Aloha,
I just want to remind everyone about what we were told about the CDP
process, following submittal of our Puna CDP WG Final Reports (enclosed).
forward!
devotion, prema
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
CRITERIA AND PROCESS
FOR REVIEW AND EVALUATION OF WORKING GROUP REPORTS
It is anticipated that reports from Working Groups are likely to vary
in terms of their thoroughness in addressing the topic; format and
expression of goals, objectives and recommendations; appropriateness
and relevance of the recommendations for a policy-type public
document; and degree to which the recommendations appear to reflect
broad community participation and support. It is also probable that
there will be some overlap between the recommendations of the Working Groups.
The purpose of reviewing and evaluating the Working Group reports is
suggest to the Steering Committee and the Planning Department a
"common denominator" for the Working Group reports, so that all
topics are adequately covered; redundancies and conflicts are
identified; there is consistency in format, expression and
terminology; and the linkage of recommendations to public involvement
is clear.
The criteria for evaluating the reports are based on the modified
guidelines that were distributed to the Working Groups on December
14, 2006. The failure to address any of the criteria in the Working
Group reports will not necessarily result in the omission of the
recommendations by a Working Group.
REVIEW CRITERIA
1. Statement of Goals and Objectives
- Are they provided?
- Do they cover the topic comprehensively?
- Do they provide a clear basis for the recommendations?
2. Recommendations
- Are they listed in order of priority?
- Are they clear enough to understand? If they are
location-specific, is a map provided or otherwise referenced?
- Do any of the recommendations overlap or conflict with
those of another Working Group?
- Is there any significant issue relevant to the topic,
based on past plans and previous public participations, that appears
to be overlooked in the recommendations?
3. Relationship to Previous Plans and Public Involvement (Where
the WG report does not address the following items the Consultant
will provide comments)
- How do the recommendations relate to the 2005 General
Plan and other previously written plans?
- How does they relate to public input received in the CDP process?
- What potential obstacles exist for implementing the recommendation?
- Who should be primarily responsible for carrying out the
recommendation?
4. Meeting Record
- How complete were the Working Group's meeting records?
- How many meetings were held, and how well attended were they?
- What does the number of attendees and meeting locations
suggest about the breadth of participation in the Working Group
throughout the district?
- If Working Group members communicated largely via e-mail,
was a log kept of the correspondence?
REVIEW AND EVALUATION PROCESS
The evaluation will be an iterative process primarily between the
Working Groups and the Consultant. The Working Groups shall submit
their reports to the Consultant, the Steering Committee and the
Planning Department.
The Consultant's review and evaluation process may require
communications between the Consultant and the Working Group
Coordinator to ensure that the Consultant has a clear understanding
of the Working Group recommendations, their purpose and intent. The
Consultant will give the Working Group Coordinator the notes from his
review and suggest some possible revisions and/or additions to the
report for the Working Group to consider. The Working Group will be
asked to respond to the Consultant's comments and recommendations
within three weeks.
The Steering Committee may review, evaluate, and receive public input
on the Working Group reports. The Steering Committee may also
communicate with the Working Groups via the Working Group Coordinator
to obtain clarification on the Working Group recommendations, their
purpose and intent. Any comments, recommendations or additional
public input on the raw Working Group reports that the Steering
Committee wishes to submit to the Consultant shall be due at the same
time as the response for each Working Group to the Consultant's
comments and recommendations.
In order to preserve the Working Group review and evaluation process
for the record all communications between the Consultant, Working
Group Coordinators and Steering Committee shall be by email via a
listserv created and managed by the HawaiiIslandPlan website manager,
John Schinnerer. John will subscribe all Working Group Coordinators,
Steering Committee Members, PlanPacific, Inc. staff and the Planning
Department project coordinator to the listserv. This will ensure
that all email correspondence in this process is copied to all
Steering Committee Members, Working Group Coordinators, the
Consultant and the Planning Department project coordinator. The
subject line in each email correspondence shall identify to whom the
email is directed and the WG subject matter.
Whether or not the Working Group responds to the Consultant's
comments and recommendations in the allotted time, the Consultant
will present the formatted (original or amended) Working Group report
to the Steering Committee with his recommendations within six weeks
of receiving the original Working Group reports.
The Steering Committee shall review the formatted Working Group
reports and the Consultant's recommendations according to the roles
and responsibilities of the Steering Committee as provided in the
Puna Community Development Plan Steering Committee Roles,
Responsibilities, and Procedural Guidelines previously
distributed. Comments and recommendations by the Steering Committee
on the formatted Working Group reports and the Consultant's
recommendation shall be made to the Consultant and copied to the
Planning Department project coordinator in as timely a manner as
reasonably practical so as not to unnecessarily delay the development
of the CDP.
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation