Dear Ákos,

Thank you so much for the suggestions! I ended up using the function
described in https://rcompanion.org/r_script_deprecated/pairwiseRobustTest.r
as suggested by a response to my post on
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/78800048/error-using-mcp2atm-function-for-robust-pairwise-comparisons-undefined-columns.
It ran perfectly, and the analysis makes all sense!

Best,
Renato


*Renato Filogonio*
http://lattes.cnpq.br/0339937732653268




On Sun, Jul 28, 2024 at 12:30 AM Bede-Fazekas Ákos <bfalevl...@gmail.com>
wrote:

> Dear Renato,
>
> It's good to hear that the original error disappeared. Regarding the new
> error, I have no idea, maybe some members of the mailing list are
> familiar with this packages/function and can help you.
> In the meantime, you might want to try calling traceback() right after
> the error. It may help you figure out the origin of this error. Also you
> can check the source code of smmcrit()
> (https://rdrr.io/cran/WRS2/src/R/smmcrit.R) and mcp2atm()
> (https://rdrr.io/rforge/WRS2/src/R/mcp2atm.R) to understand the
> not-too-informative error message.
>
> Have a nice weekend,
> Ákos
> ______________
> Ákos Bede-Fazekas
> Centre for Ecological Research, Hungary
>
>
> 2024. 07. 28. 3:49 keltezéssel, Renato Filogonio írta:
> > Dear Ákos,
> > Thank you so much for your response. I tried your suggestion and it did
> > solve that error message from before, but another message appears now:
> >
> > Error in smmcrit(df, ncol(con)) : C must be less than or equal to 28
> >
> > I tried to look for the correction of this error, but I could not find it
> > anywhere.
> > The t2way() function works fine as before, but the mcp2atm() function is
> > still problematic. I put below the dataset used for this analysis.
> >
> > i   t   c   fr0   Warm    1   050  Warm    1   2100 Warm    1   6150
> > Warm    1   16200 Warm    1   20250 Warm    1   24300 Warm    1
> > 26350 Warm    1   28400 Warm    1   32450 Warm    1   34500 Warm    1
> >   36550 Warm    1   38600 Warm    1   40650 Warm    1   42700 Warm    1
> >    44750 Warm    1   46800 Warm    1   46850 Warm    1   48900 Warm
> > 1   48950 Warm    1   461000    Warm    1   421050    Warm    1
> > 321100    Warm    1   421150    Warm    1   381200    Warm    1
> > 281250    Warm    1   281300    Warm    1   280   Warm    2   050
> > Warm    2   0100 Warm    2   0150 Warm    2   0200 Warm    2   0250
> > Warm    2   2300 Warm    2   6350 Warm    2   12400 Warm    2   20450
> > Warm    2   30500 Warm    2   38550 Warm    2   46600 Warm    2
> > 54650 Warm    2   60700 Warm    2   64750 Warm    2   68800 Warm    2
> >   72850 Warm    2   76900 Warm    2   78950 Warm    2   801000    Warm
> >    2   821050    Warm    2   841100    Warm    2   881150    Warm    2
> >   901200    Warm    2   941250    Warm    2   941300    Warm    2   960
> >    Warm    3   050  Warm    3   6100 Warm    3   16150 Warm    3
> > 22200 Warm    3   28250 Warm    3   32300 Warm    3   38350 Warm    3
> >   42400 Warm    3   46450 Warm    3   50500 Warm    3   54550 Warm    3
> >    58600 Warm    3   62650 Warm    3   66700 Warm    3   68750 Warm
> > 3   72800 Warm    3   76850 Warm    3   78900 Warm    3   82950 Warm
> >   3   841000    Warm    3   861050    Warm    3   881100    Warm    3
> > 921150    Warm    3   941200    Warm    3   961250    Warm    3
