I certainly agree that the Mala `Ai `Opio project seems to be a wonderful idea for Puna. We could actually keep alive even if Pele cuts of off from Hilo if we had enough sustainable (survial) farms like this project all over Puna. We certainly have enough good locations of State Land and County Land to get it going. Water could present some problems, but we really have a lot of rain anyway.
I was reading your post and wondering if this isn't a place that would be appropriate for us to ask the consultants to consider adding the idea of a sustainable farm at each park and ride location. I saw so much wonderful success with the little fenced off public gardens in Waikiki and other location on Oahu. For Puna to have little local public garden space with enclosures and water taps seems like something that would be great to team up with the WiFi comfort stations called for in the Mass Transit portion of theTransportation Working Group Final Report.
I wonder sometimes if people are having a hard time finding the documents, or perhaps just finding the time to read the Working Group Reports. We need to make a presentation and power point display for the public to allow them to see what our real Public Plan included. There has been a lot of posts about missing the PMAR reports in what the consultants have called for. Both Rob's and your proposals were included in the final report and deserve to be very carefully explained and discussed while moving toward a consultant's final draft.
I must admit that David never got a copy of his proposal to me for inclusion in the New Alternative Corridors Task Partnership Report, but PMAR was a major emphasis of our final report. My own executive summary has been misunderstood if people didn't understand we indeed had consensus that a PMAR was needed. Their was opposition by some and an alternative view without PMAR (except for emergency) was included as well. In my summary look at the future I always included both Upper and Lower PMAR plans as well as inter subdivision connector routes as both emergency as well as alternative corridors. In addition the Existing Roadways Task Partnership called for a divided Highway 130, and many roundabout intersections for both Highway 11 and Hwy 130.
I want to see people understand all the proposals including the three mentioned in the recent posts, and the full Transportation Working Group Final Report. Perhaps the best way to do that is to have each Task Partnership and each Proposal from outside the Working group present their work themselves. I have not the slightest doubt that the acceptance from the people who worked on the Puna CDP would want to know what really is in these documents for comparison with the material John and Wayne are presenting.
People are very busy and perhaps they do not have access to the Internet or find it difficult to read the files on-line. We need to insure that the Puna Public is represented in the final Puna Community Development Plan. Last Thursday night was an eye opener! We are getting a full four steps forward before we are smiled at and shifted five steps backward. I was embarrassed for getting angry the other night, but we did so much work together to represent the views of the public in Puna, that having them disregarded was quite upsetting.
I certainly don't want to wait 5 years to be able to drive out of Puna on an improved Beach Road, and new Corridors for emergency access through the areas between all the subdivisions in upper and lower Puna if needed. These things are called for now. Working on roads where only rain touches the ground today should not have to wait for any reason to start. If we need to purchase private land, it's cheaper today than it will be in the future. If environmental studies need to be done, then we need to start right now. If alignments need to be decided on, then now is the time to do that as well.
I don't want to get angry, I just want to get it right! Let's have another round of presentations of the original Working Group reports before any final plan be accepted. I liked the idea of a Saturday at some of the schools so that people from the public can look into the issues that they feel strongest about. This is a very easy thing for the Steering Committee to set up with the Planning Department. Our own Working Groups can do this. If no one else wants to set this up, then let's ask HCRC to give us a laptop and projector so we can display our own Power Point presentations of the work that we did ourselves. :-)
P.S. Don't forget to look at the all inclusive map at the end of my executive proposal. There were requests for about 40 roundabouts from the public, and I put them all in. People wanted to have access across the Maku`u Stat land, and that was included. Upper Puna residents called for using the existing roadways as the connector routes instead of opening big Corridors, so that is what you see on the map. We can have everything everyone wants, but we will get none of these great ideas if our work is ignored in the Final Plan. Will we have to explain and give testimony to the County Council some day to insure that the Public's ideas get included?
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
