I have been looking over John Whalens Working Paper #1 and would like to offer a comment. I do understand that it is quite a challenge to distill the WG input and to that end he has done well. What I want to comment on is that, in the distillation process, there are distinctions and complexities which might get lost.
Case in point: Discouraging new subdivision and speculation (page 11) vs. Promoting the formation of Village Centers (page 15) Discouraging New Subdivision and Speculation (page 11) is a concise statement which reflects part of the PCDP LUWG input. The distinction which is missing is the way it conflicts with Promoting the Formation of Village Centers (page 15). To effectively plan and encourage a village like Pahoa (for example) to develop as a expanded village center it will be necessary to actively promote new subdivision and speculation in a redefined Pahoa Village. A simple Pahoa Village map proposal was included, I believe, in the WG reports (LU or T) The Ag lands within and mauka of Pahoa Village are the most appropriate areas for village expansion and should be excluded from the language proposed for restriction of subdivisions and speculation throughout the district. Somewhere this point needs to be very clear. This thinking should, of course, apply to other finite areas suggested for village centers by the LUWG in Puna as well. Pahoa Village, with the basis of a village center, needs some serious attention to grow and fill it's proposed role in the district. If we are to protect our thoroughfares from strip commercialization then the "Urbane Expansion Zone" along Highway 130 needs to relocate to Pahoa Village and mauka of Hwy. 130. Substantial agriculturally zoned lands are available for subdivision (and yes, speculation) for commercial, business parks, community, park, and affordable housing. Market forces should be encouraged to work effectively in those areas. So my simple worry is that the one worthy goal might overwhelm and inhibit another. Unintended consequences. Can clarity be added? OR am I wrong about this? Mahalo, Rob Tucker LUWG ____________________________________________________________________________________ Bored stiff? Loosen up... Download and play hundreds of games for free on Yahoo! Games. http://games.yahoo.com/games/front _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
