Hi Ron, Thank you for taking your valuable time to respond. I do not expect you to take time to restructure the document to fit our group "track-changes". As I stated, I plan to ask the committee on Wednesday, to take it home and read it if they haven't already, and then ask themselves which one they like better, the original or the restructured. Then Thursday we decide which one to work on, for possibly the last cut. From feedback I've already gotten from other participants, I expect it to go favorably. With only two meetings left before the legislature is back in session, this document has some great concepts but also some confusing ones, and the overall intent is not coming out loud and clear. As it is, It's not even clear to me what exactly we'd like government to do for Puna.
I find this important enough to spend considerable amounts of time on. I want John Whalen to get the message we are trying to send in time to do something about it. There are some very specific things that must happen with the graces of the planning department, in this upcoming legislature. There are also things planning could be doing now to slow down implementation of State plans in progress. If these things are not something planning will do for Puna, I would really appreciate knowing that now, so I can be free to focus on other things. For now, I believe that planning wants to support what Puna people want, but planning doesn't know what we want, because this table is a mess. However planning does know a lot more than we do, and if it's not consistent with our recommendations, it should come forth and explain justify these differences. We need to know what the state is doing and we need to know what planning, council and mayor think about it, and what its doing about it. Otherwise most of our recommendations will be likely be invalidated or misinterpreted before 2008 is over. In spending time between meetings reading through the table and comparing to all the working group reports, and also to my notes from attending such wg meetings as land use, natural resources, agriculture and culture & history, I have come to understand how the big picture can be realized, must be realized, and it is not clearly articulated in the original table or in the current version. If it doesn't get restructured, it will never be clear, and I think that's what government would like to see. I am not saying that the planning dept wants this to be a junk product, but someone up the food chain does. It would be easy to discount it as junk if our issues are presented as haphazardly as it is, in the current version. Government could say, "this is all gibberish!" and that would be it. I didn't invest two years of my time for that to happen. Who can say that a district-wide rezoning sweep over Puna that changes all the ag lands to residential, without considering our CDP recommendations, is going to be what we want? I have been through the State community input planning process on this topic of "fake farms". It was all of two days long, and it included very few people. Who believes that State projects support County/District desires? The state wants more money flowing into state coffers, and that means attracting more people to this place. Highway widening is not to accommodate full build out, it is to accommodate excessive quantity over quality tourism. This is exactly opposite of what the people of Puna want. We are attempting to protect the island so that the visitor industry gets a high quality authentic experience while visiting, not high-volume, high-impact foot, vehicle and superferry traffic. And we want food-security, just in case something bad happens. Ironically, the worst that could happen is that there are so many people here that all the ag lands are gone, and thus the island would not be able to feed its population. And the trees will all be plowed down, creating a desert. Then what happens when the rain stops? How long will aquifers last, once it's all a desert? I understand the pressure SC members are feeling, under the gun so to speak, to get this done -however it looks- as soon as can. I understand the desires of the SC members to take more time and to do it right. My revision intends to get the better of both of these worlds, a better product in a timely fashion. Thanks for your sincere interest! Kim ----- Original Message ---- From: Ron Whitmore <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: Kim Tavares <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Cc: [email protected]; "Brown, Larry" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; [EMAIL PROTECTED]; jon <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, November 21, 2007 5:04:44 PM Subject: RE: Suggested DGOA revisions Aloha Kim, Thanks for the heads up regarding your proposed changes. The agenda for both Wednesday's and Thursday's meetings as written should accommodate a discussion of your recommended changes, so no changes to the agenda should be required. To facilitate discussion, I encourage you to bring a clearly organized outline of a proposed reorganization of the DGOA for the SC members to consider. Feel free to include specific goals, objectives, or actions that you think should be moved or combined, as you've done below. I'd like to forewarn you, however, that I am not going to take the time to restructure the document based on your suggestions before Wednesday's meeting. John Whalen organized the DGOA with a clear purpose in mind, and I think the SC should trust him to organize the final product in a manner that both reflects the views/priorities of the community and is easy for readers to follow. I'm sure he'll appreciate your suggested reorganization and