On 10/3/20, Gertjan Klein <gkl...@xs4all.nl> wrote: > > I tried to find out what happens, using your other code: > > >>> import win32con, win32api > >>> access = win32con.PROCESS_QUERY_LIMITED_INFORMATION > >>> hproc = win32api.OpenProcess(access, False, pid) > >>> executable = win32process.GetModuleFileNameEx(hproc, None) > >>> print(executable) > C:\Temp\Python\Console\venv\Scripts\python.exe > >>> hproc = win32api.OpenProcess(access, False, os.getpid()) > >>> win32process.GetModuleFileNameEx(hproc, None) > 'C:\\dev\\Python\\Python38\\python.exe' > > So, if I understand this correctly, the console is owned by the venv > Python, but the running process is the installed Python executable. I'm > lost! How did that latter one get involved?
In Windows, venv defaults to copying binaries instead of creating symlinks. Starting with 3.7.2, venv copies a python.exe launcher (a custom build of the py.exe launcher) instead of copying the base executable and DLLs [1]. The launcher finds and spawns the base python.exe, and waits for it to exit. If you run the launcher from Explorer, it's the launcher that allocates and owns the console session. The base python.exe inherits the console session. The primary benefit of copying a launcher is that existing virtual environments don't have to be updated or recreated when the base installation is updated. The primary downside is that the parent process has a handle for and PID of the launcher process instead of the base Python process. This causes problems if the parent tries to manually duplicate a handle to the child, or vice versa, since it's actually duplicating the handle to the launcher process. This is particularly a problem for the multiprocessing module. It has to detect whether it's in a launcher-based virtual environment by comparing sys.executable with sys._base_executable. If they're different files, it executes sys._base_executable and sets the child's "__PYVENV_LAUNCHER__" environment variable to sys.executable (the venv launcher) in order to make it use the virtual environment. [1] https://docs.python.org/3.7/whatsnew/3.7.html#notable-changes-in-python-3-7-2 -- https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list