My short answer is that district-wide rezoning would probably be more effective for Puna than one-time subdivision for two reasons: (1) rezoning could be accomplished concurrently with the CDP ordinance itself, since no other CDP districts are involved, a (2) Hawai'i County‛s zoning code is set up differently than Maui‛s and Kaua‘i‛s, so a one-time subdivision provision would require amendments to both the zoning code and the subdivision code and affect other CDP areas. With any significant regulatory change like this, there are also potential "downsides", which I will cover in Working Paper #2. Still, I believe the pluses of district-wide rezoning far exceed the minuses.
John -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of james weatherford Sent: Wednesday, July 04, 2007 10:21 AM To: [email protected] Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] "District wide rezoning" and Ag WG recommendation The "District-wide zoning" on pp10--12 of Working Paper #1, as well as the "one-time sub division of agricultural lands" (pp12-13) do seem to be heading in the right direction to implement the Ag WG recommendations #3 (regarding agricultural land policy) #4 (regarding "rezoning and subdivision amendments that shift options in favor of agriculture versus sprawl"). Still, more insight is needed in terms of comparing the two ideas and determing how one or the other will address issues identified in the Ag WG report. One large problem identified in the Ag WG report was the inability of agricultural production to compete with speculation and high-priced housing for the use of agricultural land, because on parcels of various sizes, including 10 to 100 acres, agriculture is outbid by non- agricultural pursuits. Large homes are built on large parcels and there is no or minimum agric ultural activity. It is not clear whether the ideas discussed in Working Paper #1 address an essential necessity stated in the Ag WG report: to "decouple the price of essental agricultural land from the price of land dedicated to non-agricultural uses." Having larger parcels of Ag zoned land will reduce the number of houses built on that land, and that can be important toward the main purpose of the recommendations: for policy to be "a positive force for local land stewardship and also make a contribution toward removing impediments to local economic opportunity in agriculture." Which of the above two ideas (re-zoning, one-time subdivision) would be more effective in discouraging speculation and the associated inflated prices of ag land? Which would be more difficult to change in the future, entirely through legislation and/or through one-at-a-time special permits? Some of these questions/clarifications may be in Working Paper #2 -- particularly if agriculture is taken not just as a land-preservation issue, but, also and just importantly as an economic development issue. In summary, preventing irreversible loss of agricultural land to non- ag uses, notable low-density housing, is necessary, but not sufficient. The price of that land will need to reflect its agricultural production value as a step toward the first 2 (of 4) Ag WG goals: 1.Local livelihood opportunities based on wholly-sustainable agriculture supplying local markets. 2.Rewarding individual agricultural enterprise. _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