take it into consideration when he finalizes the document. Moreover, I don't think it's a good use of your time to wordsmith the document by removing words and redundancies or trying to improve its readability. The focus of the SC at this point should be on the substance of the goals, objectives, and actions -- not on the exact language in the document. The SC's job is to come to agreement on that substance, and John Whalen's job is to capture the SC's intent in appropriate language. So, please don't spend your time combining sections, rewording things, or otherwise restructuring the DGOA. Get any ideas that you think need to be included, clarified, or deleted to me by Monday morning, and I'll include your suggestions in the draft for consideration by the SC on Wednesday. But I will not take the time to do any major restructuring of the document or combining of ideas that are already in the document. Hope that helps you focus your time and energy over the next few days. Ron -----Original Message----- From: Kim Tavares [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, November 21, 2007 1:47 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; Brown, Larry; Whitmore, Ron; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: [email protected] Subject: Greetings Jon, I would like to request 5-10 minutes on the upcoming meeting agenda to discuss this proposed editing of the Draft Goals, Objectives, Actions table. I would like not to surprise anyone, and so I will let you know now, I have a lot of changes. In fact, I am currently restructuring the entire thing so it makes more sense. I am compressing it by removing all the little connector words and redundancies so it reads easier. I'm also going combining goals, objectives and actions and then reorganizing each line either by "Goal" or "Action". So much is repeated throughout the doc, and so much is in the wrong place. Lots of things are even in the wrong sections or themes. I also try to keep terminology consistent throughout. My edits intend to make the document easy to absorb and understand and to make it sound appealing, even to Planning Commissioners and County Council members. I am proposing to replace the entire current document with a newly formatted version, preserving all the concepts agreed upon so far, and adding some things I felt were expressed by working group reports, and then left out. I will have a draft for circulation within a few days, hopefully before this weekend, and I will take comments and make changes if something is wrong. Here are some of the highlights in the restructured format: THEMES: Removed "Energy Conservation" from "Mobility and Energy Conservation". Move the section "Energy Conservation" into theme *Malama I ka Aina*. Theme MANAGING GROWTH: Former sections were, Land Use Pattern, Agriculture and Economic Development, Social Services and Housing, Public Services Parks and Recreation. Changes: 1) Split Agriculture and Economic Development, MOVED "Agriculture" to theme *Malama I ka Aina*. Make section "Economic Development" third of three in theme. (LUP remains #1) and, 2) Re-name section "Social Services and Housing" to "People", and keep it at #2 section under theme *Managing Growth*. Theme MALAMA I KA AINA: Former sections were, Historic and Cultural and Scenic Resources, Native Forests and Geological Features, Aquifers and Coastal Waters. Changes: 1) Added section "Agriculture" from LUP (#2 above). 2) Added section "Alternative Energy" from theme *Mobility & Energy Conservation*, leaving *Mobility* as a stand-alone third of three themes. 3) Renamed section "Native Forests and Geological Features" to "Natural Resources". NEW (Proposed) DGOA OUTLINE: Theme: Managing Growth Land Use Pattern (MG Section-1) Preserve Watershed and Natural Resources Protect Agriculture & other Valued Lands Gathering Hubs, Towns and Village Centers People (MG Section-2) Improve Social Services Improve Public Services & Infrastructure Increase Parks Economy (MG Section-3) Agriculture Environmental Education for Jobs Theme: Malama I Ka Aina Agriculture (1) Alternative Energy (2) Culture, Historic & Scenic Resources (3) Natural Resources (4) Theme: Mobility Traffic Demand Management (1) Mass Transit (2) Roadway Network (3) Highways (4) Non-motorized Travel & Scenic Byways (5) The idea is to manage growth by land use pattern first, then for humanity, and at the same time, develop a new form of economy, and environmentally sustainable one. Theme Malama I Ka Aina now includes all the things our new economy should consist of: Agriculture, Environmental, and Education to support all the Malama I Ka Aina sections of our new economy; Agriculture, Alternative Energy, Culture, History & Scenic Resources, and Natural Resources. I don't plan to do a whole lot with the theme *Mobility* for now. As I have always stated since the start, I think the people who are trying to make Puna transportation better today, are doing a wonderful thing and I support whatever works better than what's working now. But for planning the future, I firmly believe we need to work out the a-b-c's of the themes *Growth Management* and *Malama I Ka Aina* first. I hope this sounds reasonable to everyone and non-threatening to anyone. Thanks (for) giving! Kim ____________________________________________________________________________ ________ Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Yahoo! Mail. See how. http://overview.mail.yahoo.com/ ____________________________________________________________________________________ Be a better pen pal. Text or chat with friends inside Yahoo! Mail. See how. http://overview.mail.yahoo.com/ _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