> > 981300    Warm    3   1020   Warm    4   650  Warm    4   10100 Warm
> >   4   12150 Warm    4   14200 Warm    4   16250 Warm    4   20300 Warm
> >    4   22350 Warm    4   26400 Warm    4   26450 Warm    4   30500 Warm
> >     4   32550 Warm    4   34600 Warm    4   36650 Warm    4   38700
> > Warm    4   40750 Warm    4   42800 Warm    4   46850 Warm    4
> > 48900 Warm    4   50950 Warm    4   501000    Warm    4   521050
> > Warm    4   561100    Warm    4   581150    Warm    4   581200    Warm
> >     4   621250    Warm    4   621300    Warm    4   660   Warm    5
> > 050  Warm    5   0100 Warm    5   8150 Warm    5   16200 Warm    5
> > 20250 Warm    5   26300 Warm    5   30350 Warm    5   34400 Warm    5
> >   38450 Warm    5   42500 Warm    5   46550 Warm    5   52600 Warm    5
> >    54650 Warm    5   58700 Warm    5   60750 Warm    5   64800 Warm
> > 5   68850 Warm    5   70900 Warm    5   72950 Warm    5   761000
> > Warm    5   761050    Warm    5   781100    Warm    5   821150    Warm
> >     5   841200    Warm    5   821250    Warm    5   741300    Warm    5
> >    720   Warm    6   050  Warm    6   2100 Warm    6   10150 Warm    6
> >   16200 Warm    6   22250 Warm    6   26300 Warm    6   34350 Warm    6
> >    34400 Warm    6   38450 Warm    6   42500 Warm    6   44550 Warm
> > 6   48600 Warm    6   52650 Warm    6   54700 Warm    6   58750 Warm
> >   6   60800 Warm    6   62850 Warm    6   66900 Warm    6   68950 Warm
> >    6   701000    Warm    6   721050    Warm    6   761100    Warm    6
> >   781150    Warm    6   801200    Warm    6   821250    Warm    6
> > 841300    Warm    6   840   Warm    7   050  Warm    7   2100 Warm
> > 7   10150 Warm    7   16200 Warm    7   22250 Warm    7   30300 Warm
> >   7   36350 Warm    7   40400 Warm    7   46450 Warm    7   54500 Warm
> >    7   58550 Warm    7   64600 Warm    7   68650 Warm    7   74700 Warm
> >     7   80750 Warm    7   84800 Warm    7   90850 Warm    7   94900
> > Warm    7   100950 Warm    7   1041000    Warm    7   1081050    Warm
> >    7   1121100    Warm    7   1161150    Warm    7   1201200    Warm
> > 7   1221250    Warm    7   1261300    Warm    7   1280   Warm    8
> > 050  Warm    8   0100 Warm    8   0150 Warm    8   0200 Warm    8
> > 0250 Warm    8   0300 Warm    8   0350 Warm    8   0400 Warm    8
> > 0450 Warm    8   0500 Warm    8   0550 Warm    8   0600 Warm    8
> > 0650 Warm    8   0700 Warm    8   0750 Warm    8   0800 Warm    8
> > 0850 Warm    8   2900 Warm    8   6950 Warm    8   101000    Warm    8
> >    141050    Warm    8   201100    Warm    8   241150    Warm    8
> > 281200    Warm    8   321250    Warm    8   361300    Warm    8   420
> >   Warm    9   050  Warm    9   0100 Warm    9   0150 Warm    9   4200
> > Warm    9   10250 Warm    9   14300 Warm    9   18350 Warm    9
> > 22400 Warm    9   26450 Warm    9   30500 Warm    9   32550 Warm    9
> >   34600 Warm    9   38650 Warm    9   40700 Warm    9   44750 Warm    9
> >    46800 Warm    9   48850 Warm    9   50900 Warm    9   54950 Warm
> > 9   561000    Warm    9   581050    Warm    9   601100    Warm    9
> > 621150    Warm    9   641200    Warm    9   641250    Warm    9
> > 661300    Warm    9   680   Warm    10  050  Warm    10  0100 Warm
> > 10  0150 Warm    10  0200 Warm    10  0250 Warm    10  0300 Warm    10
