Puna CDP
Historical Planning Documents
Public Input Meetings & Workshops
2006 Working Group Reports
Public Input Letters
Consultants Presentations
County Planning Working Papers
-=-=-=-
Hello Prima,
I think you and Stephanie have made the point about Wayne
Yoshioka’s presentation & meetings.
I get it that he wasn’t representing the PCDP-TRANS working group. I read all
the working group reports. Specifically, how does this fact affect the
working group recommendations? I assume
your impression of his presentation was of an authority making
recommendations. My take on it was of a
consultant who did some homework on the background issues presented what his
understanding of it was. It was/is our
job to tell him where he went wrong, and where he got it right. How would you
correct it, if it were
possible to correct?
I see the importance of your point, but the urgency is not
as high on my list, as it is on yours.
In my perspective, we are still receiving reports from the
consultants. We are not blindly being
led by them. They are being paid to do
work that you seem to be asking the steering committee to duplicate, for
free. I probably have that perspective
wrong, but my take on it otherwise is this:
I’m not going to make waves or support anything unless they
are clearly obvious errors, at this point in time. Your issue related to
transportation is not
clearly obvious because the working paper is not out yet. I hope everyone is
as eager as you and I are
to see that paper when it’s here. There
were ten working groups and there are three working papers, so obviously there’s
some homogenization taking place at this time.
Once all the working papers are done, then we will be able to identify
the elements we are focusing on, to see if they’re covered or not. There could
be little bits of them in each
paper. Please remember that these working
papers are bound to be, meant to be, elaborated on in upcoming discussions,
meetings and months ahead.
If it is an urgent matter, the steering committee is the
wrong body to bring the issue up to. It
should go directly to Planning (department, commission, and committee) and if
it’s specifically transportation related, then I’d be looking to see what could
be done by the Trans (dept, commission, and committee) and the County Council
too. These established bodies can affect
decisions going on around the CDP.
Comments are duly noted at least by me, but it's about time the working groups
started thinking about coming back together again for some meetings, to
formally respond to the entire package, when all are presented. Don't you
agree?
Sincerely,
Kim
-=-=-=-
----- Original Message ----
From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: Kim Tavares <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: Stephanie Bath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; Keola Downing <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>;
Frances Stapleton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; james weatherford <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>;
rene siracusa <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; Jane Adams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; [EMAIL
PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Sunday, July 22, 2007 9:58:57 AM
Subject: Re: Clarifying Working Group Points
At 12:08 AM 7/22/2007, Kim Tavares wrote:
>Hi Prema, I think the transportation group has enough good energy
>already, and it's done pretty good so far without my help. Because
>I don't vocally support everything, does not automatically mean I am
>opposed. I am still collecting input in some areas before jumping
>into things I don't fully understand. Because I didn't choose to
>participate in transportation working group much, it could be
>perceived that I'm opposed to much of the plan. That's not entirely
>true. I just can not be everywhere all at once. When I figure out
>a way, I might learn more about transportation. Until then, I
>appreciate all the ground work you and your group has done. I
>support a lot of it.
Aloha Kim,
Thank you, sooooooo much, for your sincere reply.
We needed the support of the steering committee, when Larry Brown cut
off public testimony during Wayne Yoshioka's PowerPoint presentation
in May. That was a critical meeting for the Transportation WG
because we observed the same phenomenon that James Weatherford
observed at the SC meeting last Thursday, i.e. the consultant
promoting his own agenda while ignoring portions of the working group report.
What you saw at the transportation public outreach meetings was NOT
the Transportation WG Report. The public was led to believe that
this is what those 3 public outreach meetings were about. As an
example, the consultant told the public that the Puna Regional
Circulation Plan and the Hawaii DOT (via the STIP) recommend the
widening of Highway 130. The consultant did *not* even mention what
the Transportation WG Report recommended.
I don't fault the SC for not being knowledgeable about the content of
each and every WG report. What I do find troubling is the SC
disregarding the concerns raised by WG Coordinators, who express
discontent with the work of the consultants.
While you may feel good about what the Transportation WG has done
already, we do not feel good about how we are treated at SC meetings,
when the consultant is given a higher regard than the public. We do
not feel good about the consultant cherrypicking recommendations from
the WG reports and inserting his own agenda into the working papers.
My observation: The SC is relying too much upon the consultants and
too little upon the WG Coordinators. I mean, afterall, the
consultants reside on Oahu. They don't hafta live with the
consequences of the recommendations they promote for us, here on the
Big Island.
Instead of the consultants attempting to make the Big Island fit into
their square hole, we need them to use their stellar expertise to
help us solve the problems we have identified in the way that we have
recommended in the WG reports. That won't happen if the SC blindly
accepts everything the consultant presents and turns a deaf ear to
public input.
forward!
devotion, prema
____________________________________________________________________________________
Sick sense of humor? Visit Yahoo! TV's
Comedy with an Edge to see what's on, when.
http://tv.yahoo.com/collections/222
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation