioned 
Indonesia's decision. Economic, political and strategic reality had finally 
dawned. When the next vote in the human rights council occurs, don't count on 
Indonesia being in the same place. 

Jeffrey Robertson is a foreign affairs analyst focusing on the Korean Peninsula 
region. He can be reached at [email protected]
. 

(Copyright 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please 
contact us about sales, syndication and republishing





[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke