Hannah,  

I used the word "speculation" and could have used
"investment" I guess.  But in discussing the opposing
issues in Working Paper #1 I was hoping to most
clearly compare apples to apples.

Business investment involves risk and reward. For
someone to invest in a village center to build and
operate a store or develop affordable housing it is
impossible to do so without "speculating" on the
outcome- hoping to obtain a benefit or profit for the
effort.   This is a process that every current
business in Pahoa has been through.

This is a capitalist, free enterprise country.  This
is how it works here.  

I can ask you what is meant by "regular people".  It
suggests that there are other types of people.  I
think you mean people without substantial 
financial resources.    I know of no practical
mechanism, except hard work and savings, private or
bank loans, to convert a broke "regular person" into
an investor or "speculator".  If such a person has
skills, intelligent ambitions and good reputation then
it is likely they might borrow funds to launch
themselves into a business venture or speculation. 
The focus of the LU-WG is to locate those speculative
efforts into various village centers rather then have
them spread out all along every random roadway.

Recently a gentleman from Maui speculated that his 3
acres on Hwy. 130 could profitably be converted from
agricultural use to a commercial use.  He lost.   Such
is the nature of investment, business risk and
speculation.  

More recently another gentleman is speculating that
his 3 acres on Pahoa Village Road can profitably be
converted from agricultural use to commercial use.  It
appears he will succeed.

A huge risk for both these gentlemen is that Puna
currently lacks any intelligent plan of development. 
They have to make their best effort without guidance. 
One wins, one loses.  The PCDP is hoping to change
that with broad community input.  It will become
easier for everyone, including "regular people"  to
gage their hope of success.






 
____________________________________________________________________________________
Get your own web address.  
Have a HUGE year through Yahoo! Small Business.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/domains/?p=BESTDEAL
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to