I agree with Hannah and Kim in their take on the need for the Puna
CDP process to move forward rather than focusing on this need to
constantly "beat the bushes" for more public input.
With all due respect to the ideals of public inclusion and
transparency in the process, what I saw happening in the working
groups and the online discourse following up the WG reports
demonstrate that those ideals are being met. It is up to the public,
including those members of the public who have accepted certain
responsibilities as Steering Committee representatives, Working Group
members, etc. to use the tools providing the transparency to keep
abreast of the Puna CDP's working edge (currently in the hands of the
SC) and keep it moving forward.
Frankly, I was surprised at Thursday's meeting to realize that most
of the SC members had not read the reports that were on the agenda. I
had not been asked to make a presentation...it was only the courtesy
of an email from Larry Brown alerting me to the fact that the Mass
Transit report was up for discussion that evening that got me there.
I merely expected to be answering questions about the details of the
report, or explaining concepts that weren't clear. Thursday's meeting
felt like a rerun of our WG sessions. Redundant, redundant, redundant!
The reports synthesized immense amounts of input and information, and
gave specific, prioritized recommendations that were voted on in our
meetings. The Mass Transit report represents consensus, not special
interests. That was what we were told the WG reports were supposed to
do. We even met our deadline! Please read the reports; they speak for
themselves. And the appendices list the incredible pyramid of sources
reviewed and reflected in the reports' findings. People need to
realize their individual comment or request is probably not going to
be found in the report itself; that's what the appendices are full of
and that's why I brought a box full of things from the Mass Transit
appendix to the meeting. For those who need documentation of all the
input, etc., Prema, Keola and I each have the working posters, notes,
papers, etc. that show the process as we went through it, complete
with attendance at the meetings, vote counts and prioritizing.
In regards to my comments about the Mass Transit director, I
apologize to those who felt I was attacking him. But it is very hard
to discuss anything to do with Mass Transit in Hawaii County without
mentioning Tom Brown. He has been doing his job (a civil service
position) since 1980 and he has a grand total of five staffers, which
includes his mechanics. So it is pretty much a one-man show! In
several places in the report, we acknowledge the improved bus
services of the past five years or so but as the report points out,
current services fall far below what many sectors of our community
expect from Mass Transit.
Re: Kim's comment about "the big decisions are being danced around,
and rightly so, for now, since LAND USE has not been discussed. We
should be working out the landscape FIRST, and then figuring out
where those beautiful multifunctional routes will be. Why isn't this
happening? I need a real answer. For example, "Here are the facts:
this is what is already in progress and why ..., this is what has
already been approved, but not yet funded, this is where community
centers are located and their development status, here are paved
roads, here are not... and this is what we have to work with." Now
where do we want the schools, hospitals, community centers, public
buildings, commercial and industrial centers in Puna?
Okay, GREAT! NOW lets talk about where the roads, bus terminals and
whatever else about transportation, should be.
I agree with the need for Land Use issues to be decided before many
big-ticket decisions can be justified and made. But there are SOME
MIGHTY IMPORTANT ISSUES that need to be taken up immediately to
provide relief for Puna's populace...highway safety, community
connectivity, economic and educational opportunities, these need long
range planning, for sure, but there are some things that can be done
in a more immediate future to respond to needs in those areas. So
what I see missing from this process is a discussion of short-term
objectives, a midrange timetable, and the long-term vision in EACH of
the 12 group topics. And I would respectfully ask the Steering
Committee to consider giving us feedback on the shortterm
recommendations that came out of the Transportation WG. I do not
understand the need for more public meetings in May on
transportation...just about everything's been listed and researched
and pondered. I agree with Kim and Hannah that this process needs to
move on.
Thanks for considering my comments! Aloha, Frankie Stapleton
On Apr 21, 2007, at 12:57 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I commend all PCDP participants for staying with this process.
While I believe we should continue to reach out to groups and
individuals, I hope we recognize the tremendous success of outreach
efforts thus far and the heroic efforts of volunteers and public
employees to respect, capture, and organize input.
As someone who has been involved from the initial "visioning"
sessions, (1) through the facilitator training process to collect
more "visions," (2) through the formation of work groups, (3)
through dozens of community meetings, (4) through struggles to get
participation in the work groups, (5) through varied efforts to get
input into reports/recommendations and to get the reports written,
and (6) through the ongoing struggles of Steering Committee members
to understand their roles, responsibilities, and processes , I
strongly agree with Kim Tavares' comment in her response to Rob
Tucker that this "next round of input" must include "exact points
Planning wants to resolve."
My concern is that we are continuing to send the message that every
individual "idea" and "concern" submitted from the beginning and
throughout the process will be reflected in the final PCDP and the
resultant "laws." I have spoken with several people and groups who
participated early on who are interested in seeing only if "their"
exact submitted wording is reflected. This belief is perpetuated
when we keep giving so much importance to the input in the initial
meetings instead of building on it. Many of those early (and later)
comments reflect self-serving or wishful "my backyard" suggestions
rather than contributions to what is good for all components of the
plan. Early responders did not even know what those components
would be.
I believe communications should emphasize that the "vision" process
has been completed and we are now examining (1) WHAT EXISTS, (2)
WHAT IS IN CURRENT PLANNING DOCUMENTS, and (3)HOW COMMUNITY MEMBERS
CAN CONTRIBUTE TO A PCDP THAT SERVES AS A VIABLE BLUEPRINT FOR
CURRENT AND FUTURE ACTIVITIES.
I encourage us to consider options for facilitiating participation
by existing and new contributors, such as providing transportation
from designated sites to the May 18 and 19 meetings as well as to
future meetings. I don't agree with Rob's suggestion that we pay
people to fill out questionnaires unless this is done as a "focus
group" effort. Otherwise, the people developing, handing out,
administering, and/or paying for the questionnaires can
inadvertantly influence what people say.
Again, thanks to everyone reading this emai. Hand in there.
Hannah Hedrick, COPD Connections, Preserving Land, Air, and Water
subgroup
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation