Hi Wayne ,

My puspose in these postings is to provide
constructive criticism not merely to be argumentative.
 The simple basis for my criticism are the "scope of
work" sections of both consulting agreements.  I am
glad that you have responded in this forum for the
first time.  I will invite you to do so here more
often.    

I and others in this process have expectations of you
and your work product.  It sould cover all areas of
the scope of work.  It should respond clearly to the
community input generated by and reflected in teh
Transportation WG report.   

Since no response to my open letter to you and John
Whalen has been made verbally, in writing or in
presentation I am going to repeat it just in case you
missed it when it posted on Aug. 10th.  [ I do
apologize for mis-spelling your last name in that
letter].

As follows:

Quote
Wayne and John,

I’m not going to beat around the bush. Your work to
date is compromised by your failure to address the
PMAR issue.  Your firm is purported to be a
professional transportation consultant yet you
completely fail to address the implications of HPP
approaching full build out.  The suggestions you have
made, and failed to make to date, assure that Puna
will be facing deadly and chronic traffic problems for
at least the next generation.

By viewing the charts you provided at your
presentation the statistics show HPP contributes
approximately 70% of the peak hour congestion on Hwy.
130.  HPP is approximately 20% built out today and is
rapidly growing.  Without an alternative route to
provide HPP residents an alternative to Hwy. 130 
through and from HPP all of your “short term
solutions” will be overcome before they are completed.
 The result of your lack of vision will be constant
construction, modifying, amending, lane adding and
danger on Hwy. 130.  The two lane will build to a 4
lane which will build to a six lane and at least two
two things will occur.

Nonstop traffic woes just like every other location
served by such planning vision and Puna will
irrevocably be changed from the rural district the
PCDP input wants to maintain. The 20 plus years of
nonstop construction might serve the construction
industry just fine.  It will not serve the residents
of Puna very well.

At least three PMAR proposals have been put forth  in
the PCDP process.  James Weatherford’s, David
Fukumoto’s and mine.  You have made zero mention of
any of them to date.  I want to see your analysis,
charted positive and negative attributes, of each of
these proposals.  If your firm is creative enough to
bring forth a forth proposal then, by all means, do
so.  Do read the PCDP Transportation report and
respond to it.

You may not enjoy this note but I am a resident of
this district and you are not.  I and my neighbors
have to live or die with the results of this process
and you do not. 

End Quote

So a few more weeks have now passed and the message
and intent of my Aug. 10th letter remains the same.  

You have time still to correct the deficiencies of
your presentations.  I encourage you to do your work
and fill in the blanks.  Do consult with John Whalen
on what sections of your 'scope of work' are still
lacking. Meanwhile we will be await the minutes and
notes of your private meetings and are prepared to be
bored.  Some of it we are already aware of.  We would
like the blanks filled in.

Rob Tucker
LU-WG



--- "Yoshioka, Wayne Y." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:

