---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ----------------------------------------------------
NOTE: All references to the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report can be accessed at the following URL: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report Section I. SAFETY: PRIORITY #1 Along Roadways in Puna Page 4 of 28 thru Page 11 of 28 http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-existing-roadways.pdf/view . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >The transportation subconsultant will have additional comments and >suggestions on the recommendations contained in the task group >reports, but below are my observations and questions on the Existing >Roadways section. > >Comments re TR-ER: > >INTERSECTION SAFETY > >Issue #1: Up to 16 intersections are listed as candidates for >roundabouts (preferably) or other form of intersection >control. That's a lot of locations, and the treatment may vary >according to the conditions and opportunities at each >intersection. It will probably be necessary to set some priorities >among the intersections. Also, it would be necessary to build a >strong case for roundabouts on Highway 130 to overcome DOT's >resistance to them (see attached letter.) This is a major reason >for re-focusing the transportation subconsultant's scope of work. . Aloha John W, There were about 125 residents of Lower Puna, who attended the Governor's East Hawai`i Advisory Council meeting, at Maku`u Market, on September 28, 2006. An overwheming majority of citizens testified with regards to TRAFFIC CRASHES and/or TRAFFIC CONGESTION along Highway 130, at the following intersections: + Opukahaia Road & Highway 130 + Shower Drive & Highway 130 + Pohaku Drive & Highway 130 + Kaloli Drive & Highway 130 + Paradise Road & Highway 130 + Orchidland Road & Highway 130 + Maku`u Road & Highway 130 + Ainaloa Road & Highway 130 + Kahakai Blvd. & Highway 130 + Malama Marketplace entrances + Leilani Estates & Highway 130 Some of the comments from the Puna community were documented in the Governor's East Hawai`i Advisory Board meeting minutes for September 28, 2006 LINK: 060928 Governor's East Hawai`i Council of Advisors Meeting Minutes <http://www.hcrc.info/Members/pqadir/state-dot-resistance-to-modern-roundabouts> A community group known as The Action Care Team (ACT) prepared a statement of transportation issues, which were intended for presentation at the meeting, however, due to time constraints, this was not possible. ACT's prepared statements were submitted as public testimony. The attachment that you posted was Mr. Morioka's response to ACT (dated October 10, 2006). LINK: 061010 Response from Brennon Morioka to The Action Care Team <http://www.hcrc.info/Members/pqadir/state-dot-resistance-to-modern-roundabouts>. After receiving Mr. Morioka's reply of October 10, 2006, The Action Care Team responded, as per the following hyperlinks: LINK: 061022 Response to Brennon Morioka from Keola Downing 16KB <http://www.hcrc.info/Members/pqadir/state-dot-resistance-to-modern-roundabouts> LINK: 061026 Response to Brennan Morioka from Tom Lackey 16KB <http://www.hcrc.info/Members/pqadir/state-dot-resistance-to-modern-roundabouts> What was *not* mentioned in the Governor's East Hawai`i Council of Advisors meeting minutes is the fact that a significant number of Puna residents from multiple subdivisions expressed support for the construction of modern roundabouts, instead of signalized traffic intersections, to solve traffic problems, particularly traffic crashes and traffic congestion, at major intersections along Highway 130. I should add that a significant number of these same residents from multiple communities did not know each other or did not discuss modern roundabouts, prior to attending the Governor's East Hawai`i Advisory Council meeting. The idea for constructing modern roundabouts was evident in the collective consciousness as attendees spoke to solving transportation issues in Puna. Another point that did not appear in the meeting minutes was a recommendation from the public that the Federal government provides up to 100% funding for modern roundabouts. Modern Roundabouts are discussed in the Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report, at the following URL. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report Section I. SAFETY: PRIORITY #1 Along Roadways in Puna Page 5 of 28 and Page 6 of 28 http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-existing-roadways.pdf/view FYI, I have also posted files, an image and links related to modern roundabouts at the HCRC.info Website: Modern Roundabouts http://www.hcrc.info/Members/pqadir/modern-roundabouts/ . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >Issue #2: For clarification, was this recommendation meant to refer >to the entrance to Nanawale Estates from Highway 132? . Yes, that is correct. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >ROADWAY SAFETY > >Issue #1: If a vendor is located in a State right-of-way, it's my >understanding County zoning officials lack jurisdiction; however, it >is probably a violation of the traffic code for State highways, so >police officers can issue a summons. I will ask the County to comment on this. . Thank you. Illegal vending is increasingly becoming an issue along Highway 130, as well as the feeder roads. For example, in Hawaiian Paradise Park at Paradise Road and Highway 130 there are vendors selling products during the morning and evening rush hour. On one occasion I witnessed a homemade A-frame sign about 3 feet tall that was placed in the Kea`au-bound shoulder lane of Highway 130. The make-shift sign created a blind spot for vehicles attempting to turn left onto Highway 130. In order to see beyond the make-shift sign, drivers had to pull-up closer to the white line, so that we could see traffic traveling from the Pahoa direction. The placement of the make-shift sign put vehicles at risk of being hit by traffic traveling from the Pahoa direction turning left onto Paradise Road. We've also noticed make-shift signage in front of businesses that are located on Highway 130, especially in the vicinity of Road A at Pahoa town, where business signage competes with State DOT roadway signage for driver attention. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >ROADWAY DESIGN > >Issue #1: The recommendations in this section have statewide >significance and are not likely to get appropriate attention if >included in the CDP. I understand the frustration about lack of >access to data, since I have faced this problem myself in working on >neighborhood plans. I also agree that more study is needed to >identify how hazards associated with roadway design can be >mitigated. However, these suggestions need to be raised in another >type of forum; namely, the State Legislature. These are ideas that >you could bring to your elected State representatives. From an >institutional standpoint, I believe Recommendation #1 refers to the >State of Hawai'i Department of Health, since there is no County >agency with this type of responsibility of title. . The fatalities, injuries and property damage due to traffic crashes in the District of Puna are highly significant to the residents. We would like to see the County of Hawai`i show some aloha for the welfare of its citizenry by taking an active role in addressing the traffic crash issue. In lieu of data that can be provided by the State DOT, we would like to see the County of Hawai`i use whatever resources (including the County Police Department) it has at its disposal to at least establish a reporting system that would reveal the extent to which traffic crashes kill and maim residents and cause property damage. In the same way that the County of Hawai`i maintains a GIS system for tax key mapping, it could establish a GIS system for traffic crash data mapping. forward! devotion, prema _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
