Maciej Stachowiak wrote:
On Apr 21, 2006, at 9:33 AM, Mark Nottingham wrote:
[ from the big comment e-mail; raising as a separate issue, as
requested ]
The current draft says that:
"If the method is POST or PUT, then the data passed to the send()
method must be used for the entity body."
This doesn't account for other request methods that may have a
request body, e.g., PROPPATCH. Suggested text:
"Any data passed to the send() method MUST be used in the entity
body. If data is passed to send() when it is known to be incorrect
(e.g., in GET, HEAD, and DELETE requests), implementations MUST raise
an error."
Current implementations silently ignore the body in this case. It seems
like a bad idea to change this to raising an exception, since it could
break existing content that blindly sets a body. But it seems ok to
change the requirement to require ignoring the body for a specific list
of methods, instead of allowing it only for a specific list of methods,
so long as this would not allow security holes or violations of the
http spec.
Agreed. Not following the HTTP spec as written now is a bad idea since
it could confuse proxies and servers and thereby causing security issues.
/ Jonas