> Do you have an example from boost-histogram..
One of the dev's here, and actually, I think "Hist" would use it, rather than
boost-histogram directly. In boost-histogram, axis are only represented by
numbers, so `h[{0:slice(2,5)}]` probably could not be written `h[0=2:5]` even
after this PEP; but we could have ax0, etc, for example. See the SciPy 2020 or
PyHEP 2020 talks for more examples. Hist extends boost-histogram and adds named
axes, where this would be _very_ useful. Now you could make a histogram:
```pyhton
h = Hist(axis.Regular(10,-1,1, name="x"), axis.Boolean(name="signal"))
h_signal= h[x=2:8, signal=True]
```
(of course, you could actually have a lot of axes, and you don't need to slice
all of them every time)
I realize now on further reading the PEP does discuss the idea, though I only
agree with one of the arguments; the slow part might be solvable, the
complexity issue is reversed (adding a new one-off rule ontop of the _already_
one-off rule for tuplizing arguments is more complex, IMO, than reusing
function syntax), the transition/mix could be done, the one where "*args" would
be needed to represent a tuple of arguments makes no sense to me (of course
that's how you should write a Python signature for a variable number of args,
that's not a downside). It would be reasonably easy to write a conversion
to/from `__getitem_func__`, and the end result would be a cleaner, nicer
language (in 10ish years?). There have been similar transitions in the past.
Furthermore, you currently can't tell the difference between `x[(a, b)]` and
`x[a, b]`; with the new function, libraries could differentiate, and maybe
eventually make them behave reasonably (you can always use x[*c] if you already
have a tuple, just like for a function, and it's one of the rare / only places
where list vs. tuple matters in Python).
Just some thoughts, still excited to see this become available in some form. :)
_______________________________________________
Python-ideas mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
https://mail.python.org/mailman3/lists/python-ideas.python.org/
Message archived at
https://mail.python.org/archives/list/[email protected]/message/QWJKM7FIS4K4KKPBXT3T7TT2ILV4LUUX/
Code of Conduct: http://python.org/psf/codeofconduct/
