On Feb 7, 2:46 pm, weloki <[email protected]> wrote: > I need to both build some new servers and rebuild some existing ones > keeping in mind I want to use Puppet. The question is which is the > best sequence to proceed with? > > A) Develop modules one by one and make sure each component works, then > assemble and test modules that need to talk to each other and make > sure those work together, all *before* building the servers. Then once > all the modules are completed and tested for each piece of > configuration and functionality needed at the systems level they can > be used to build each server automatically. > > B) Build the servers manually first and retrofit them with pre- > existing Puppet modules, hoping that the modules will just work AND > match how each system should be for your particular needs. > > C) Build the servers manually first and then develop the modules > needed to manage each one. > > Is there one way that saves more time? Is there one that lends a > higher degree of confidence everything will work as expected at the > end?
If you don't yet have any Puppet infrastructure then the shortest time to achieving operational servers is provided by (C), perhaps with a touch of (B) mixed in. Really, that's the only approach that makes sense unless you have a development lab in which to build and test your new Puppet infrastructure before deploying it, and enough time to use it. A development lab for this purpose could be virtual (e.g. Craig's VMs), but you're still looking at non-trivial time to get an interesting configuration together. As I already hinted, I don't think (B) and (C) are exclusive. If you're open to using third-party modules at all, then you should definitely seek existing modules that fulfill some of your requirements. As things currently stand, however, you should be prepared to tweak such modules for your own needs and for compatibility with other modules (whether local ones or other third- party ones). John -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Puppet Users" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/puppet-users?hl=en.