> 
> Aloha Rob!
> 
> It seems there is misunderstanding with regard to
> what we've been doing
> on this project.
> 
> First.  Your statement that I've been "taking
> politics into" our
> calculations of the Puna transportation potentials
> is absolutely false.
> We have been collecting much information with regard
> to what others are
> doing.  That is a very normal part of any thorough
> analysis of
> alternatives.  Not collecting information or
> collecting only one-sided
> information would be unprofessional.  We always
> begin from trying to
> understand all of the viewpoints.
> 
> Second.  You will receive the minutes of our
> meetings.  I was largely
> out of the office last week, and had not been able
> to get them to you.
> I will this week. I'm afraid you'll find them fairly
> boring.  All of our
> meetings have been data collection or data sharing
> meetings that help us
> understand what other transportation efforts are
> happening in the Puna
> region.
> 
> Third.  As I said at the last Steering Committee
> meeting, we are not
> conducting our analysis to prove that a certain
> alternative is the best
> alternative.  We are conducting an evaluation to
> provide a realistic
> plan of action that would benefit the majority of
> the community within
> the Puna region.
> 
> I hope this clarifies what we believe our charge is
> on this project.  My
> hope is that you will continue to contribute your
> ideas in a
> constructive way to help us arrive at a
> transportation plan that is the
> best for the Puna communities.
> 
> A hui hou,
> 
> Wayne Yoshioka
> 
> 
> -----Original Message-----
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On
> Behalf Of Rob Tucker
> Sent: Saturday, August 25, 2007 10:23 AM
> To: puna CDP Participants
> Cc: Puna WG Members; Puna WG Evaluation; Sara
> Burgess; Puna CDP
> Participants;
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] Concerning the PCDP
> transportation consultant
> 
> Concerning the PCDP transportation consultant:
> 
> Following the last SC meeting and the presentation
> by Wayne Yoshika -
> the PCDP transportation consultant - there has been
> little said on this
> board on the subject. I want to change that with
> some concerns and
> observations that all the SC members, the County 
> and John Whalen need
> to pay attention too.
> 
> Wayne indicated, by statements he made at the last
> presentation, that he
> is taking politics into his calculations of Puna
> transportation
> potentials.  I have also had this concern mentioned
> by people who have
> met privately with Wayne in the process.  
> 
> This had made me very concerned about....
> 
> 1) Influence. What input has Wayne been gathering
> and from whom in
> private meetings? I asked about this at the SC
> meeting and Wayne told me
> he would provide a list of people he met with and
> minutes of those
> meetings.  He has not yet provided this info and he
> needs to ASAP.
> Wayne, when can we expect this disclosure?  The
> opportunity for the
> community to invest thousands of hours of work and
> effort and have it
> swayed and influenced by unknown private parties
> exists.  We need to
> watch closely.  I call on the SC to be very
> diligent.
> 
> 2.  Politics.  I asked John Whalen for the
> contractual 'scope of work'
> regarding Parsons-Brinckerhoff (Wayne
> Yoshioka) agreement.  John provided that promptly
> (thank-you).  I passed
> it on the the SC members. 
> Nowhere in that document is Wayne Yosioka charge
> with making political
> assessments regarding the suitability of any
> transportation proposals.
> It is not his job. 
> It is not professional.  It distorts his thinking
> and subverts the whole
> purpose of having a transportation consultant. The
> Primary consultant,
> Plan Pacific, and the County of Hawaii need to
> impress Wayne Yoshioka
> with the need to keep his analysis pragmatic and
> confined to the
> cost/benefit analysis of various transportation
> options.  It is glaring
> that he has, to date, ignore key section s of his
> description of work
> - specifically PMAR,  This is serious.  If he is
> unable to complete his
> clearly stated tasks professionally he should be
> dismissed and not paid.
> 
> 
> I am not saying this to be mean or demeaning.  I am
> saying this because
> it needs to be said.  I would prefer to see him
> succeed in this task....
> I have serious doubts at this time though.  I may
> have more to say on
> this later.  I invite participants to weigh in...
> 
> Rob Tucker
> LU-WG 
> 
> 
>  
>
________________________________________________________________________
> ____________
> Park yourself in front of a world of choices in
> alternative vehicles.
> Visit the Yahoo! Auto Green Center.
> http://autos.yahoo.com/green_center/
> _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
>
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
> 
> ___________________________
> NOTICE: This communication and any attachments
> ("this message") may contain confidential
> information for 
> the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any
> unauthorized use, disclosure, viewing, copying,
> alteration, 
> dissemination or distribution of, or reliance on
> this message is strictly prohibited. If you have
> received this
> message in error, or you are not an authorized
> recipient, please notify the sender immediately by
> replying to 
> this message, delete this message and all copies
> from your e-mail system and destroy any printed
> copies.
> _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
>
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
> 



       
____________________________________________________________________________________
Building a website is a piece of cake. Yahoo! Small Business gives you all the 
tools to get online.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/webhosting 
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to