On Fri, 6 Nov 2026 09:28:53 +0530 <[email protected]> wrote: > From: Manish Honap <[email protected]> > > Hello, > > This series adds cxl-type2, an emulated CXL Type-2 device with volatile > device memory. It is emulated in such a way that all the Linux checks > are satisfied so that CXL passthrough using vfio-pci (vfio-cxl) can be > developed and tested in a guest without Type-2 hardware. > > This series builds on the Type-2 model from Zhi's series (carried in > Cédric's tree) and carries one fix from Shuai's tree. Shuai's tree also > set up the decoders through device properties and stubbed CXL Reset; the > firmware setup and CXL Reset here are new code. > Carried patches keep their authors, with a note for each change. > > The device: > - PCI ID 1b36:0017 and the processing accelerator class 0x1200; > - PCIe DVSEC for CXL Devices with CXL.cache, CXL.mem, one HDM range, > cache write-back and invalidate, CXL Reset and Mem Clr; Register > Locator and Flex Bus Port DVSECs; > - CXL.cache advertised but not modelled. The device sends no CXL.cache > requests, and its memory is host RAM, which is coherent already. A > cache write-back and invalidate completes at once. The capability is > set because vfio-cxl takes a device as Type-2 only when it reports > both CXL.cache and CXL.mem; > - component registers with one HDM decoder; > - slot 0, function 0 below a CXL root port of a pxb-cxl, memory in one > fixed memory window selected with fmw-index, cold plug only (no > hotplug or unplug), not migratable. > > No Linux driver claims the device on its own. cxl_pci does not bind to > the accelerator class, and sfc, the other driver that calls the CXL > core Type-2 interface, matches only its own devices. A guest binds > cxl-type2 to vfio-pci, which hands it to vfio-cxl. Testing the CXL core > Type-2 interface without vfio-cxl needs a driver for 1b36:0017 that > calls it. There is none yet. > > QEMU has no firmware that commits the HDM decoders of a CXL route at > boot, and Linux attaches a Type-2 device only to a committed region > (devm_cxl_probe_mem()). So QEMU does that step itself.
Just in case you missed it, Yukiya Takaki is looking at bios programmed flows. https://lore.kernel.org/all/[email protected]/ My immediate thought is follow a similar flow to the one I suggested in that patch. Doing CXL setup in QEMU but the PCI enumeration in the bios doesn't seem like a sustainable model to me. I'd much prefer to see a bios flow with just the QEMU generate tables updated in a similar fashion to how DSDT is updated for PXBs. Alternative for you (assuming you care more about arm than x86) might be to just use the SBSA model and do the full enumeration in firmware. Unfortunately I have quite a large backlog so might be a while before I get a chance to take a close look at this series (or the kernel ones!) Jonathan
