Hi Fran,  

Thanks for your input!  It's refresing to hear some
new good ideas!  You make some important points, for
sure.  

We're looking at what can help lift the problems
people are having right now with transporation, and
then as we look at future land use, (where schools,
other infrastructure things, will/could go), then some
of your bigger ideas will make a whole lot of sense!

Sincerely,
Kim


>>> forwarded from Fran Harriman: >>>

Hi Kim, and all,

For those who don't know me, I'm orignally from Maine,
a 10 year resident of Fern Forest, and a senior
citizen.

Yes, a survay on the different issues would be an
excellent idea, and should be made available at the
various community/convenience stores like J Hara's and
Hirano's, for instance. A lot of people would be more
likly to see and pick them up. I would also suggest a
numbering system, on the printed surveys, applicable
to a given area, ie, one series of #s for Rt 130 and
another series for communities along RT 11, for
instance, to help identify problems and potential
solutions in specific areas, that might get "lost" in
an overall survey result, without identifiable areas. 
Would also give an indication of what participation in
any future surveys would be, in various areas. .
 
Transportation-wise.....yes, Kim I'm back, on the
potential long-range efficency of trolleys, rather
than busses, on longer and permanent routes!. 
The price of fuel has already affected my travel to
Hilo, and my car gets 40mpg. This will, over time,
increase the fares on busses, or require County budget
allotments to keep the fares to a level that will
support a growing numbers of riders.   

Fuel generation costs will also cause a rise for any
transportation system, train, bus or trolley, unless
alternative sources are more fully developed, but that
will have to happen anyway, at some point, because
less reliance will be needed on fossil fuel sources,
on cost and availability issues, alone.
 
Having grown up with trolleys, I want you to be made
aware that they can run with two, or even three
attached cars, depending on the grade of any hills,
and weight involved..  Therefor, at pau hana time, an
extra car could be added for the heavier need.  On
some runs, an attached  "baggage-type" (closed) car
could deliver and pick up mail at Post Offices, and/or
deliver goods to local convenience stores, thereby
cutting a percentage of  delivery routes now done by
truck. Yes, an additional employee would have to ride
that car, in order to validate delivery and pickups. 
There would be no public access to those cars.
Trolleys  made hills comparable to the one on  Hwy 11,
above Hirano's, even in the winter, unless some kids
decided to grease the tracks, that is!

If done in increments, say a "test project" from
Prince Kuhio, to downtown shops, running.down 11, and
along Hwy 19, would allow tourists at the hotels, to
easily visit both areas, and residents to get to
Prince Kuhio or other businesses along that route,
without a car.  Or a longer run, to HPP on Hwy 130, or
up to J Hara's on Hwy 11 would establish the level of
interest of outlying communities, and a cost
comparison to running such a system, to the present
bus and personal car method, and effects on those
overall upgrade costs involved.  Expansion of a
successful trial, could then be done in increments. 

Ten to 15 mile routes, or more,  were common in Maine,
connecting outlying towns to the city, until after
WW2. Busses were cited as "better" for flexibility in
routing. (The busses ran the same routes as the
trolleys did...still do, to my knowlege, but the old
tracks were tarred over in the city..)  Our town,
population 6000, in the 1950s, had one such trolley,
with a multi-time schedule.. Then,the transfer to bus
routes began. There is presently no bus route
available in my hometown, as costs and fares
skyrocketed.  Bus schedules, then routes, were cut in
the late 1960s/early70s. Today, my hometown, of over
13,000 residents, is forced to rely on personal cars.
One plus, of such a system, would reduce traffic on
the highways, fossil fuel consuption, and potentially
cut accidents, injuries and deaths, at least during
hours of operation.  For instance, the Metro in DC, 
runs a last train to Rockville MD at 10:30PM, and the
earliest train at about 5:30 AM, allowing workers, who
have odd shifts, to still use the Metro. There, it
runs at 1/2 hour intervals, not feasible here, yet.  

The drawback, to such a trolley system, would be the
initial expense of laying track and a separate
poleline to power it,. plus the initial cost of cars,
perhaps modified subway cars. Such lines, and tracks
would parallel the road, just off the shoulder, and
unless heavily scheduled, would require only one
track, say on Hwy 130, or Hwy 11, similar to the
single lanes now on most roads, that will require
widening for vehicle traffic, quite soon, by the
changes I have noted, recently. Long run trolley
schedules, such as to Volcano, would be limited by the
time required to run the route with a single trolley,
although runs could be sectioned, such as Volcano to
Mountain View and return, with another from there to
Keauu/Hilo, and return.. A system of "transfers",
issued on the original route, would allow riders to
change from one form of transportation or route, to
the another.  Smaller scheduled busses or vans, with
more fuel efficency, could be used for populated
areas, where route changes, over time, would be
necessary, due to population increases.... such as
city residential areas and subdivisions.

Power to run such a system, of course,  is another
aspect, however. Hawaii has alternative sources of
power generation already, such as wind, solar, and
geo-thermal.  Additional generation, such as a tidal
project, east and west HI, designed for expected
increased sealevels, would also provide an alternative
to fossil fuels, thereby reducing the need for them. A
long range plan, initially expensive, yet, barring
lava flow, washouts or earthquake,  as permanent as a
road system is, today, and probably less expensive to
repair.  
 
So, having a memory of the "old days", I offer this as
a potential solution, long forgotten.

Fran Harriman.  
 
 .

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to