Aloha,

One of the recommendations in both the Existing 
Roadways Task Partnership Report and the New 
Alternative Corridors Task Partnership report is 
the construction of modern roundabouts at major intersections.

On Thursday, February 22, 2007, a federal highway 
engineer on assignment in Honolulu was the guest 
speaker at the monthly Governor's East Hawai`i 
Advisory Council meeting.    The topic for the 
evening was modern roundabouts.  Enclosed, is an 
article that appeared in the Hawai`i Tribune 
Herald regarding the content of the presentation.

NOTE:  The article states: ""Roundabouts are not 
going to pass the ADA act," he said."  This is 
incorrect information.  What Mr. Worrell said is 
that he 4-lane modern roundabouts "may" not pass the ADA act.


forward!
devotion, prema


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Hawai`i Tribune Herald - Friday, February 23, 2007


FEDERAL EXPERT TOUTS ROUNDABOUTS

But highway engineer wouldn't say whether traffic control would work here

by Peter Sur, Tribune-Herald Staff Writer


KEAAU -- A federal highway engineer touted 
roundabouts as safer and more efficient than the 
stop signs and traffic lights that predominate on Hawaii's roadways.

More than 50 people gathered in the Keaau 
Elementary School cafeteria Thursday night to 
hear Eric Worrell, an engineer with the Hawaii 
Division of the Federal Highways Administration.

Worrell's multimedia presentation, which he said 
he would give to Hawaii Department of 
Transportation officials next week, was heavy on 
technical studies and photographs of roundabouts 
on Oahu, across the United States and in Europe.

During the question-and-answer session after the 
90-minute presentation, the Tribune-Herald asked 
Worrell whether he noticed any Big Island 
intersections that would be suitable for conversion into roundabouts.

"No," he said. "I really haven't looked for 
that." He then said he declined to get involved in the issue.

Some of those in the audience clearly wanted to 
hear about the applicability of roundabouts to 
Highway 130, but Worrell said he wasn't there to 
focus on the traffic-clogged roadway.

Worrell began by identifying what a roundabout is and what it isn't.

A true roundabout, he said, has three criteria:

-- A circular intersection with yield control of all entering traffic

-- Channelized approaches

-- Geometric curvature restricting travel speeds 
on the circular travel area to under 30 mph.

Roundabouts aren't good in all circumstances, 
Worrell pointed out. They won't work when there's 
insufficient space, when the ground isn't flat, 
when there's insufficient line of sight, 
high-speed approaches or traffic loads higher than 40,000 vehicles daily.

On the plus side, Worrell said, once the driving 
public adjusts, the incidents of crashes are 
drastically cut down, capacity is almost doubled 
and head-on collisions are virtually impossible.

Roundabouts, Worrell said, increase capacity 
substantially and reduce traffic delays over 
traditional forms of intersection control.

He acknowledged it is counterintuitive to think 
that roundabouts slow traffic yet increase the 
capacity of vehicles. Worrell said it works 
because while traffic can pass through an 
intersection at 45 mph during a green light, it 
comes to a stop during a red light. In a roundabout, almost nobody stops.

In addition, because everyone is moving in the 
same direction and roughly the same speed, 
collisions that do happen are not serious.

Worrell cited a federal study of 24 intersections 
that were converted into roundabouts. The study 
found a 39 percent decrease in all crashes, a 76 
percent drop in injuries and fatal crashes, and a 
90 percent drop in fatal or incapacitating crashes.

One major drawback for roundabouts that Worrell 
identified was that when traffic never stops, it 
poses a hazard for the visually impaired. He 
suggested possibly installing traffic controls, 
but that would make them cease to become true roundabouts.

"Roundabouts are not going to pass the ADA act," he said.

Public testimony focused on the cost of 
purchasing additional land, and was generally critical of the proposal.

Worrell gave his talk at the monthly meeting of 
the Governor's East Hawaii Council of Advisors. 
Before Chairman Alton Okinaka arrived a few 
minutes late, advisor John Kai noted that "Alton's stuck in traffic."

In 2006, the County Council passed a resolution 
by Councilman Bob Jacobson requesting that the 
county look into the feasibility of roundabouts 
on island intersections. The Big Island has, on a 
per capita basis, the state's deadliest roads.

Peter Sur can be reached at [EMAIL PROTECTED]

###

All rights reserved. Copyright © 2007 Hawaii Tribune Herald.
Content on this site may not be archived, 
retransmitted, saved in a database, or used for 
any commercial purpose without the express 
written permission of Hawaii Tribune Herald.


SOURCE: 
<http://hawaiitribune-herald.com/articles/2007/02/23/local_news/local02.txt>


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
This posting is provided to the individual 
members of this group without permission from the 
copyright owner for purposes of criticism, 
comment, scholarship and research under the "fair 
use" provisions of the Federal copyright laws and 
it may not be distributed further without 
permission of the copyright owner, except for "fair use."



_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to