> >   4350 Warm    10  12400 Warm    10  20450 Warm    10  28500 Warm    10
> >   34550 Warm    10  38600 Warm    10  44650 Warm    10  48700 Warm
> > 10  52750 Warm    10  56800 Warm    10  60850 Warm    10  64900 Warm
> >   10  64950 Warm    10  681000    Warm    10  701050    Warm    10
> > 741100    Warm    10  761150    Warm    10  761200    Warm    10
> > 781250    Warm    10  801300    Warm    10  800   Warm    11  050
> > Warm    11  0100 Warm    11  0150 Warm    11  6200 Warm    11  16250
> > Warm    11  26300 Warm    11  34350 Warm    11  42400 Warm    11
> > 48450 Warm    11  56500 Warm    11  62550 Warm    11  68600 Warm    11
> >   74650 Warm    11  80700 Warm    11  86750 Warm    11  92800 Warm
> > 11  96850 Warm    11  102900 Warm    11  108950 Warm    11  1121000
> > Warm    11  1161050    Warm    11  1221100    Warm    11  1241150
> > Warm    11  1301200    Warm    11  1341250    Warm    11  1381300
> > Warm    11  1420   Warm    12  050  Warm    12  0100 Warm    12  0150
> > Warm    12  0200 Warm    12  0250 Warm    12  6300 Warm    12  12350
> > Warm    12  16400 Warm    12  20450 Warm    12  24500 Warm    12
> > 26550 Warm    12  30600 Warm    12  32650 Warm    12  36700 Warm    12
> >   38750 Warm    12  42800 Warm    12  44850 Warm    12  46900 Warm
> > 12  50950 Warm    12  521000    Warm    12  541050    Warm    12
> > 561100    Warm    12  581150    Warm    12  621200    Warm    12
> > 641250    Warm    12  661300    Warm    12  700   Warm    13  050
> > Warm    13  14100 Warm    13  26150 Warm    13  38200 Warm    13
> > 46250 Warm    13  54300 Warm    13  62350 Warm    13  68400 Warm    13
> >   74450 Warm    13  76500 Warm    13  82550 Warm    13  82600 Warm
> > 13  88650 Warm    13  92700 Warm    13  94750 Warm    13  92800 Warm
> >   13  92850 Warm    13  100900 Warm    13  108950 Warm    13  1041000
> >   Warm    13  1021050    Warm    13  961100    Warm    13  561150
> > Warm    13  401200    Warm    13  381250    Warm    13  341300    Warm
> >     13  300   Warm    14  050  Warm    14  8100 Warm    14  14150 Warm
> >    14  18200 Warm    14  20250 Warm    14  24300 Warm    14  26350 Warm
> >     14  30400 Warm    14  32450 Warm    14  34500 Warm    14  38550
> > Warm    14  40600 Warm    14  42650 Warm    14  44700 Warm    14
> > 46750 Warm    14  48800 Warm    14  50850 Warm    14  52900 Warm    14
> >   54950 Warm    14  541000    Warm    14  561050    Warm    14  581100
> >    Warm    14  601150    Warm    14  601200    Warm    14  621250
> > Warm    14  641300    Warm    14  660   Warm    15  1050  Warm    15
> > 42100 Warm    15  112150 Warm    15  178200 Warm    15  204250 Warm
> > 15  220300 Warm    15  234350 Warm    15  244400 Warm    15  252450
> > Warm    15  260500 Warm    15  264550 Warm    15  268600 Warm    15
> > 268650 Warm    15  268700 Warm    15  266750 Warm    15  256800 Warm
> >   15  188850 Warm    15  136900 Warm    15  100950 Warm    15  801000
> >   Warm    15  661050    Warm    15  641100    Warm    15  421150
> > Warm    15  381200    Warm    15  321250    Warm    15  281300    Warm
> >     15  240   Warm    16  050  Warm    16  0100 Warm    16  0150 Warm
> >   16  10200 Warm    16  18250 Warm    16  24300 Warm    16  32350 Warm
> >    16  38400 Warm    16  44450 Warm    16  48500 Warm    16  54550 Warm
> >     16  58600 Warm    16  62650 Warm    16  66700 Warm    16  70750
