There are two major problems with that confgi:
- there is a "routes" block nested under "inhibit_rules", where it is not 
allowed
- there is a "matchers" block nested under "receivers", where it is not 
allowed

And if I try to start alertmanager 0.25.0 (the version you say you're 
using) with that exact configuration, it aborts.

root@prometheus:~# /opt/alertmanager-0.25.0.linux-amd64/alertmanager 
--config.file=amtest.conf  --web.listen-address=:9193 
--cluster.listen-address=0.0.0.0:9194
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.716Z caller=main.go:240 level=info msg="Starting 
Alertmanager" version="(version=0.25.0, branch=HEAD, 
revision=258fab7cdd551f2cf251ed0348f0ad7289aee789)"
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.716Z caller=main.go:241 level=info 
build_context="(go=go1.19.4, user=root@abe866dd5717, 
date=20221222-14:51:36)"
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.723Z caller=cluster.go:185 level=info 
component=cluster msg="setting advertise address explicitly" 
addr=10.12.255.33 port=9194
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.726Z caller=cluster.go:681 level=info 
component=cluster msg="Waiting for gossip to settle..." interval=2s
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.761Z caller=coordinator.go:113 level=info 
component=configuration msg="Loading configuration file" file=amtest.conf
*ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.761Z caller=coordinator.go:118 level=error 
component=configuration msg="Loading configuration file failed" 
file=amtest.conf err="yaml: unmarshal errors:\n  line 27: field routes not 
found in type config.plain\n  line 43: field matchers not found in type 
config.plain"*
ts=2025-01-07T08:51:23.761Z caller=cluster.go:690 level=info 
component=cluster msg="gossip not settled but continuing anyway" polls=0 
elapsed=35.105627ms

You cannot possibly be running a working alertmanager with this config.

On Monday, 6 January 2025 at 18:40:09 UTC Chrysale Tchako wrote:

