Aloha All. I do hope to attend the meeting on the 24th - so glad to learn that 
it begins at 3:30pm. I attended the community meeting on the beach road from 
Kapoho to Hawaiian Shores. There were many who wanted that road paved for the 
purpose of evacuation and safety, and many more who wanted it to remain an 
unpaved route. Their reasoning was that we don't want to "pave paradise", that 
people move there because it is off the grid, and putting a paved road would 
encourage speeding, road rage, etc. I tend to agree with the unpaved group. I 
think the county decision to improve the roadway, but not pave addresses both 
parties issues. I think that might also be a solution to the Beaches to 
Paradise Park segment of the road as there are more and more houses along that 
road, but it is virtually impassable a good deal of the time due to the huge 
ruts from lava. I was interested that John Whalen used Rob Tucker's reasoning 
to align the through Paradise Park road between streets as it would impact 
fewer driveways. However, Rob Tucker's idea that PMAR go further toward the 
water in HPP seemed more reasonable to me as is would divert more traffic from 
HWY 130 - if PMAR is a third of the way up the subdivision, 2/3rds of the 
community would find it a more accessible road. The closer to 130 the less 
difference it makes for people to use it. It also appears as if John Whalen's 
PMAR is what Shipman might find most palatable as it basically parallels Hwy11 
and has minimal impact on their property. I don't know that that conveys the 
goal that PCDP has had to minimize the traffic on 130 or 11. 
I also find it interesting that there has been no discussion about ways to 
connect the new fire/police location to lower Puna except via 130. The Nanawale 
connector envisioned by John Whalen succeeds in nonimpact of the Beaches/Shores 
subdivisions, but it would make sense to me for the purpose of evacuation and 
safety to have additional connectivity to the "back" side of the police/fire 
location connecting to the farmlot roads off Kahakai, and possibly the Nanawale 
connector road. Another resource that has been mentioned in some meetings but 
was not included in the committee reports is the improvement of the landing 
strip so that it could be used as an emergency evacuation by helicopters to 
Hilo Hospital, or by the police, or for other disasters. It is near the 
police/fire location and could also be connected in someway, possibly.  
At one point in the Parks Committee discussions a park/community with 
bike/transit/road access outside HPP was considered to be desireable. In John 
Whalen's diagram the intersection of the Railroad bike path and the Nanawale 
connector road might be that kind of an intersection. Then the park/community 
could be built on state land, minimize the impact on HPP, and have a larger 
acreage for the recommended "regional center" recommended in the Village Center 
segment. 
Another thought that has been posed many times but does not seem to show up is 
the idea that HPP is the "bulge". All recommendations have made a road go 
through HPP. In reality, we really only need a second road out of HPP, but 
roads should be going both toward Hilo and toward Pahoa. Those roads don't have 
to connect in HPP. Drivers will connect them, but might use multiple routes if 
there is not one designated, thereby minimizing impact to private roads.
I have not "chimed in" before, and maybe its too late, but I guess I had to 
eventually get my two cents posted! 
       


Date: Sun, 20 Jan 2008 23:32:26 -0800From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] Re :ROW width for PMAR and additional cost 
considerationsAloha allThe discussion you are having is the reason why this 
coming meeting on Jan. 24 is important 3:30 pm @ KCC  starts with managing 
growth, then at 5:30 pm review w/ John Whelan and Chris Yuen...time for 
clarifications.Also Beach road is being targeted as the emergency access road 
out of lower Puna by Bruce McClure of Public Works. It will be a graded gravel 
road from what PCPC heardPrema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: 
Aloha,FYI, on Page 18 of 28 thru Page 21 of 28, the Puna CDP Transportation 
Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership addressed the issues, goals 
and objectives for connectivity along roadways in Puna. Amongst the list of 
roadways considered in Puna Makai, were:+ Government Beach Road+ Railroad 
Right-Of-Way+ Shower DriveI have enclosed the text of the recommendations for 
the above roadways, below.Also, on Page 29 of 47 of the Puna CDP Transportation 
Working Group Final Report - OVERVIEW, the Proposed Allowable Uses for Existing 
Roadways in Puna are recommended in TABLE 13.1.Source: Puna CDP Transportation 
Working Group Final Report - OVERVIEW (February 15, 2007)forward!devotion, 
prema+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++a. GOVERNMENT BEACH ROAD:i. ISSUE: 
Government Beach Road is impassable between the following point(s): Kahakai 
Blvd. to Maku`u and Shower Drive to Hilo.ii. GOAL: Government Beach Road serves 
as a "scenic coastal byway" connector route between Kapoho and Hilo.iii. 
