Aloha All, Regarding comments by John Whalen, I have the following responses:
LU-PR re: "Recommendations for Actions During PCDP Process", I will suggest to the steering committee that we agendize this item. Some of the details will be included in the proposed letter to the County Council on zoning & subdividing pause. I will send out a draft letter prior to the next steering meeting, and I encourage feedback and other items for inclusion, etc. The steering committe can finalize the draft if necessary, and then the letter can go. re: "Recommendation IV.A. (Scenic Corridors)" I have posted Bill 231 "Scenic Corridors" to the NRWG FILES BILLS folder. If you want a direct mailing of this file, contact me. I got it from Bob Jacobson, who is supporting this bill. It has passed 2nd & final reading, and there is a pending motion by Mr. Pilago and seconded by Bob, to approve it (March 9, 2007). Anyone interested in how to implement the bill, might want to contact Bob J. for more information. re: IV.C (Various): Bulldozer errors: Penalties such as re-planting don't solve the problem. First, there are not enough plant-sellers for all the mistakes going on, and next, re-planting once the soil is gone will be difficult, even if the plants are availble. So mandating an impossible task will result in guaranteed penalties, and fines won't bring the forest back either. There must be a way to prevent the destruction rather than demanding it be re-grown. Demanding re-planting won't help the person who's property got dozed becasue the owner didn't have a certified surveyor find the pins and/or the clearing area to make sure it is their land. I can keep going, but I won't (for now). Thanks for the opportunity to respond, Kim (more tomorrow!) --- "John P. Whalen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > LU-PR > > > > Recommendations for Actions During PCDP Process: I > take it that these > recommendations are directed to the Planning > Department and the County > Council, since they precede the preparation and > adoption of the CDP. > > > > Recommendation IV.A. (Scenic Corridors): The tie-in > with existing codes is > a good idea, since it makes this proposal more > likely to be implemented. > Has the WG identified specific scenic corridors in > Puna to which this would > apply? Highway 137 is mentioned in the following > section, but are there > other corridors? > > > > Recommendation IV.B. (Highway 137, Kaimu-Kapoho > Road): Is the 15-ft > easement in addition to standard front yard setback > requirements? Is this > meant to apply to both sides of the road? Is it the > intent to leave just > the properties (or portions of them) makai of the > highway unfenced? > > > > Recommendation IV.C. (Various): Most of these > recommendations appear to > link to other WG reports. Just a comment on the > penalties for grading > violations: It might be more effective to require > the owner to restore the > site to original condition by replanting and > establishing a minimum regrowth > period before allowing any additional development. > State law enables > counties to impose a lien on the property and deny > licenses in the case of > egregious violations or prolonged noncompliance. > > > > LU-BR > > > > Overall comment: The supporting rationale is well > documented and the goals, > objectives and recommendations in your proposal are > quite clear and > specific. > > > > I note some good changes from an earlier draft of > this proposal, but would > like to reiterate the following comments with > respect to implementation: > > > > 1. Creation of the Advisory Commission having > authority to make binding > decisions would probably require an amendment to the > County Charter. If so, > this would take longer than a year to establish this > Commission. Also, it > may not be legally permissible for the County > Council to adopt a CDP > ordinance containing a provision whose > implementation is dependent on a > Charter amendment, which must be approved by the > electorate. It may be more > practical to keep the Commission an advisory body > within the scope of the > present County Charter. I would expect that the > Commission's > recommendations would carry a lot of weight with the > Planning Director, if > the members are well-qualified and credible. > > > > 2. You might want to think about being a little less > specific on some items. > For example, I don't think it is necessary to > specify the amount of the fine > or the maximum width of a permitted driveway. > Enforcement provisions can be > contained in the implementing ordinance or within > the administrative > provisions of the zone code. > > > > > > PlanPacific, Inc. > > 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 > > Honolulu, HI 96813 > > Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12 > > > > > _______________________________________________ > Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation > ____________________________________________________________________________________ No need to miss a message. Get email on-the-go with Yahoo! Mail for Mobile. Get started. http://mobile.yahoo.com/mail _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
