Hi Slau,
Thanks for such a detailed answer. It is interesting to read these, because as I have said before we all bring different usages to the table. as a radio producer, for example, I use the workspace window a great deal, but would never need the midi structure at all. I have mixed reviews about plug ins, I do not like the automatic aspect, I will use the designated fader on my digi for flavoring, but many folks are not going to have that kind of background or even need it. I am not sure how I feel about the groups list factor, that will depend on what I am doing.
The additional keystrokes though will be  great.
I almost wish there had been more sound, but non-music people involved with the construction, but still its progress. I think for me personally though the question comes down to how efficiently i can work in the new setup without loss of speed, and your wise points about both knowing the screen reader, I have never used voiceover at all, and being firm in pro tools, I am better at this, but not recent editions carries allot of weight. I will likely end up asking my type of editing questions of someone used to teaching pro tools for radio rather than anyone on this list. Still thanks for your take, and I look forward to reading other comments as well.


Karen

On Thu, 8 Jul 2010, Slau Halatyn wrote:

OK, Karen,

I finally have a chance to give you and the list members who've used Pro Tools 
with OS 9 an overview of how the two systems compare in terms of accessibility.

First, I suppose it's important to point out (although it should be fairly 
apparent) that the same Pro Tools keyboard shortcuts that were available in Pro 
Tools version 5 under OS 9 are still available. In fact, there are even more 
shortcuts since combinations once available only in TDM systems were 
incorporated into LE since Pro Tools version 6.7 or so. Since outSPOKEN users 
couldn't migrate to version 6, this was never available until now.

Some aspects of the user interface which were hidden or clumsy under OS 9 
unless you were a power user, are now easily accessible in Pro Tools 8. for 
example, the playlist icon was never visible with outSPOKEN. A user had to 
simply understand that it was an invisible icon to the right of the track name 
in the Edit window. Not the track name in the Show/Hide list but within the 
scroll area that contained the record, mute and solo buttons. The icon was in a 
fixed position based on the relative position of the track name and, since 
track names in this display were limited to 8 or 9 characters or so, the icon 
was directly to the right. If a track name had four characters, an outSPOKEN 
user could move the cursor four clicks to the right and do a mouse click. This, 
of course, presumed that one had read the track name from left to right rather 
than right to left, else the cursor would be to the left of the track name and 
one wouldn't land on the right position to click on the playlist icon.

All of what I described above makes it sound like it's incredibly complex to 
get to the playlist icon with outSPOKEN. Trust me, it's not. I can do it in a 
matter of a couple of seconds—probably faster than it would take someone to 
grab a mouse and move the pointer. However, to someone who wasn't using Pro 
tools every day and for a living, it might not even occur to them that such a 
thing is possible. However, with the current version, it's a simple matter of 
clicking on the playlist button and you're in.

Another such example is the Groups List where, depending upon what was 
highlighted or active, one had to constantly monitor what the status was of any 
given group, especially in a complex editing situation where groups were being 
employed. Now it's an easy task and doesn't require a bunch of mousing around 
and checking status, etc.

An area that's not yet accessible is the MIDI Event List. Now, that's a big 
deal, frankly. For the most part, I use MIDI fairly often but not nearly as 
often as someone would in a home studio situation. Most of my needs and my 
client's needs are covered by simple record, cut, copy and paste, perhaps a 
little quantization. A significant portion of the time, however, MIDI is of no 
significant use to me. That said, when I do need tight control of things like 
editing note on and off velocities, it won't be possible with the current MIDI 
Event List. There are certain work-arounds which I won't get into right now but 
will simply say they're not nearly as efficient as having an accessible event 
list.

In a similar way, entering tempo and meter changes is a breeze but, once 
they're entered, it's not possible to edit them currently. In some cases, 
that's a deal-breaker for someone needing heavy editing of tempo maps, etc.

The subject of plug-ins is interesting and somewhat complicated. When the last major work 
was about to be completed on the interface, we all thought plug-ins weren't going to be 
accessible at all until a future release. Believe me, after seeing what had already been 
done with the entire rest of the interface, I thought, "So what. Look at all we have 
to start with." Turns out, the programmer figured out a work-around that gained 
access to most plug-ins right out of the box by exposing automation parameters. Now, this 
works quite well for a ton of plug-ins but not necessarily all plug-ins. This is because, 
while plug-ins have automate-able parameters, they might have menu buttons which are not 
automate-able and, thus, are not exposed to VoiceOver. A work-around is to use something 
like quicKeys to create shortcuts which can even be shared among users. None of that has 
happened yet although I've used QK for many years, I haven't used it in OS X. I'm sure 
Bryan's experiments will yield some great results at some point soon. Perhaps others 
might get involved as well.
There are still some windows that are not accessible like the Workspace window 
or the Disk Space window, the Universe window, among others. These are not 
critical and have varying degrees of importance. for example, the Workspace 
window is where you set the record and playback designations for given volumes 
on your system. In other words, you specify whether a hard drive is for 
playback only or recording, etc. Well, I've never had to set anything in that 
window until one specific instance where, for some inexplicable reason, Pro 
Tools wanted me to specify the information. Actually, this was even before I 
had a beta of the accessible version. I was using Pro Tools completely by 
keyboard shortcuts to playback some backing tracks at a performance. Well, 
luckily, I had someone look at the screen, set the parameters and we were off. 
since then, never had to look at that window again. Still, it's something that 
we should have access to in the future, just for those special occasions when 
things are going so smoothly and a good wrench in the gears would make life oh 
so much more interesting.

Now, speaking of having a sighted person help, I have to say that, Pro Tools is both a 
very simple and very complex program. In fact, it can be anything in between as well. 
Thing is, the better one knows the user interface or at least how to use Pro Tools, the 
better off they'll be using it with VoiceOver. I've always said that one needs to read 
the Pro Tools Reference Guide and understand it independently of the screen reader. 
Secondly, one needs to know the screen reader like the back of their hand if they expect 
to be efficient. That said, I haven't put in enough "real world" time in on 
VoiceOver with Pro Tools 8 in order to feel comfortable using it in sessions with my 
clients. Sure, some sessions would be a breeze but, some of the more complex sessions 
would require me to have some procedures a little bit more, shall we say, under my 
fingers. I have no doubt that I'll get to that point very soon.

Having said a few specific things and a few general things, it might be easier 
for me to answer some very specific questions about specific tasks rather than 
general things about what it's like to work in Pro Tools or edit in Pro Tools. 
Questions like that are simply too big and they can have a short or a long 
answer, both of which may not actually answer the question satisfactorily. 
Hopefully that makes sense.

OK, enough for now.

Slau


On Jul 7, 2010, at 7:20 PM, Karen Lewellen wrote:

why thank you!
I hope you took a moment to pat yourself on the back, you have worked long and 
hard for this.

For those who have used it already though specifically with digi 002 or 003, 
especially those who were hold overs from the os 9 days,
What do we lose?
Slau already said that they are not even mentioning this access as a feature,  
and it is far from 100%, but do you gain more then you had in the prior 
accessible structure?
Karen
On Wed, 7 Jul 2010, Slau Halatyn wrote:

Hi Karen,

Avid doesn't do public beta cycles. This is an update to the commercial release 
of Pro Tools 8. The current version is now 8.0.4 and it's accessible with 
VoiceOver.

Best,

Slau

On Jul 7, 2010, at 6:25 PM, Karen Lewellen wrote:

is this another beta edition?
Karen

On Wed, 7 Jul 2010, Slau Halatyn wrote:

http://secure.digidesign.com/services/avid/kb/downloads.cfm?digiArticleId=41974&localeCode=en







Reply via email to