Since neither Working Paper 3 nor the 8/16 SC agenda are online, I 
have not been able to learn about tonight's SC meeting. So, I have been 
using my previously-scheduled PCDP hour today to go back and review 
Working Paper 2. 

WORKING PAPER 2, PAGE 2, paragraph 3:
"The closure of sugar production in Puna opened a large amount of 
agriculture land to a more diversified industry. Presently, Puna 
produces at least 40 different agricultural products..."

Based on the above, a reader unfamiliar with the reality on the ground 
could easily surmise that Puna agriculture, using former cane land, has 
made a seamless and prosperous transition from sugar to diversified 
agriculture. Of course, this is opposite of reality.

How many acres of agricultural land were "opened"?
How many of these same acres of agricultural land are now in 
"different agricultural products"?

While there are a few good examples of successfully using former cane 
land for diversified agriculture, jungles of invasive species occupy a 
much larger portion of what was "opened."

Most of the agriculture expansion in Puna during recent decades -- e.
g., papaya, macadamia, flowers, vegetables -- has NOT been on former 
cane land. 

Without accurately addressing the issue of the thousands of acres of 
abandoned cane land in Puna and the role that land is able to play in 
increasing local market share of food, Working Paper 2 is a lie.
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to