+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Posted on: Sunday, March 13, 2005

COMMENTARY

LAW CREATED TO 'PROTECT PEOPLE'S RIGHT TO KNOW'

By Jon M. Van Dyke

Hawai'i's Sunshine Law was enacted in 1975 to ensure that the public 
has access to the meetings and documents of all state and county 
boards, commissions and legislative bodies (except for the 
Legislature, which operates under its own rules). Governmental 
agencies frequently view the requirements of the Sunshine Law as 
awkward and cumbersome, but they have learned to live with the law 
and operate in accordance with it. This law has truly opened up our 
governmental agencies and allowed citizens to monitor their work and 
have input into their decisions.

Over the years, some awkward situations have occurred. On Maui, 
community activist Jim Smith challenged the way Maui's governmental 
bodies were operating, particularly during the late 1990s. After much 
discussion, I was brought in to serve as consultant for the Maui 
Circuit Court and prepared a report for the court, which was later 
published in the University of Hawai'i Law Review in the Winter 2003 
issue. This report summarized the key elements of the Sunshine Law as follows:

The Sunshine Law is designed "to protect the people's right to know," 
and also to allow citizens to have input into decision-making. 
Hawai'i's Intermediate Court of Appeals has explained that "the 
Sunshine Law is intended to foster transparency in the formation and 
conduct of public policy by opening up the governmental processes to 
public scrutiny and participation," and Hawai'i's courts have said 
repeatedly that the Sunshine Law is to be "liberally construed," and 
that doubts are to be resolved in favor of greater openness.

The Sunshine Law guarantees the public's right to know when 
government bodies meet, to be informed in advance of what business 
these bodies intend to conduct, to attend these meetings and to 
obtain their minutes in a timely manner. All "interested persons" 
must be permitted to present written and oral testimony on all agenda 
items. Each body can adopt rules to "provide for reasonable 
administration of oral testimony," and many bodies limit public 
testimony to three minutes per agenda item, with the opportunity to 
return for further testimony after everyone else has testified. 
Boards cannot delegate to a committee the responsibility of hearing 
public testimony but must be available to hear such testimony 
directly itself, with a quorum of members present.

A "meeting" is defined as "the convening of a board for which a 
quorum is required in order to make a decision or to deliberate 
toward a decision upon which a matter over which the board has 
supervision, control, jurisdiction, or advisory power." The attorney 
general has, for instance, given the opinion that a "retreat" planned 
by the trustees of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs to take place after 
its formal board meeting in order to "resolve personality conflicts" 
and discuss OHA's goals would have been a "meeting" that would have 
had to comply with the Sunshine Law.

Board members are prohibited from engaging in any deliberations with 
each other outside formal meetings and are specifically prohibited 
from discussing how they will vote except in properly noticed 
meetings. But two board members can communicate with each other to 
"gather information from each other about official board matters to 
enable them to perform their duties faithfully, as long as no 
commitment to vote is made or sought." A board member who missed a 
meeting would be permitted, for instance, to contact another board 
member by phone to learn what had happened at the missed meeting. But 
an inquiry such as "How do you feel about that matter?" would be 
improper, as would any attempt by either member to try to influence 
the opinion of the other.

Six calendar days in advance of each meeting, an agenda for the 
meeting must be posted at the site of the meeting, filed with the 
county clerk and mailed to people who request such notices. The 
posted agenda must list the "items to be considered" with 
particularity, in order to give the public sufficient notice to make 
an informed decision regarding attendance and participation. The 
"agenda" is the written list of each and every item proposed to be 
considered for deliberation and action at a meeting of the board, 
listed in the order in which the items will be considered.

The attorney general concluded that a published agenda containing 
only general references, such as "unfinished business" and "new 
business," is insufficient to comply with the law, and that a board 
must list "all of the specific 'items' or 'matters' that will be 
discussed" at its meeting. Executive or closed sessions should be 
noticed in advance if they are anticipated, and the purposes for such 
executive sessions should be provided to the public. Changes to the 
agenda cannot be made without a two-thirds vote of the board members.

Boards, commissions and legislative bodies should be practical in 
setting their agenda and should list only the number of items that 
they think they can realistically complete during their scheduled 
meeting. But it nonetheless sometimes occurs that a body fails to 
complete action on all the agenda items listed for a meeting by the 
end of the day. It is logical to allow these difficult meetings to be 
recessed until the following day or until a day in the very near 
future. But if the continuation is put off more than five days, then 
the full notice requirements of the Sunshine Act, as explained above, 
should be complied with, a new agenda should be posted, and 
additional public testimony must be allowed.

Minutes must be kept and copies must be made available to the public 
at a "reasonable cost of reproducing such copy." The minutes must be 
produced within 30 days after the meeting, unless all or part of the 
meeting was closed to the public, and in those situations the minutes 
of the closed portions must be produced as soon as the need for the 
closure disappears. The law does not authorize any exceptions to the 
30-day rule (except for confidential matters), but if a board for 
some reason has not approved its minutes within the 30 days, then 
whatever draft minutes have been prepared must be made available to 
the public.

Anyone who willfully violates any aspect of the Sunshine Law can be 
charged with a misdemeanor and, if convicted, can be summarily 
removed from the board or commission they sit on.

The Sunshine Law has promoted transparency and integrity to the 
decision-making of Hawai'i's boards and commissions and has helped us 
have a government that is truly "of the people." We need to protect 
and promote this law and expand public access to governmental 
decision-making whenever possible.

Jon M. Van Dyke has been a professor of law at the William S. 
Richardson School of Law, University of Hawai'i-Manoa, since 1976. He 
wrote this commentary for The Advertiser.


SOURCE:  <http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2005/Mar/13/op/op05p.html>


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
This posting is provided to the individual members of this group 
without permission from the copyright owner for purposes of 
criticism, comment, scholarship and research under the "fair use" 
provisions of the Federal copyright laws and it may not be 
distributed further without permission of the copyright owner, except 
for "fair use."


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to