Tim Peters <t...@python.org> added the comment:
Can't really know without a system to try it on, but my best guess is that these asserts are the only thing that will fail with tagging enabled. The obvious "fix" is indeed just to skip them on a platform with tagging enabled. They're meant as a sanity check that only 48 bits are really used for addresses. Which remains true even when tagging is enabled - the tag bits are part of the _pointer_ on AMD, but not part of the address. Taking tagging seriously instead would be a significant project, relying on platform-specific instructions. For a start, obmalloc would have to generate a random 4-bit integer for each object it returns, plug that into 4 specific "high order" bits of the pointer it returns, and tell the OS to associate those 4 bits with each 16-byte chunk of the object's space. mmap()-like calls would also need to be changed, to tell the OS to enable tag checking on the memory slice returned. While caching may or may not speed things up, I'm not seeing how it _could_ help move to 64-bit addresses. As is, the tree needs 8 bytes of bottom-node space for each arena in use, and that's independent of how many address bits there are (it only depends on the arena granularity). I think that could be cut by a factor of 4 by keeping track of arena pool (instead of byte) boundaries in the bottom nodes, meaning that, with the _current_ settings, we'd only need to keep track of the 64=2^6 possible pool addresses in an arena, instead of the 2^20 possible byte addresses. 6 bits fits fine in a signed 8-bit int (but we need a 32-bit int now to hold the 2^20 possible byte addresses in an arena). So the clearest way to ease the space burden of keeping track of truly expansive address spaces is to boost arena size. And, if the tree bottom changed to keep track of pool (instead of byte) addresses, possibly boost pool size too. ---------- _______________________________________ Python tracker <rep...@bugs.python.org> <https://bugs.python.org/issue43593> _______________________________________ _______________________________________________ Python-bugs-list mailing list Unsubscribe: https://mail.python.org/mailman/options/python-bugs-list/archive%40mail-archive.com
