Aloha kakou, This is in reply to Kim Tavares‛ suggestions that we consider approaches taken by Hood River County OR and Martha‛s Vineyard MA re growth control. I am more familiar with Martha‛s Vineyard than I am with Hood River, but I think the latter is comparable to other counties in the Northwest that have dealt with similar farm and forest preservation issues, a couple of which I have cited in either a working paper or presentation. I believe these NW counties provide a more useful model for Puna than does Martha‛s Vineyard, which is a somewhat unique case because of the pronounced changes in seasonal population, the relatively small size of the island, and the income profile of the residents (both part-time and permanent.)
Some of the development standards in the Hood River code could be useful to consider for Puna. District-wide rezoning and maximum footprints for new dwellings on ag-zoned lots, as presently recommended in the preliminary CDP table, accomplish the same objectives. In any case, these standards would have to be determined in a follow-up zoning code and zoning map revision effort, so it is not necessary for the CDP to decide the specifics, only to point the way by describing the purpose and intent of the proposed action. I didn‛t see anything particularly remarkable in Hood County‛s non-conforming use section. The provisions are similar to those in the present Hawai'i County code. I thought Kim might be referring to a method whereby a non-conforming use might be amortized completely, whether or not the owner has discontinued the use for a period of time. This is a more aggressive approach that has been used very sparingly by municipalities due to the threat of litigation over "regulatory taking" of property. San Francisco is the only place I know of that has adopted a measure like this, but it applies only to "noxious" uses in residential areas, as I recall. In Hawai'i, State law enables counties to adopt an amortization provision in their zoning codes, but they cannot apply it to residential or agricultural zones (Section 46-4 (a), HRS.) Honolulu nearly adopted an ordinance to phase out sidewalk vendors in Waikïkï under this provision, but dropped this initiative when another approach proved effective. To my knowledge, no other county has tried the amortization approach. I have not yet gotten a reply from the Hood County planners about the reference in their code that it has been "superseded by state law". I suspect this refers to proposition on the ballot in the 2004(?) election, passed by the voters, that essentially gutted the farmland preservation features of Oregon‛s Land Use Law. Hood County‛s code provisions for farmland preservation were probably based on the authority of that law. Fortunately, we don‛t run that type of risk in Hawai'i. John -----Original Message----- From: Larry Brown [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, October 30, 2007 12:59 PM To: John Whalen Subject: FW: New Agenda Topic - District-wide re-zoning? FYI LB -----Original Message----- From: Kim Tavares [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, October 28, 2007 8:50 PM To: John Whalen Cc: Larry Brown Subject: Fw: New Agenda Topic - District-wide re-zoning? Second attempt to get this to John Whalen... (keep getting a bounce back) ----- Forwarded Message ---- From: Kim Tavares <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Larry Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, October 28, 2007 8:43:11 PM Subject: New Agenda Topic - District-wide re-zoning? Hi Jon, John, Larry, I have been digging around some more on the internet and through the reports, to find out more about district-wide rezoning. I didn't find much of that talk in the goals & visions table, though it was a recommendation in the first working paper. My notes say "Look into this - this concept has potential". I'd like to find out more about it, and maybe discuss it around the round (horseshoe) table. There is enough data and documentation on Puna resources to justify the entire district as a valuable resource to everyone. There is enough federal and state language that justifies we plan for sustainability, protect natural and historical resources and stop all forms of pollution. We really should take that plunge, and restructure the zoning code. Right off the top - protect forest lands, historical & cultural sites, prevent agricultural land depletion, and stop creating waste we can't deal with, and stop wasting resources. (Thanks Jon, for asking us to think back to our three most important issues, those are mine! watershed, agriculture, waste). We know where the forest lands are. We know which lands used to be cane, cattle or other agriculture. There is no mystery there. We know which subdivisions have incorrect zoning, we know which big lands have incorrect zoning and we know that all our zoning codes today will create disaster way before full build out. We really need to rezone, in addition to having overlay zones, special districts, village centers and all the rest. If we look at land use holistically instead of something separate from all other working group topics, we will never see the big picture. I was lead to an interesting website for Hood River County, Oregon. They have a non-conforming use phase-out plan, ordinances to protect natural resources, historical sites and management plans for sustainability. Of particular interest are Articles 65, 5, and 7. Of course they'd need some tweaking, but generally they look very interesting. There's a note on Article 7 that notes it was superceded by State law, and to find out more about that, to call planning. That might be a worthwhile phone call for one of you? http://www.co.hood-river.or.us/HRCG_Template_STD_HTML.asp?PageINDX=37 And another place with proven controlled growth, Marrtha's Vineyard. The MV Commission has an interesting website too: http://www.mvcommission.org/ Thank you, Kim __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
