Hi,
Thanks to Greg, Patrick, Nicolas and Nyall for the good discussion.
I never used lat/lon based layouts before and the result can be odd. I
was trying to make it work, but it is not easy. The layout must include
a warning about the difference in scales along the axes.
As Nyall said, additional logic could be added to detect scale changes
along different directions. That introduces newer configurable
parameters to decide the percentage of change to warn the users.
I think that it would be enough to warn users when they start a layout
with a lat/lon coordinate system. The warning can be as simple as:
"Please consider the usage of a projected CRS for your layout. Be aware
that lat/lon printed maps can have different scales on the x and y axes.".
Regards,
Jorge
On 07/04/22 02:51, Nicolas Cadieux via Qgis-user wrote:
Hi Nyall,
That would be a "nice to have"!
Nicolas
On 2022-04-06 9:13 p.m., Nyall Dawson via Qgis-user wrote:
On Thu, 7 Apr 2022 at 10:26, Greg Troxel <g...@lexort.com> wrote:
Nyall Dawson <nyall.daw...@gmail.com> writes:
In all cases (projected OR geographic) the scalebar logic is:
1. Create a horizontal line across the width of the layout map
2. Calculate the length of that line using great circle/ellipsoidal
calculations, based on the project's ellipsoid settings.
3. Compare the length of the ellipsoidal line vs the map width to
calculate the corresponding scale
That is a very straightforward approach with easy-to-understand
semantics.
So qgis scalebar calculations are ALWAYS based on great
circle/ellipsoidal lengths*.
And more precisely, a true geodesic between two points varying in x and
with constant y in the layout CRS. For north-up (at least ish)
projections, that means a line of constant latitude.
For a lat/lon CRS in the layout, at mid latitudes, it's going to mean
that the scale in the y axis is smaller by about 110km/70km; a
square in
lat/lon is taller than it is wide (and plus it's not a square, but
that's less obvious). Equivalently, a square on the ground has a
larger
difference in longitude than it does in latitude. Or maybe I have that
backward, but using lat/lon in a layout does not preserve shapes.
This is what I was trying to get at: a single concept of scale is
really
only valid for a projection that has the same scale in x and y.
Which I
think is true iff the projection is conformal. And it's only truly
valid if the scale doesn't change over the layout, which is probably
~never exactly true, but many projections aim to have it remain close
enough to be treated as constant (e.g. UTM).
Which is a long way of getting around to "if you are using lat/lon as
the axes in your layout, either you are doing something odd on purpose
or you probably should rethink your approach." If you really do mean
it, I would find the explanation of why interesting.
All correct, indeed!
I've been thinking about introducing a new warning when exporting
layouts, which would look something like this:
1. For each scale bar, look at the referenced map
2. Measure the scale using multiple lines, each across the
top/middle/bottom horizontally and left/center/right vertically
3. Compare these scale values, and if any differ by more than XXX %
then show a warning to the user. Something like "The scale for map 1
varies from 1:xxxx to 1:yyyyy across different parts of the map.
Consider using an alternative form of representing the map scale (such
as a grid overlay), as the scale bar may be misleading for this map."
What do you think?
Nyall
* Unless the project itself is set to not use ellipsoidal calculations
and only use planar calculations, in the project properties dialog
Presumably those calculations are in the project CRS's xy space, and
would typically (when used sensibly) be grid distance in UTM, some
State
Plane Coordinate System, or similar.
_______________________________________________
Qgis-user mailing list
Qgis-user@lists.osgeo.org
List info: https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-user
Unsubscribe: https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-user
_______________________________________________
Qgis-user mailing list
Qgis-user@lists.osgeo.org
List info: https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-user
Unsubscribe: https://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-user
