Zash‎ speaks out against merging this patch and fixing the issue. To be honest, I don't understand this anti-legacy attitude in the world where vcard4 is currently supported by one(?) released client and others use vcard.

Still hoping this patch to be merged.

> ‎ValdikSS‎: https://xmpp.org/extensions/xep-0292.html#mapping-temponly-desc > >Mapping the vcard-temp <DESC/> element to the vCard4 NOTE property is appropriate.
> ‎Zash‎: That is what it does
> ‎ValdikSS‎: It doesn't mention reverse-mapping, but why not? Can't find anything in the dev list. > ‎Zash‎: In the 3 years since Prosody 0.11.0 was released with this, I think this is the second time I've seen it mentioned in the Gajim channel and nobody has reported a bug about it to us. > ‎Zash‎: Not seeing any bug reports to Gajim for not showing the NOTE field either.
> ‎ValdikSS‎: Zash, I didn't notice it until recently
> ‎Zash‎: Just as Gajim finally merges the new work that removes vcard-temp support entirely 🙂 > ‎ValdikSS‎: I'll send it to devel list anyway, as I believe it fixes a bug and does not introduce new. > ‎ValdikSS‎: Zash, there are other clients like miranda, psi, which support only vcard-temp. It's useful. > ‎Zash‎: I'd be happier if those switched to vcard4 and vcard-temp went away. > ‎Zash‎: You are free to use the old mod_vcard (maybe it should have been called vcard_legacy... but eh, names are hard) > ‎Zash‎: Your patch would show the same info twice in a client that shows both NOTE and DESC. > ‎Zash‎: I once had a patch that preserved "this <note> was originally a <DESC>" but this idea was rejected some years ago I think and I can't find that patch anymore. > ‎ValdikSS‎: Zash, well yes, is that an issue? Are there clients which show note? > ‎Zash‎: I'm not really interested in taking any action on this anymore. Sorry.

On 05.12.2021 20:14, ValdikSS wrote:
Some clients like Gajim 1.3.3 and Psi 1.5 support displaying only DESC field of vcard-temp and does not show NOTE.
However, vcard4 contains only "note" and missing "desc".

Map vcard4 "note" to both "NOTE" and "DESC" vcard-temp fields to fix the issue.

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"prosody-dev" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/prosody-dev/b3af38c6-f387-aad7-dc7d-b069a74c061c%40valdikss.org.ru.

Attachment: OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature

Reply via email to