aloha all,
Once an old growth ohia forest is dozed it is gone. There is no way to have
it replanted in a way that will compensate those living now or over the next
few generations. I believe that replanting is an must. As far as a minimum
regrowth period before allowing development, who can say what that will be.
If the grove takin out in 400 years old, Will 100 years be acceptable as a
regrowth period? Maybe? Whatever the "period " is, the penalty should be so
severe that mismanagament of natural resources would hopefully disappear. We
are all accountable for abiding by laws. Opps, sorry judge I didn't know i
was violating the law probably won't cut it in court. I think that including
NR protection in the PCDP is as important an issue as evaculation safety
measures and connectivity routes.

John do you happen to know what the penalty imposed would be if a developer
on the perimeter of sequoia national park accidentally took out, say, a 1/4
acre of trees? I'm curious?

be well,
Stephanie Bath
On 3/27/07, [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

 Dear Land, Air, and Water Friends and PCDP Steering Committee,

Below are comments from John Whalen to the Preserving Land, Air, and Water
subgroup report. Having requested input from those who contributed to the
report, we are now asking others if they have comments to add to the PLAW
response.

1. Recommendations for Actions During PCDP Process:  The PLAW report asks
for immediate action in several areas; John Whalen responded that he assumed
these recommednations were directed to the Planning Department and the
County Council.

*PLAW Request*: The PCDP Steering Committee to communicate with the
Planning Department and County Council re viable recommendations from PLAW
and other WGs requesting amendments to existing land use regulations prior
to adopton of the PCDP.

2. Recommendation IV.A. (Scenic Corridors):  No one has resonded to John's
query re: specific scenic corridors, other than Highway 137.

*3.* Recommendation IV.B. (Highway 137, Kaimu-Kapoho Road; response from
Bettie Van Overbeke):  The 15 foot easement is a planting easement from
the road. The road is only a 40 foot easement  and lots are small . There
isn't room for more than 15 feet in the platted subdivisions. Bettie's house
is only 20 feet off the road but tolerable due to cococut  plantings. Bettie
recommends keeping the tree tunnels of mangos, coconuts, kamanis that are in
situ, not to cut them down and plant ohias. Fences and walls were not
referenced in the recommendation, as both are hardscape not plantings. We
made the planting easement voluntary as some people prefer walls to plants.

4. Recommendation IV.C. (Various):  John Whalen commented that,
re: penalties for grading violations, "*It might be more effective to
require the owner to restore the site to original condition by replanting
and establishing a minimum regrowth period before allowing any additional
development.  State law enables counties to impose a lien on the property
and deny licenses in the case of egregious violations or prolonged
noncompliance. " Does anyone have a response for John's query?*

*Whalen Responses to **Preserving Land, Air, and Water Subgroup Report *

*Recommendations for Actions During PCDP Process:  *I take it that these
recommendations are directed to the Planning Department and the County
Council, since they precede the preparation and adoption of the CDP.

*Recommendation IV.A. (Scenic Corridors):  *The tie-in with existing codes
is a good idea, since it makes this proposal more likely to be implemented.
*Has the WG identified specific scenic corridors in Puna to which this
would apply?  Highway 137 is mentioned in the following section, but are
there other corridors?*

*Recommendation IV.B. (Highway 137, Kaimu-Kapoho Road): * *Is the 15-ft
easement in addition to standard front yard setback requirements? Is this
meant to apply to both sides of the road?  Is it the intent to leave just
the properties (or portions of them) makai of the highway unfenced?  *

*Recommendation IV.C. (Various):  *Most of these recommendations appear to
link to other WG reports.  Just a comment on the penalties for grading
violations: *It might be more effective to require the owner to restore
the site to original condition by replanting and establishing a minimum
regrowth period before allowing any additional development.  State law
enables counties to impose a lien on the property and deny licenses in the
case of egregious violations or prolonged noncompliance. *



------------------------------
AOL now offers free email to everyone. Find out more about what's free
from AOL at *AOL.com* <http://www.aol.com?ncid=AOLAOF00020000000339>.

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to