> This is the exact configuration of my alermanager.yml file (some values 
> were substituted for privacy/security) do you notice any discrepancies? 
>
> global:
>   smtp_hello: 'example.com'
>
>
> route:
>   group_wait: 1m
>   group_interval: 5m
>   repeat_interval: 12h
>   group_by: ["alertname", "severity"]
>   # Default receiver (for all alerts that don't match any specific route)
>   receiver: "default-receiver"
>
>   routes:
>     - receiver: "default-receiver"  # This is for other alerts, not 
> EndpointDown or dev-team alerts
>       continue: true
>     - match:
>         service: "EndpointDown"
>       receiver: "custom-receiver"
>
>
> inhibit_rules:
>   - source_matchers:
>       - severity="critical"
>     target_matchers:
>       - severity="warning"
>     equal: ['alertname', 'instance']
>     routes:
>       - {receiver: default-receiver, continue: true}
>       - {receiver: custom-receiver}
>
>
> receivers:
>   # Default receiver for other alerts
>   - name: "default-receiver"
>     email_configs:
>       - to: "[email protected], [email protected]"
>         from: '[email protected]'
>         smarthost: 'smtp-relay.example.com:587'
>         send_resolved: true
>
>   # Receiver for custom alerts (both EndpointDown and dev-team alerts)
>   - name: "custom-receiver"
>     matchers:
>       - service: "EndpointDown"
>     email_configs:
>       - to: '[email protected]'
>         from: '[email protected]'
>         smarthost: 'smtp-relay.example.com:587'
>         send_resolved: true
>
> On Monday, January 6, 2025 at 1:03:08 PM UTC-5 Brian Candler wrote:
>
>> Then something strange is going on. Are you 100% sure that you pasted 
>> *exactly* the configuration file you're using, with *exactly* the correct 
>> contents and indentation?
>>
>> You can add labels in your service discovery, e.g. if you are using 
>> file_sd_configs then inside the targets file you can put
>>
>> - labels:
>>     owner: teamA
>>   targets:
>>     - foo
>>     - bar
>>     - baz
>> - labels:
>>     owner: teamB
>>   targets:
>>     - qux
>>
>> In this case, all timeseries which are scraped from the hosts will have 
>> those labels added as attributes of every timeseries.
>>
>> Or you can add labels in your alerting rules:
>>
>> groups:
>> - name: UpDown
>>   rules:
>>   - alert: UpDownTeamA
>>     expr: up{instance=~"foo|bar|baz"} == 0
>>     for: 3m
>>     keep_firing_for: 3m
>>     labels:
>>       owner: teamA
>>   - alert: UpDownTeamB
>>     expr: up{instance=~"qux"} == 0
>>     for: 3m
>>     keep_firing_for: 3m
>>     labels:
>>       owner: teamB
>>
>> It's up to you on whether you want to label the timeseries themselves 
>> (which is simpler but less flexible), or do the labelling in the alerting 
>> rules (which means you may need to look at other labels to decide how to 
>> route things, but allows you to change your alert routing without changing 
>> the underlying timeseries)
>>
>> In alertmanager you'd then match labels to decide where to deliver.
>>
>> route:
>>
>>   # Default receiver (for all alerts that don't match any specific route)
>>   receiver: "everyone"
>>
>>   routes:
>>     - matchers:
>>         - owner=teamA
>>       receiver: "gmail"
>>     - matchers:
>>         - owner=teamB
>>       receiver: "dev-receiver"
>>
>> This simple example says alerts with owner=teamA go to "gmail", alerts 
>> with owner=teamB go to "dev-receiver", and everything else goes to 
>> "everyone".  (The first match stops any subsequent processing, unless that 
>> rule has "continue: true")
>>
>> There is a tool you can test your alertmanager config with here:
>> https://prometheus.io/webtools/alerting/routing-tree-editor/
>>
>> Try pasting in the above block, then click "Draw routing tree". Then next 
>> to Match Label Set, enter
>> {instance="foo",owner="teamA"}
>> and click Match Label Set.
>>
>> HTH.
>>
>> On Monday, 6 January 2025 at 16:39:49 UTC Chrysale Tchako wrote:
>>
>>>
>>> I believe this is the correct config file because when I mute an email 
>>> from one of the receivers that email is no longer included in any 
>>> notification that gets sent out. As far as the labels you mentioned 
>>> earlier, could you share an example of how to implement or format those in 
>>> my alertmanager.yml and alert.rules.yml files.
>>> On Friday, January 3, 2025 at 11:15:20 AM UTC-5 Brian Candler wrote:
>>>
>>>> I have retested this with alertmanager 0.25.0, and it still rejects the 
>>>> config file you supplied as invalid, refusing to start. Therefore, I think 
>>>> you're *not* running with the configuration file you think you are. This 
>>>> is 
>>>> the first issue to resolve.
>>>>
>>>> You can prove this to yourself by running a separate instance of 
>>>> alertmanager on the command line, pointing it explicitly at the config 
>>>> file 
>>>> in question:
>>>>
>>>> # /opt/alertmanager-0.25.0.linux-amd64/alertmanager 
>>>> --config.file=amtest.conf.orig  --web.listen-address=:9193 
>>>> --cluster.listen-address=0.0.0.0:9194
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.215Z caller=main.go:240 level=info msg="Starting 
>>>> Alertmanager" version="(version=0.25.0, branch=HEAD, 
>>>> revision=258fab7cdd551f2cf251ed0348f0ad7289aee789)"
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.215Z caller=main.go:241 level=info 
>>>> build_context="(go=go1.19.4, user=root@abe866dd5717, 
>>>> date=20221222-14:51:36)"
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.217Z caller=cluster.go:185 level=info 
>>>> component=cluster msg="setting advertise address explicitly" 
>>>> addr=10.12.255.33 port=9194
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.219Z caller=cluster.go:681 level=info 
>>>> component=cluster msg="Waiting for gossip to settle..." interval=2s
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.249Z caller=coordinator.go:113 level=info 
>>>> component=configuration msg="Loading configuration file" 
>>>> file=amtest.conf.orig
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.249Z caller=coordinator.go:118 level=error 
>>>> component=configuration *msg="Loading configuration file failed" 
>>>> file=amtest.conf.orig err="yaml: unmarshal errors:\n  line 12: field 
>>>> routes 
>>>> not found in type config.plain\n  line 23: field routes not found in type 
>>>> config.plain"*
>>>> ts=2025-01-03T16:10:12.249Z caller=cluster.go:690 level=info 
>>>> component=cluster msg="gossip not settled but continuing anyway" polls=0 
>>>> elapsed=30.684346ms
>>>>
>>>> (The default config file is "alertmanager.yml", but as there is no 
>>>> absolute path, it will be in whatever the current working directory is 
>>>> when 
>>>> alertmanager is started. This may not be where you think it is, and in 
>>>> particular, is not necessarily the same directory as alertmanager itself)
>>>>
>>>> > Let's say I have Team A receiver for Team A resources and Team B 
