Please see my comments below.
Larry Brown _____ From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of John P. Whalen Sent: Tuesday, March 13, 2007 9:40 PM To: Puna CDP listserve Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] LU-GM Comments and questions re the recommendations: Goal #1 (Prevent population sprawl and scattered development) recommendations: 2nd bullet - Loans and loan guarantees are available to incorporated subdivision owners' associations through the USDA's Rural Community Assistance Corporation. Are you suggesting that an additional funding source be made available, perhaps at the State or County level? If so, I believe the State would be better able to do this than the County because of greater borrowing capacity. This would require State legislation to establish and identify the source of this fund. Most likely, it would be administered by the Hawai'i Housing Finance & Development Corporation (HHFDC). Normally I would suggest that State initiatives be addressed outside the forum of the Puna CDP, but since infrastructure deficiencies in nonconforming subdivisions are such a significant issue in Puna, and this is a condition that is nearly unique to Puna and neighboring Ka'u, I think it is appropriate to include this recommendation in the Puna CDP. To implement it, however, your State legislators need to take the lead. 3rd bullet - There are many larger tracts that could be rezoned to the Ag-20 district, which is the agricultural zoning category in the Hawai'i County Code that requires the largest minimum lot size. I will ask John S. to post a map on the website showing what areas would be affected by this recommendation. Another approach to consider, perhaps in combination with down-zoning, would be Kaua'i County's "one-time subdivision" provision, which allows a property to be subdivided only once. There is also a sliding scale for minimum lot sizes, depending on the size of the original lot area. A-20a is not the County Ag zoning designation with the largest minimum lot size. We do have A-8000a zoning in Hawaii County. There is nothing in the Zoning Code setting a maximum Ag zoning designation. The minimum Ag zoning designation, which applies only to rezoning requests, is A-5a (five acre minimum lot size) 4th bullet - I believe this meant to suggest that "illegal" uses rather than "nonconforming" uses should be prosecuted. "Nonconforming" means that the uses were legal at the time they were established. They are allowed to continue, as long as they don't increase the nonconformity, attempt to replace the use, or discontinue the use for a specified period of time. Goal #2 (Maintain subsurface water quality) recommendations: All bullets - Private wastewater treatment systems and safe drinking water standards are regulated by the State Department of Health (DOH). Several times over the course of decades, the State has proposed to transfer regulatory authority over wastewater systems to the counties, but the counties have resisted because no State funding accompanied the proposed transfer. As long as the authority remains with DOH, there is unlikely to be any change to regulations that reflect conditions specific to Puna. On the other hand, the County is not necessarily precluded from adopting health standards that are more restrictive than those of DOH. An interesting aside: According to DOH sanitary engineers, Hawai'i and Rhode Island are the two states with the largest number of cesspools - also the two with the smallest land mass. 1st & 2nd bullets - Presently, DOH allows cesspools for a single dwelling on a lot that is at least one acre in size. A second dwelling on the lot is required to provide a septic tank. The recommendation to prohibit all new cesspools is not unreasonable from a growth management policy standpoint, although this proposal is likely to encounter political resistance because it will viewed as penalizing affordable housing in the nonconforming subdivisions. Do you have confidence that this recommendation has broad community support? DOH officials say that incidents of cesspool failure or well contamination from cesspools are very rare in Puna. They say that the aquifer "flushes out" the septic waste, diluting the effluent and transporting it to the ocean, where it then dissipates quickly due to the steep drop off of ocean floor off-shore. This is one subject on which "broad community support" may lack validity if there is a lack of accurate information available on what the impacts would be if the build-out of Puna subdivisions proceeds with cesspools being allowed. Cesspool failure or well contamination from cesspools in Puna may also be historically rare due to the relatively sparse development in Puna subdivisions until recent years. What are the likely health and environmental impacts as we approach 30,000+ cesspools and an increasing number of private wells in Puna? 3rd bullet - DOH now prohibits new cesspools within 1,000 feet from the shoreline or below the 100-ft elevation, whichever is the greater distance from the shoreline. This actually covers more land area than the present SMA boundary, so it would be better to retain the present requirement if the intent is to limit the extent of cesspools. Present regulations also prohibit cesspools within a 1,000-ft radius of a community well. There are no regulations protecting the water quality of wells for use by fewer than 25 individuals. Are you suggesting that the distance standard should apply to these smaller wells? If so, it would be difficult to determine their locations, since, in many cases, they were drilled without permits and are therefore not in DLNR's inventory. 