Aloha kakou,

 

After making comments on a few of the Working Group reports and receiving
responses to those comments, I would like to explain the purpose and intent
of my "evaluations" to reduce some possible misunderstandings.

 

The reports that I have reviewed thus far have done a good job of
incorporating previous plans and translating previous community input into
goals, objectives and priorities.  I get a sense that all of the Working
Groups have tried diligently to stay true to the sentiments of the broader
community, even though the number of people who were active in the Working
Group process is obviously limited.

 

I have focused my comments on the specific recommendations from the Working
Group reports rather than the goals and objectives because this is where the
hard questions about implementation come up - e.g., proposals that may
conflict with the goals and objectives of other Working Groups, proposals
that have islandwide or state-wide as opposed to just Puna-wide
significance, proposals that may run into legal difficulties, and proposals
that may preclude alternative approaches that could be just as, if not more,
effective in addressing a stated problem.

 

Some of my comments have pointed out jurisdictional issues; for example, a
recommendation calls for State legislation or initiative rather than County
action.  I've also pointed out that some proposals involving institutional
changes would require amendments to the County Charter, or perhaps even in
some cases to the State Constitution.  In those cases, I have suggested that
it would be more effective to pursue those recommendations in a forum other
than the CDP.  Let me be clear, however, that I do not intend to make
unilateral decisions on what should or should not be included in the CDP.
Ultimately, this is a decision that will be made by the County Council,
which is to adopt the CDP.  Prior to that, the draft CDP will be reviewed by
the Steering Committee, the Planning Department and the Planning Commission,
all of which will be open to public comments.  

 

As a consultant, I see my role as providing the best advice I can based on
my experience with similar types of community-based plans in Hawai'i.  Puna
has some significant and unusual challenges due to the growth pattern
established by the nonconforming subdivisions, so the recommendations of the
Working Group reports are understandably ambitious.  I am in complete
sympathy with the goals and objectives set forth in those reports, so I hope
that, collectively, we can find effective ways to implement them.

 

John 

 

PlanPacific, Inc.

345 Queen Street, Suite 802

Honolulu, HI 96813

Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12

 

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to