>>>> receiver for Team B resources, I want to isolate the notifications for 
>>>> each 
>>>> team. Neither team should be aware of or get notified about the other 
>>>> teams 
>>>> resources. How can I accomplish that?
>>>>
>>>> You set labels on the Team A / Team B alerts, and use those labels in 
>>>> routing rules in alertmanager to route them appropriately. But there's no 
>>>> point trying to do that until you've worked out why the system isn't using 
>>>> the configuration file you think it is.
>>>>
>>>> On Friday, 3 January 2025 at 15:43:30 UTC Chrysale Tchako wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> Currently I am running alertmanager version 0.25.0, and I am making 
>>>>> changes/modifications directly in the alertmanager.yml file, this is the 
>>>>> file containing the information I shared in my initial inquiry. Or are 
>>>>> referring to another file? I updated my routes config to match what you 
>>>>> recommended but, email notifications are still getting sent to all emails 
>>>>> in the alertmanager.yml file regardless of the receiver they are 
>>>>> associated 
>>>>> with. What I am trying to accomplish is a custom alert/notification for 
>>>>> each receiver. 
>>>>>
>>>>> Let's say I have Team A receiver for Team A resources and Team B 
>>>>> receiver for Team B resources, I want to isolate the notifications for 
>>>>> each 
>>>>> team. Neither team should be aware of or get notified about the other 
>>>>> teams 
>>>>> resources. How can I accomplish that? What modifications should I make to 
>>>>> my alertmanager.yml file? Also, do I need to make any modifications to 
>>>>> my alert.rules.yml file or any other file that is?
>>>>>
>>>>> Please let me know if you need any additional information.
>>>>>
>>>>> On Thursday, January 2, 2025 at 11:56:08 AM UTC-5 Brian Candler wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>>> What version of alertmanager are you using? Your configuration is 
>>>>>> invalid, so I don't know how you're even getting alertmanager to start.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> You have a top-level "routes:" block (before "inhibit_rules"), and 
>>>>>> you have another "routes:" block nested under inhibit_rules, but neither 
>>>>>> of 
>>>>>> these are allowed by Alertmanager. If I try to run your config with 
>>>>>> alertmanager-0.27.0 I get an explicit error:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> ts=2025-01-02T16:41:05.905Z caller=coordinator.go:118 level=error 
>>>>>> component=configuration msg="Loading configuration file failed" 
>>>>>> file=amtest.conf err="yaml: unmarshal errors:\n*  line 12: field 
>>>>>> routes not found in type config.plain\n  line 23: field routes not found 
>>>>>> in 
>>>>>> type config.plain*"
>>>>>>
>>>>>> It would be valid to nest "routes" under "route", like this:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> route:
>>>>>>   group_wait: 1m
>>>>>>   group_interval: 5m
>>>>>>   repeat_interval: 12h
>>>>>>   group_by: ["alertname", "severity"]
>>>>>>   # Default receiver (for all alerts that don't match any specific 
>>>>>> route)
>>>>>>   receiver: "gmail"
>>>>>>
>>>>>>   routes:
>>>>>>     - receiver: "gmail"
>>>>>>       continue: true
>>>>>>     - receiver: "dev-receiver"
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Note the spacing: "routes:" is indented to line up with other 
>>>>>> attributes like "receiver", not at the top level. Furthermore, if you 
>>>>>> did, 
>>>>>> it could explain the behaviour you're seeing, since this configuration 
>>>>>> requests all messages to be sent to both receivers. But since you say 
>>>>>> that's *not* your actual configuration, I think we have to start 
>>>>>> somewhere 
>>>>>> else.
>>>>>>
>>>>>> How are you getting your config into alertmanager? Are you editing 
>>>>>> the alertmanager configuration directly, or is it coming via some 
>>>>>> frontend 
>>>>>> like a helm chart which spits out the config? If so, can you show the 
>>>>>> generated config, which is the actual file that alertmanager consumes?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> > What changes can I make so that each receiver gets it's own 
>>>>>> individual email notification instead of grouping them together?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> What do you mean by "individual email notification instead of 
>>>>>> grouping them together"?  Do you want some alerts to go to one receiver, 
>>>>>> and some alerts to go to a different receiver? If so, how do you want to 
>>>>>> choose which alerts go where?
>>>>>>
>>>>>> On Thursday, 2 January 2025 at 15:16:26 UTC Chrysale Tchako wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> This is my current alertmanager.yml config, but all notifications 
>>>>>>> sent out get sent to all emails added in the "to" section of the email 
>>>>>>> configs. What changes can I make so that each receiver gets it's own 
>>>>>>> individual email notification instead of grouping them together? Note 
>>>>>>> the 
>>>>>>> "from" email is the same for both receivers.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> global:
>>>>>>>   smtp_hello: '*******.net'
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> route:
>>>>>>>   group_wait: 1m
>>>>>>>   group_interval: 5m
>>>>>>>   repeat_interval: 12h
>>>>>>>   group_by: ["alertname", "severity"]
>>>>>>>   # Default receiver (for all alerts that don't match any specific 
>>>>>>> route)
>>>>>>>   receiver: "gmail"
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> routes:
>>>>>>>   - receiver: "gmail"
>>>>>>>     continue: true
>>>>>>>   - receiver: "dev-receiver"
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> inhibit_rules:
>>>>>>>   - source_matchers:
>>>>>>>       - severity="critical"
>>>>>>>     target_matchers:
>>>>>>>       - severity="warning"
>>>>>>>     equal: ['alertname', 'instance']
>>>>>>>     routes:
>>>>>>>       - receiver: "gmail"
>>>>>>>         continue: true
>>>>>>>       - receiver: "dev-receiver"
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> receivers:
>>>>>>>   # Default receiver for other alerts
>>>>>>>   - name: "gmail"
>>>>>>>     email_configs:
>>>>>>>       - to: "email1.net, email2.net"
>>>>>>>         from: '*******.net'
>>>>>>>         smarthost: 'smtp-relay.gmail.com:587'
>>>>>>>         send_resolved: true
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>   - name: "dev-receiver"
>>>>>>>     email_configs:
>>>>>>>       - to: 'email3.net'
>>>>>>>         from: '*******.net'
>>>>>>>         smarthost: 'smtp-relay.gmail.com:587'
>>>>>>>         send_resolved: true
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Prometheus Users" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/prometheus-users/324a6655-6199-4baa-bf50-4b7b4d77dab8n%40googlegroups.com.

Reply via email to