There are so many questions generated by, and contradictions and 
deceptions contained within, the Transportation Preliminary 
Recommendations that it is almost impossible to know where to start!  
(Is that the idea?)

A few here (and plenty more to say tomorrow night at the PCDP Steering 
Committee):

p. 1
“Puna is becoming a bedroom community. This results in more 
concentrated and directional travel demand, primarily on the arterial 
roadways connecting Puna to Hilo. Primarily agricultural land uses, on 
the other hand, tend to have residents that work in the same district 
as they live. This results in a greater number of short-distance trips 
that are not as concentrated directionally.”
“...strategies that encourage a mix of land uses that retain more of 
the travel demand within the Puna District. Although there is much 
support for these strategies within the Puna communities, this effort 
is expected to take a number of years to have an appreciable effect on 
travel demand patterns.”
“...blends the desires of the community with engineering and 
institutional constraints so that the plan results in actions that 
could be implemented within a time frame that would be useful to the 
Puna communities.”

Question:
Specifically, what are two examples each of engineering and 
institutional constraints in the Puna context that must over ride 
desires of the community?

Comment: 
That Puna is now a bedroom community of Hilo is apparent to everyone. 
Throughout the PCDP process, Puna residents have clearly stated this as 
a problem that needs the highest attention in making the necessary 
changes to center more economic and cultural activity, as well as more 
public, social, and commercial services within Puna.
Rather than rolling up their sleeves and sitting down with the 
community to achieve the community's goals of village center and 
increased self-reliance, the consultants are using inappropriate, 
unimaginative, stale, off-the-shelf proposals that will perpetuate Puna 
being  a bedroom community and dependent on another community for basic 
services --  exactly the opposite of what is clearly desired by the 
community. 
The consultants have dismissed substantial and critical input from 
working group reports as well from individuals at public meetings -- 
the message from the consultants to the community, as a whole and 
toward individuals, has been, 'You have to understand, we are the 
experts. You, the community, could not possibly be able to know what is 
needed. We do. Trust us.'

p. 2
“...approaches the transportation issues by offering choices to the 
Puna community.”

Comment:
The set of choices presented is incomplete, by intent. A community 
choice prematurely dismissed is that of retaining more travel within 
Puna. This is a viable choice that is cast aside (on page 1) as taking 
too long. Like road building or any other action, village center 
development will only be done when it is funded. And, like other 
actions, the sooner village center development is started the sooner it 
gets done. If setting village development as the highest priority for 
money and time means dropping the high-cost medium- and long-term road 
widening, that is good and will be in accordance with what the 
community has clearly indicated!
Pushing village development aside and pushing 4-lane highways through, 
as the consultants propose, will serve to perpetuate, not diminish, 
existing concentrated and directional travel demand.

p. 2

“...travel reduction techniques...” 

Questions:
Specifically, what are these techniques and where are they detailed as 
such in the document? 
What is the approximate cost of proposed travel reduction techniques?
What is the approximate cost of proposed road work to accommodate 
concentrated and directional travel demand?
How does the marginal cost:benefit of proposed techniques compare to 
proposed road work? That is, which of these two ‘choices’ (travel 
reduction techniques or road building) get the most additional benefit 
from the least additional cost?

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to