OBJECTIVE: Transform Government Beach Road into a "scenic byway" and emergency 
evacuation route*.*In the event of a hurricane disaster it is likely that 
Highway 130 would be littered with a forest of utility poles, possibly 
rendering it impassable to all traffic. Under such circumstances, Government 
Beach Road would provide redundancy from Kalapana to Hilo.iv. RECOMMENDATIONS: 
The County, in cooperation with the State DOT, should apply for Federal "scenic 
byway" funding to:1. Pave Government Beach Road from Kapoho to Hilo, without 
the destruction of any significant trees with sensitive regard for the historic 
preservation of the Old Puna Trail.2. Re-open impassable sections of Government 
Beach Road between:a. Hawaiian Parks and Hawaiian Paradise Parkb. Hawaiian 
Paradise Park to Hilo3. Repair the coastal portion of Government Beach Road 
that is now blocked off between Maku`u Drive and Paradise Drive. This area is 
currently used for pedestrian travel only, but could be re-opened after repair 
of a short portion of the roadway along the coastal cliff where the County of 
Hawaii parcel is currently used for whale watching, fishing, and light 
recreational use.4. The entire scenic byway should be declared "restricted 
access" for passenger vehicles, mini-vans, paratransit buses, bicycles and 
pedestrians only, with a posted and enforced speed limit of 25 
mph.+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++b. RAILROAD RIGHT-OF-WAY (ROW):i. 
ISSUE: Portions of Railroad Avenue are impassable between Kapoho and Shower 
Drive.ii. GOAL: Railroad Avenue serves is a multi-modal pastoral experience, 
isolated from the manifestations of commerce and advertising, even when the 
road passes through populated areas from Kapoho to Hilo.iii. OBJECTIVE: Re-open 
Railroad Avenue at the following locations:1. Kapoho to Hawaiian Shores2. 
Hawaiian Beaches to Hawaiian Paradise Park3. Shower Drive to Railroad Avenue in 
Hiloiv. RECOMMENDATIONS:1. Pave and improve Railroad Avenue from Kapoho Road to 
Hawaiian Shores, clearing any blocked or impassible areas of the roadway along 
that route.2. Construct a connector roadway extension of Kehau Road, from the 
Nanawale subdivision to Railroad Avenue.3. Construct a greenscaped modern 
roundabout at the intersection of Kehau Road and Railroad Avenue.4. Improve and 
pave Railroad Avenue from Hawaiian Beaches to Hawaiian Paradise Park, clearing 
any blocked or impassible areas of the roadway along that route.5. Improve and 
pave Railroad Avenue from Hawaiian Paradise Park to the existing Railroad 
Avenue on the Hilo side of the W. H. Shipman properties at Milo Street.6. We 
endorse the Railroad Avenue Multi-Purpose Pathway, the Old Volcano Trail and 
the Safe Routes to School (SR2S) program.Note: This would complete the route 
along the former Railroad easement connecting Hawaiian Paradise Park and Hilo. 
Although Railroad Avenue no longer exists as a railroad easement across W. H. 
Shipman land, the use of the grade improvements and railway roadbed itself 
would be less expensive than construction of a new roadway.7. The County should 
construct a rock wall along the roadway from Hawaiian Paradise Park to the 
existing Railroad Avenue on the Hilo side of the W. H. Shipman properties at 
Milo Street to protect the current W.H. Shipman properties from agricultural 
theft.8. The entire Railroad Avenue multi-modal corridor should be declared 
"restricted access", exclusively for passenger vehicles, mini-vans, paratransit 
buses, bicycles and pedestrians, with a posted and enforced speed limit of 25 
mph.+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++c. SHOWER DRIVE:i. ISSUE: Shower 
Drive is a dead end roadway.ii. GOAL: An extension of Shower Drive to 17th 
Avenue facilitates connectivity for Puna Makai traffic, from the bottom of 
Hawaiian Paradise Park (by way of Kaloli Drive and/or Shower Drive) to the 
subdivisions mauka of Hwy 130.iii. OBJECTIVE: Improve access from Makai 
portions of Hawaiian Paradise Park to the subdivisions mauka of Highway 130.iv. 
RECOMMENDATIONS:1. Improve and extend Shower Drive to 17th Avenue.2. Construct 
a modern roundabout at the intersection of Shower Drive and Highway 130, 
providing a safe intersection and access to Pohaku Drive and mauka 
subdivisions.SOURCE:Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report - 
Existing RoadwaysFebruary 15, 
2007_______________________________________________Puna-wg-evaluation mailing 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation


Looking for last minute shopping deals? Find them fast with Yahoo! Search.
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to