----- Original Message ----- From: Jeff Lux To: Pete Adams Cc: Rob Tucker Sent: Sunday, July 01, 2007 5:42 PM Subject: Re: Code enforcement concerns
I agree this bears repeating Pete, I was at the SC meeting, and a question came up at the end regarding punitive measures against unpermitted dwellings. I again pointed out that our WG interest lay in accounting for these dwellings and the people in them, in order to fund the services they use, not to deny them the use of their property. After 4 hours in a chair, I did not have the presence of mind to further point out, that of the two enforcement issues, the non-conforming highway business use was of greater priority to our WG. Thanks for the input! Aloha, Jeff ----- Original Message ----- From: Pete Adams To: Jeff Lux Cc: Rob Tucker Sent: Sunday, July 01, 2007 10:58 AM Subject: Code enforcement concerns Hi Jeff, Rob, I finally found and read John Whalen's first working paper and have concerns about his interpretation of our recommendations on code enforcement (p. 14). Below is what I've written up. If you have concerns that I'm not getting it right or it needs work please let me know. Otherwise, Jeff, please post this on the appropriate list (my wife gets email from two lists, [Puna-WG-eval] and [Puna-WG-evaluation] while I only get the former, and I'm not sure which is most appropriate). Thanks, Pete I have concerns about the interpretation of at least the Land Use/Growth Management subgroup's recommendations concerning code enforcement as reflected in John Whalen's Working Paper No. 1, "Elements of a Growth Management Strategy." My first concern arose from Larry Brown's notes on the SC's response to the reading of the working paper in which they contrasted "enhanced Building Code enforcement" with "an increased need to provide more affordable housing availability." They asked about "other offsets" and "alienation" of owners of non-conforming buildings. I wondered, where did this come from? As our subgroup specifically wrote against punitive building code enforcement I figured this comment somehow arose from the recommendations of another working group and let it go. Then, in reading the actual working paper later, I discovered that a significant focus of the Code Enforcement section was devoted to punitive code enforcement "against illegal dwellings." Perhaps this is where the "alienation" concern arose. Let me further clarify our written recommendations. At only one point did our working group discuss code enforcement against non-conforming dwellings, saying only that continued tolerance reinforces a larger indifference to county policies and laws (our text is included below). Rather our subgroup made two basic recommendations regarding code enforcement. The first, illegal uses along highways, is addressed fairly well by Mr. Whalen's text though unfortunately confounded with an inappropriate (from the point of view of our recommendations) focus on removing illegal dwellings. Our focus in goals #1 and #3 was entirely on these illegal highway uses and new building permits. With respect to the latter we simply recommended that no variances be allowed for wastewater, drainage, etc. in order to reduce or eliminate marginal and substandard development. With respect to non-conforming dwellings our only recommendation was that they are brought on to the county tax rolls so that such owners are on par with the rest of us responsible for paying taxes on our homes as well as property. This should be able to be readily accomplished in the normal cycles of property tax assessment. Let me emphasize: Our purpose in recommendations regarding code enforcement have nothing to do with removing people from their homes. They are directed at mitigating dangerous and ugly situations well in the public view on our highways. Putting non-conforming dwellings on the tax rolls is, in itself, not part of code enforcement and we specifically do not tie assessment to code enforcement. Part of Goal #1 and all of Goal #3 of the LU/GM subgroup recommendations follow: Goal #1 Prevent population sprawl and scattered development .... ● Increase county staffing to increase code enforcement activity; increase county initiative for prosecution of the most obvious nonconforming uses, particularly along major roadways. ... Discussion Our working group believes that we need to send a clear message to the executive branch that obvious non-conforming land uses, from ad-hoc car lots, junkyards, fast food stands, chicken grills, satellite dishes and the like, need to be prosecuted as a matter of standard county business rather than requiring a formal citizen complaint as the basis of action. We support budget increases for additional county personnel to carry out this enforcement, particularly as we found that investigations from 2003 are still not complete. GOAL #3: Maintain high residential infrastructure standards for subdivisions and building permits OBJECTIVES: ● No new substandard parcels less than five acres ● Reduce physical, social and environmental impacts of inadequate residential infrastructure RECOMMENDATIONS: ● All new subdivisions and residential building permits for parcels below five acres must meet all county standards for building with no variances for wastewater, drainage, road, water and other requirements ● Begin a non-punitive assessment of non-permitted dwellings for property taxes. ● Increase county staffing to increase code inspection and enforcement activity DISCUSSION: The County should alleviate the impact of speculative and haphazard building by insuring that smaller parcels are up to county infrastructure requirements. Create consistent expectations for developers by consistently enforcing standards. It must be noted that the continued tolerance of large numbers of unpermitted buildings, of whatever quality, creates disrespect for the construction principles underlying the building code and the County itself as the enforcers of the code. Just as some people feel that they are not getting a fair return on their tax dollar, having some citizens escape valuation of their homes entirely seems even less fair. There are any number of reasonably well built unpermitted dwellings that contribute nothing (via property taxes) to support the roads, parks, police and fire, civil defense, etc. that they depend on. Nonetheless, for the purposes of taxation, assessment should be disassociated from punitive actions such as red-tagging a dwelling. Pete and Jane Adams White Cloud Nursery P.O. Box 1387 15-89 South Road Pahoa, Hawai'i 96778 www.whitecloudnursery.com
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
