Aloha kakou,

Kim makes a good point about the need to put land use planning ahead of 
transportation.  This is why I have deliberately organized the sequence of 
presentations to the Steering Committee at its July through August meetings to 
lead with the subject of growth management, then protection of natural/cultural 
resources, and finally transportation/energy.  Planning for roadways should not 
drive the CDP.  It is unavoidable that the present cluster of public meetings 
will focus on roadways and connections because that‛s the subject matter at 
hand.  But this should not distract us from the really big issue in Puna, which 
is how to shape and manage the growth pattern that is implied in the template 
of the nonconforming subdivisions in a manner that steers away from the 
widespread destruction of natural/cultural resources and ever greater 
dependence on automobile/truck/SUV travel.  At least, that‛s what I think the 
Small Group and Working Group process has been telling us. 

John Whalen 

-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Kim Tavares
Sent: Saturday, May 19, 2007 1:25 PM
To: Rob Tucker; Dwight Stevens; Robin Wright; Elin Sand; Pat Conent; Hannah 
Hedrick; Skip Bethea; David Fukumoto; Athena Peanut; Marissa Furfaro; Cathi 
Lux; Judy Stenger; Jeff Lux; Jo Anne Backman; Kent Killam; Christine Mingo; Sue 
Heinz; Jonathan Kawamura; Barbara Kahn-Langer; Pete Adams; Sara Burgess; Erica 
Johnson; Star Newland; Bettie Van Overbeke; Bill Walter; Rick Warshauer
Cc: Bob Jacobson; Wyatt Lotz; [email protected]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; Paul Banko; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] PCDP Working group feedback

Hi Rob, All,

My first impression of the transportation presentation
REVIEW was that it seems that planners are still
looking for more input, and not yet ready to lay out
any solid plans (that we can massacre).  

But that is actually what's happening now.  I listened
to the full presentation last night, with
comments/questions from the audience in Volcano.  If
you can attend one of today's meetings, it's highly
recommended.  

Rather than focusing on the process, provide the Wayne
with useful comments.  He is summarizing the PRCP,
PCDP, old CDP's, STIP and all the other products on
the Hawaii Island Plan Puna website, and analyzing
them from a non-stakeholder's perspective (we assume),
and presenting his interpretation of what they are
saying.  

We are being promised that in the near future, he will
come back to present us with various options, models
that will include a variety of cause/reaction
scenarios that we will have to think over, and then
sink our scissors into.

My personal take on it is that it seems to be a
reasonable approach to resolving some traffic, but it
scares me to death to see that this process (LAND USE
PLANNING) actually IS being driven by transportation
planning, WHICH IS EXACTLY THE OPPOSITE OF WHAT SHOULD
BE OCCURRING.

We are not going to fix traffic problems, by building
or improving the roads.  All that will do is
accommodate more traffic, and it will come.  Someone
said that last night, and I totally agree.   

CONNECTIVITY, another issue that always comes up, is
another that always prompts me to comment. I think it
is vitally important to have connectivity, to serve as
emergency access routes and to provide off highway
alternatives to various locations.  But in upper Puna,
so many of those locations are not yet defined. 
Potential links are proposed in many places, but they
don't go anywhere.  I firmly believe we should decide
what we want and where it goes first.  Otherwise,
improved roads will make those decisions for us, and
we get what we get.  

Nobody wants to go to town all the time, but there are
no other alternatives right now.  

We need to answer the questions “What are we trying to
connect, and for what purpose?”  and,  “What does 
upper Puna need to stop contributing to daily traffic
loads on the highway to Keaau and Hilo?”

1. More elementary schools/day care centers
2. A small high-school/night-school/community college
campus
3. More community offices, and a large community
gathering space, county services 
4. Medical clinics or emergency care facilities
5. Indoors & outdoors recreation facilities
6. Financial institutions

To make this happen, I suggest we make our NEEDS our
economic base, and our public centers are the hubs for
connectivity.   Where do we put all this stuff, and
make it somewhat low-impact?  I have some ideas, and
the Volcano Health folks are also looking around, but
I’d like to hear some of yours too!

Thanks,
Kim





--- Rob Tucker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> Aloha to all of you on the Land Use Working Group.
> 
> John Whalen of Plan Pacific, the consultant on the
> CDP, has delivered a 
> summary and comment on most, but not all, of the WG
> reports.
> 
> I am attaching the summary here for your reading
> enjoyment.  It is 38 
> pages and I thought it rather well organized.
> 
> I attended the May 17th Steering Committee meeting
> which included a 
> presentation by a transportation consultant hired by
> the county.
> Personally I thought him particularly uninformed on
> the Puna CDP and I 
> left the meeting after he took some long amount of
> time explaining that 
> the key issues were the key issues.  I sensed a
> consultant, raised and 
> bred in conventional highway development, who is
> there to tell and not 
> listen.  I hope I am wrong.
> 
> Mahalo,
> 
> Rob
> 
> 
> 



      
____________________________________________________________________________________Fussy?
 Opinionated? Impossible to please? Perfect.  Join Yahoo!'s user panel and lay 
it on us. http://surveylink.yahoo.com/gmrs/yahoo_panel_invite.asp?a=7 

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to