guardian.co.uk home

WikiLeaks Iraq war logs: Nick Clegg calls for investigation of abuse claims

Any suggestions that the rules of war have been broken or torture condoned are 
'extremely serious', says deputy PM

    * Jonathan Haynes, Mark Townsend, Jamie Doward and Paul Harris and agencies
    * guardian.co.uk, Sunday 24 October 2010 12.45 BST
    * larger | smaller
    * Article history

Nick Clegg on The Andrew Marr Show Nick Clegg on The Andrew Marr Show. 
Photograph: Handout/Getty Images

Allegations of killings, torture and abuse in Iraq contained in leaked US 
military logs "need to be looked at", Nick Clegg said today.

The deputy prime minister said any suggestion that the rules of war had been 
broken or torture had been condoned were "extremely serious".

The almost 400,000 secret US army field reports show two cases of alleged 
involvement of British troops in the abuse of detainees.

Clegg did not rule out the possibility of an inquiry into the actions of 
British forces in Iraq, but said it was up to the US administration to answer 
for the actions of its forces.

His comments contrasted with a statement from the Ministry of Defence 
yesterday, which warned that the posting of classified US military logs on the 
WikiLeaks website could endanger the lives of British forces.

Clegg told BBC1's The Andrew Marr Show: "We can bemoan how these leaks 
occurred, but I think the nature of the allegations made are extraordinarily 
serious. They are distressing to read about and they are very serious. I am 
assuming the US administration will want to provide its own answer. It's not 
for us to tell them how to do that."

Asked if there should be an inquiry into the role of British troops, he said: 
"I think anything that suggests that basic rules of war, conflict and 
engagement have been broken or that torture has been in any way condoned are 
extremely serious and need to be looked at."

He added: "People will want to hear what the answer is to what are very, very 
serious allegations of a nature which I think everybody will find quite 
shocking."

Vince Cable, the business secretary, also said allegations of abuse should be 
investigated and criticised the way in which they were leaked. He told Sky News 
Sunday Live: "The Liberal Democrats were strong opponents of the Iraq war and 
we do feel vindicated by what's happening."

He added: "I think there have been several investigations already but I think, 
clearly, if there have been abuses taking place they need to be investigated – 
that's obvious enough."

British involvement in the alleged torture and unlawful killing of Iraqi 
civilians may also be the subject of legal action. Lawyers said the reports 
embroiled British as well as US forces in an alleged culture of abuse and 
extrajudicial killings in Iraq.

Phil Shiner, of Public Interest Lawyers, appearing alongside the WikiLeaks 
founder Julian Assange at a press conference in London yesterday, said some of 
the deaths documented in the reports may have involved British forces and could 
now go through the UK courts. The Iraq war logs, Shiner said, indicated that 
British as well as US commanders were likely to have ignored evidence of 
torture by the Iraqi authorities, contrary to international law.

"Some of these deaths will be in circumstances where the UK have a very clear 
legal responsibility. This may be because the Iraqis died while under the 
effective control of UK forces – under arrest, in vehicles, helicopters or 
detention facilities," he said.

The Ministry of Defence said the publication of the records was reckless and 
put the lives of British military personnel in danger, adding that it 
investigated any allegations made against British troops. It said: "There is no 
place for mistreatment of detainees. Any civilian casualty is a matter of deep 
regret and we take any incidents extremely seriously."

As Assange defended the decision to disclose the documents – saying it was of 
"immense importance" to reveal the truth about the conflict – the UN warned 
that if the logs pointed to clear violations of the UN convention against 
torture, Barack Obama's administration had a clear obligation to investigate 
them.

Manfred Novak, the UN special rapporteur on torture, said: "President Obama 
came to power with a moral agenda, saying we don't want to be seen to be a 
nation responsible for major human rights violations." A failure to investigate 
credible claims of complicity in torture, Novak suggested, would be a failure 
of the Obama government to recognise US obligations under international law.

The US defence department condemned the WikiLeaks release, describing the 
documents as raw observations by tactical units, which were only snapshots of 
tragic, mundane events. Assange said the snapshots of everyday events offered a 
glimpse at the "human scale" of the conflict. He told the news conference his 
motive for the disclosure was "about the truth".

Iraq Body Count, a private British-based group that has tracked the number of 
Iraqi civilians killed since the war began in 2003, said its analysis of the 
logs had raised its total of civilian deaths from 107,369 to more than 122,000. 
IBC, which worked with WikiLeaks, said the war logs showed there were more than 
109,000 violent deaths between 2004 and the end of 2009. They included 66,081 
civilians, 23,984 people classed as "enemy", 15,196 members of the Iraqi 
security forces, and 3,771 coalition troops.

John Sloboda of IBC said: "They [the documents] show the relentless grind of 
daily killings in almost every town or village in every province."

WikiLeaks yesterday promised to publish 15,000 more documents about the war in 
Afghanistan.




------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke