Bett's comments are absolutely spot on! In particular the concern about people in the community having a working understanding of some of the proposals. Getting information from the community on draft recommendations is good when done correctly; and counterproductive when done poorly and/or with a pre-determined outcome (as in the case of Punaluu).
The good outputs from the Working Groups has, to a very large degree, been done by people (Elizabeth and myself included) at a stage in life where there is time, ability, and health to volunteer. There are people in the community who have thus far had less opportunity to be heard from because of limited time, money, and/or mobility . For example, this would include Puna residents who travel long hours and sleep away from home so as to work in Kona, young families with small children, and elders with limited mobility (especially at night). A community survey can be helpful in getting input from the above people. However, before they even think about or look at, much less participate in, a survey, they must be able to objectively consider the ideas put forth. As Prema has indicated, public input into the structure and wording of the survey instrument is imperative. The structure and wording can make all the difference between getting useful informtion and getting what is pre-determined by the people paying for the survey (The Golden Rule: 'He who has the Gold Rules'). _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
