########################
AG AGRICULTURE
Recommendation 2: These are interesting suggestions, but all of them have island-wide applicability. Proposed changes to the valuation methods for agricultural land would obviously have significant implications for the Countys tax base and revenue stream. The other proposals would probably have lesser fiscal impact. As I mentioned in my posting a few days ago, I will make no unilateral decisions about what should or should not be included in the CDP, but I question whether the CDP should contain such specific proposals of island-wide significance.
First of all, these are recommendations for action, not merely suggestions. Regarding island-wide implications, that is true and is no reason for dismissal of them. In fact, with application of the standard that recommendations with island wide implications will be dismissed, then most of what needs doing here and in the other districts will not get done. Is that the intent? Although I have not followed the CDP process in other districts closely, I am confident that many recommendations coming out of those other districts also have island-wide implications.
Recommendation 3: Im not sure how essential agricultural land corresponds to important agricultural land. The latter (IAL) is defined and mapped in the General Plan. As I read the description in AG-WG report, essential agricultural lands seems to include much more area than IAL. I am not sure how to develop an accurate map of these areas. In any event, intent of the CDP is follow the policy guidance of the General Plan, so I believe the IAL definition prevails unless the General Plan is amended.
Essential agricultural land does cover more than IAL that is the point. The IAL, taken largely from state legislation, is inadequate, excluding, for example, the lava lands in Puna where there are thousands of acres in agricultural production.
As indicated in the report, Essential agricultural land is that which is essential for Hawaii Island agriculture to be capable of supplying local markets
As for your dismissal of essential agricultural lands because the CDP will follow the policy guidance of the General Plan well then, what are we (Puna citizens) supposed to be doing, if not guiding policy, including the General Plan!!! Do you have the order of guidance backwards?
The objective stated in the report is, to decouple the price of essential agricultural land from the price of land dedicated to non-agricultural uses. If this objective is not met in Puna and across the entire island, then very little agriculture will exist on the island in 10 years from now.
Recommendation 4: We are preparing a map that shows what areas would be candidates for rezoning to implement this proposal. I will ask that it be posted on the website. I am unclear how the County would have the legal authority to force the consolidation of two adjoining, existing parcels (Recommendation 4.2.2.) Am I reading this correctly?
You question whether the County has legal authority to force the consolidation of two adjoining, existing parcels (Recommendation 4.2.2.)
The recommendation clearly states that this is to be done through incentive, i.e., voluntary not through force.
Recommendation 5: Do the three proposed locations for farmers markets assume that Makuu will continue in operation? Did the WG have any thoughts about how to leverage private investment in the farmers market sites? Public funds (federal, state, county) could play a part, as well.
No assumptions are made regarding Makuu market.
There are numerous ways to leverage private investment: sponsorship and on-site advertisement by industry (producer associations, retail farm-supply stores, etc); funds for processing food capacity at the market; membership fees; and on and on. There are literally hundreds of examples of successful modern farmers markets in the USA and other countries, to draw upon in finding ways for the private sector to invest in farmers markets.
The main point is that public money be spent for the basic infrastructure, perhaps (or not) the land, and cooperation in zoning. That opens the way for private investment.
Recommendation 6 & 7: These are worthy proposals, but the State is a more appropriate source of funding than the County because it has a much larger tax base and is directly responsible for supporting agricultural development and providing agricultural education and extension services.
Yes the State has a direct responsibility for supporting agricultural development and providing agricultural education and extension services. However, that does not provide the County with an excuse to do nothing. We must absolutely must! be willing to do things differently.
If the State was sufficiently addressing the issue of training agriculturalists in Puna (and other rural areas on the island), then we would not need to make this recommendation! As is clearly stated in the report, the intent is to leverage Federal, State, and private money with a relatively small amount of County funding.
....
As a general point, John, it seems you are over-eager to dismiss the recommendations; and to do so without any reference to the clearly stated issues and situations presented, and the objectives for which the recommendations are made. Perhaps this is only my own narrow take, but please do give some consideration to being more open minded. Thanks.
....
James Weatherford, Ph.D.
Áina Maikaí Ranch
19-4260 Alanui Iiwi (P.O. Box 69)
Volcano, HI 96785
Tel: 1-808-967-7357 (h); 967-8579 (o); 345-9422 (cell)
Fax: 1-808-967-8525
e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] (h); [EMAIL PROTECTED] (o)
http://www.volcanologist.com
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
