"Anne van Kesteren" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
I don't see why responseText MUST be null other than in readyState 3 or 4, why not undefined (e.g. if the firing of the 2 is delayed for some reason then data could be available) Equally MUST on 3 is incompatible with existing implementations.

It's never null. If the firing of the 2 is delayed, isn't that just a bug?

No, we're not mandating that events fire in realtime - we can't as ES is single threaded etc.

The "MUST on 3" is incompatible with existing implementations in what way?

MS's XHR implementation throws an error on 3.

alert( ) isn't defined anywhere, traditionally print has been used as a dummy function in ES code.

Any pointers of its use?

The ES spec, just changing alert to print...

 by data.xmlEncoding, if specified and supported, or UTF-8 otherwise

Makes some sense to me...

I still don't see the point of the restriction at all, and inputEncoding would be a better option than xmlEncoding - if we're assuming the server knows the best format for a document serialisation, but I don't see the point of requiring such behaviour.

> Responded to this one already. In addition, we now have an open issue on
it.

Cheers!

Jim.

Reply via email to