Aloha,

I send the enclosed conversation, between J. Stenger (Puna CDP 
Transportation WG) and Patrick Tom (STIP Manager), FYI . . .


forward!
devotion, prema


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

The State Department of Transportation would like to announce the 
conditional approval of the FFYs 08-11 (+2) STIP. The FHWA and FTA 
have jointly approved the 2008-2011 (+2) STIP, CONDITIONALLY, for the 
next 6 months. This conditional approval is due to planning details 
that are being presently addressed.

During this time, major amendments, that include adding new projects, 
completely deferring an existing project out of the STIP, or major 
scope and cost estimate changes will NOT be allowed. Minor revisions 
such as deferral or advancement of existing projects within the 08-11 
STIP and minor scope or cost estimate chagnes will be allowed. In the 
meanwhile, projects that are presently in the conditionally approved 
08-11(+2) STIP may go forward and seek funding as they are ready. We 
anticipate that these details will be addressed within a few months.

Please refer to our 08-11 (+2) STIP website for further information 
and updates.

http://www.hawaii.gov/dot/stp/stip/index.htm

Patrick Tom
STIP Manager


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

J Stenger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

10/28/2007 08:04 PM
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED], 
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], 
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], 
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Subject: Re: Fiscal Years 2008-2011 (+2) Statewide Transportation 
Improvement Program (STIP): Conditionally Approved on September 28, 2007


In your opinion, how much have you and your staff utilized the 
recommendations and comcerns that were submitted to you, that 
represented the tremendous amount of volunteer hours the Puna 
Community Development Planning members have devoted to this project?

Would you say more than 50 % ?   Or less that 50 %  ?

Jason, your article published Friday, Sept. 28, 2007 states, "state 
planning studies call for either widening the road or building an 
alternative route elsewhere, so it remains t be seen which gets 
built, Tamura said."    Was this a direct quote from Stanley Tamura?

Also, Jason, you quoted Lorraine Inouye as saying, "I want to have 
this four-lane project expedited, it's an urgency."   Did Lorraine 
even know about the need for an alternative route elsewhere?  Could 
you please ask her?

I'm not sure where Jason got his information from, but it doesn't 
seem like it came from the hard work of the Puna Community 
Development Planners.

It seems like STIP is ignoring the PCDP recommendations.


J. Stenger


+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED],
        [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: Fiscal Years 2008-2011 (+2) Statewide Transportation Improvement
Program (STIP): Conditionally Approved on September 28, 2007
Date: Fri, 2 Nov 2007 09:59:35 -1000


J Stenger,

Thank you for your comments and questions. We would like to offer the 
following information to clarify some of your questions.

Please know that the input we received through our extensive public 
involvement process for the development of the STIP was fully 
considered and applied throughout the decision-making process.

When a project is considered for STIP funding, the basic question 
that is asked is whether   a project should be funded with Federal 
funds. The discussion on the specifics of a  project's purpose and 
need, is more appropriately addressed during development of the long 
and mid range plans as well as in the Alternatives Analysis section 
of the project's environmental document. Input from our STIP meetings 
is passed to our project managers that are involved in these other 
stages of project identification and development.

There were basically two messages that we heard when we went out to 
our two meetings in Keaau.

1. A Puna-Makai Alternative Route (PMAR) is needed more so than 
improving the existing Keaau-Pahoa Road.

Our response was that the PMAR should be identified in the long range 
land transportation plan for the Island of Hawaii and that 
development of the project will likely require a lengthy 
environmental impact disclosure process. Also, that the environmental 
assessment (EA) for the Keaau-Pahoa Road Improvements project will 
analyze the PMAR as an option in the alternatives analysis (which 
also will include the "no-build" option). As a result of this, we did 
not defer Federal funding for the Keaau-Pahoa Road Improvements 
project in the financially constrained STIP. We transmitted the 
attendance sheet of the two meetings to the project manager of the 
Keaau Pahoa Road Improvement project so that Keaau STIP meeting 
attendees can be notified when the 1st Keaau Pahoa Road Improvement 
project public meeting is scheduled.

Also, to draw upon the efforts of the Puna Community Development Plan 
(CDP), our project managers for the Keaau-Pahoa Road Improvements 
project are coordinating with Hawaii County's points of contact for 
the Puna CDP.

2. Safety is a big concern along the existing Keaau-Pahoa Road. Three 
specific intersections were named and roundabouts were suggested by 
some as a possible solution at these intersections.

We responded that there are three ongoing efforts to enhance safety 
at these intersections, one of which will be using only State money 
and therefore is not listed on the STIP.  The Department of 
Transportation (DOT) is considering roundabouts at various locations 
as part of possible safety alternatives.  In fact, the DOT recently 
attended a community open house in Pahoa with conceptual plans that 
illustrated a possible roundabout configuration at one of the 
intersection locations. We also alerted the Safety Program managers 
that Keaau STIP meeting attendees should be notified when the first 
public meetings for these efforts occur. As a result of these 
comments, we did not defer federal funding for the two intersection 
improvement projects in the financially constrained STIP.

We believe many of the comments raised are being taken into 
consideration within the appropriate projects and planning efforts 
being done by the DOT in accordance with Federal regulation.  As 
public participation is essential for our projects, we are hopeful 
that you will be an active participant in many of the upcoming public 
meetings and we look forward to your suggestions.


Patrick Tom
STIP Manager

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to