I think that it is important to make sure that the recommendation by Parsons
Brinckerhoff regarding whether or not the widening of Hwy 130 to 4 lanes
obviates the need for a PMAR is not based solely on the level of service
improvement of Hwy 130 due to widening.  Adequate consideration needs to be
given to the escalating need for redundancy as subdivision build-out
increases.

Larry

-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Prema
Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 3:11 PM
To: Puna WG Evaluation
Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant

----------------------------------------------------
Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER
----------------------------------------------------


.
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:
>
>I think it is important for the transportation 
>subconsultant to focus on the core issues of 
>highway intersections, alternative corridors and 
>interconnectivity, which are the priorities 
>identified by both the Small Group Meetings and 
>the Working Group.  Also, it seems apparent that 
>this will probably require more than the two 
>community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant.
.



Aloha John W,

Agreed.

Highway intersections along BOTH Highway 130* and 
Highway 11*; alternative corridors in BOTH Puna 
Mauka and Puna Makai and interconnectivity 
between subdivisions throughout Upper Puna and 
Lower Puna are core transportation issues in the 
District of Puna.  These issues deserve as much 
time and attention as you can spare in your consultant's budget.

* Reference:  Puna CDP Transportation WG EXISTING ROADWAYS Report
Section:  1.  INTERSECTION SAFETY, Page 4 of 28
Web: 
http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio
n-existing-roadways.pdf/view

Note:  Item 1.a.i.1.d. (Opukahaia Road & Highway 
130) should have been listed under Highway 130 
intersections, instead of Highway 11.


Also, thank you, very much, for including "modern 
roundabouts" in the evaluation process for both 
Highway 130 and the proposed Puna Makai 
alternative corridor.  Please note preferred 
terminology is: "modern roundabouts" not "roundabouts".



forward!
devotion, prema


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:

The overview section and the executive summaries 
of the task partnerships emphasize highway 
intersection controls (especially the use of 
roundabouts as an alternative to signalization) 
and connectivity in the circulation 
system.  These are fundamental needs for 
improving transportation safety and convenience 
for all modes of travel, and for providing 
emergency access and evacuation routes, so the emphasis is appropriate.

There are also many recommendations for enhancing 
multi-modal travel, including transit, bicycling 
and walking.  These are all good objectives, but 
changes to the land development pattern in Puna - 
particularly to create walkable "village centers" 
- will be key to making these ideas a 
reality.  The Land Use Working Group report 
addresses this issue, and we will be following up 
with a pilot study of a portion of Hawaiian 
Paradise Park to look at the feasibility of 
applying "land pooling" as a method to create 
village centers within existing, nonconforming 
subdivisions.  Also, between the Puna Regional 
Circulation Study and the County's recent 
paratransit study there are already significant 
proposed initiatives for multi-modal 
transportation that have yet to be implemented, 
so it would be good to start with those.

Given the above observations, I think it is 
important for the transportation subconsultant to 
focus on the core issues of highway 
intersections, alternative corridors and 
interconnectivity, which are the priorities 
identified by both the Small Group Meetings and 
the Working Group.  Also, it seems apparent that 
this will probably require more than the two 
community meetings described in the original 
scope for this consultant.  Therefore, to keep 
within the budget allotted for this consultant, 
we have revised the scope as follows (with 
additions underscored and deletions noted in 
brackets): 


I.  HIGHWAY 130 AND PUNA MAKAI ALTERNATE ROUTE

A.  Conduct traffic analyses to recommend:

1.   Whether widening Highway 130 from two to 
four lanes obviates the need for the Puna makai alternate route;

2.   If needed, the number of lanes for the Puna 
makai alternate route and whether the Puna makai 
alternate route should continue through Hawaiian Paradise Park;

3.   Evaluate the need and optimal location for 
traffic signals and/or roundabouts along Highway 
130 to enable turning movements from intersecting streets;

4.   If the Puna makai alternate route must 
traverse Hawaiian Paradise Park, recommend 
alignment and context-sensitive design.


B.  Attend at least two public meetings to present findings.


II.  HIGHWAY 11

A.  Evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of 
alternative connectors between Highway 11 and 
Highway 130 to alleviate congestion going to Keaau High School and Pahoa;

B.  Recommended mitigation measures to ease existing and future congestion.


III.  INTERCONNECTIVITY

A.  Evaluate existing street network and 
recommend interconnectivity system and standards.

[Multi-modal and commercial center analyses are omitted.]

    

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to