4th bullet - Who would prepare this Environmental Assessment - DOH? It could be a long wait before such a study is funded and conducted. For example, DOH engineers have noted that U.S.Soil Conservation Service needs to update its soil maps, which is a key piece of information needed to do a comprehensive assessment. This may be a good argument for "erring on the side of caution" by prohibiting new cesspools. Goal #3 (Maintain high infrastructure standards) recommendations: 1st bullet - I need to check with the County to see whether variances are being granted for new subdivisions, but by law variances must meet the test of hardship, which is a pretty tough standard that allows few exceptions. I'm unclear whether the second part of this recommendation is suggesting that current infrastructure standards should be applied retroactively to a lot less than 5 acres in size in a nonconforming subdivision in order to qualify to build a dwelling on it. If so, this is very unlikely to withstand a legal challenge because it would deny reasonable use of thousands of lots. The Hawaii County Zoning Code does not allow for the approval of a variance that would provide relief from the permitted uses or specified density of parcel. Variances may be granted, and recently have been granted, for relief from the minimum roadway standards, requirement for the availability of County water, minimum lot width, etc. The County does not exercise any authority over private wastewater disposal systems (cesspools, septic systems, etc.) The Subdivision Code does allow for the exemption from the infrastructure and minimum lot size requirement for a consolidation and resubdivision where the action results in the same or fewer number of total lots. 2nd bullet - Is it the intent of this amnesty program to collect property taxes from lots with illegal dwellings or to bring the structures up to code - or both? Goal #4 (Manage highway usage) recommendations: All bullets - These overlap with the Transportation Working Group (TRWG) recommendations, which contain more specific suggestions for these points, so please refer to my comments to TRWG. Goal #5 (Property taxation) recommendations: All bullets - To a planner, these seem like reasonable proposals to promote growth management and agricultural activity. I'm not sure how they will be received by County fiscal staff and policy makers; we'll have to see how this plays. Goal #6 (Industrial use) recommendations: 1st bullet - In describing uses suitable for the different categories of "village center", the LU-VC report includes some that could be characterized as small "service industrial" establishments - e.g., repair shops. Is this what you intended by this recommendation? 3rd bullet - This seems to imply that home occupations should not be permitted, since they are allowed only by Special Permit in agricultural districts. The zoning code already prohibits most industrial-type activities as home occupations. Some activities are in a "grey area", such as artisans' studios or furniture repair shops. To prohibit all uses that could be construed as "industrial" could adversely affect the livelihood of many Puna residents. Goals #7 & 8 - No comments. Goals #9 - (Reduce speculation) recommendations: 1st bullet - This idea has been proposed many times over the years, but the State Legislature has declined to pass the necessary legislation. The issue is not unique to Puna. I think it would be more effective to make this proposal directly to elected State representatives rather than incorporate it into the CDP. I believe a bill has been introduced, with the support of the Governor, this legislative session proposing substantial financial penalties for "flipping" of real estate in Hawaii. 2nd bullet - This could have the unintended result of encouraging more "spec" building for dwellings. Other comments: Did the LU-GM group consider recommending the following? ­ Prior to the sale of any property on which a dwelling could be permitted under County Code, require a disclosure to the prospective buyer that the property lacks access to infrastructure meeting County and State standards for residential use, that neither the County nor the State assume responsibility for bringing the infrastructure up to current standards to serve existing or future residential use of the property, and that the buyer acknowledges and accepts this condition. ­ Limit the lot coverage of dwellings and their accessory uses in all agricultural zones.
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