> > Warm    16  74800 Warm    16  78850 Warm    16  80900 Warm    16
> > 84950 Warm    16  861000    Warm    16  901050    Warm    16  921100
> >   Warm    16  961150    Warm    16  981200    Warm    16  1021250
> > Warm    16  1021300    Warm    16  1040   Warm    17  050  Warm    17
> > 0100 Warm    17  0150 Warm    17  0200 Warm    17  0250 Warm    17
> > 0300 Warm    17  4350 Warm    17  10400 Warm    17  14450 Warm    17
> > 20500 Warm    17  24550 Warm    17  28600 Warm    17  32650 Warm    17
> >   36700 Warm    17  40750 Warm    17  44800 Warm    17  46850 Warm
> > 17  50900 Warm    17  54950 Warm    17  561000    Warm    17  601050
> >   Warm    17  621100    Warm    17  641150    Warm    17  681200
> > Warm    17  701250    Warm    17  741300    Warm    17  760   Warm
> > 18  050  Warm    18  0100 Warm    18  0150 Warm    18  0200 Warm    18
> >   0250 Warm    18  0300 Warm    18  0350 Warm    18  0400 Warm    18
> > 0450 Warm    18  0500 Warm    18  0550 Warm    18  0600 Warm    18
> > 0650 Warm    18  0700 Warm    18  4750 Warm    18  10800 Warm    18
> > 14850 Warm    18  18900 Warm    18  22950 Warm    18  241000    Warm
> >   18  281050    Warm    18  301100    Warm    18  321150    Warm    18
> > 341200    Warm    18  361250    Warm    18  381300    Warm    18  420
> >   Warm    19  050  Warm    19  14100 Warm    19  26150 Warm    19
> > 38200 Warm    19  46250 Warm    19  54300 Warm    19  62350 Warm    19
> >   68400 Warm    19  74450 Warm    19  76500 Warm    19  82550 Warm
> > 19  82600 Warm    19  88650 Warm    19  92700 Warm    19  94750 Warm
> >   19  92800 Warm    19  92850 Warm    19  100900 Warm    19  108950
> > Warm    19  1041000    Warm    19  1021050    Warm    19  961100
> > Warm    19  561150    Warm    19  401200    Warm    19  381250    Warm
> >     19  341300    Warm    19  300   Warm    20  1250  Warm    20  22100
> > Warm    20  28150 Warm    20  34200 Warm    20  42250 Warm    20
> > 48300 Warm    20  54350 Warm    20  60400 Warm    20  66450 Warm    20
> >   70500 Warm    20  74550 Warm    20  78600 Warm    20  82650 Warm
> > 20  88700 Warm    20  92750 Warm    20  96800 Warm    20  98850 Warm
> >   20  102900 Warm    20  104950 Warm    20  1061000    Warm    20
> > 1101050    Warm    20  1121100    Warm    20  1141150    Warm    20
> > 1161200    Warm    20  1181250    Warm    20  1201300    Warm    20
> > 1200   Warm    21  050  Warm    21  0100 Warm    21  14150 Warm    21
> > 26200 Warm    21  32250 Warm    21  38300 Warm    21  44350 Warm    21
> >   48400 Warm    21  52450 Warm    21  54500 Warm    21  58550 Warm
> > 21  60600 Warm    21  62650 Warm    21  66700 Warm    21  68750 Warm
> >   21  70800 Warm    21  72850 Warm    21  74900 Warm    21  76950 Warm
> >    21  761000    Warm    21  781050    Warm    21  801100    Warm    21
> >   801150    Warm    21  801200    Warm    21  821250    Warm    21
> > 821300    Warm    21  820   Warm    22  050  Warm    22  2100 Warm
> > 22  12150 Warm    22  16200 Warm    22  22250 Warm    22  26300 Warm
> >   22  30350 Warm    22  32400 Warm    22  36450 Warm    22  38500 Warm
> >    22  40550 Warm    22  44600 Warm    22  46650 Warm    22  48700 Warm
> >     22  50750 Warm    22  50800 Warm    22  52850 Warm    22  54900
> > Warm    22  56950 Warm    22  581000    Warm    22  581050    Warm
> > 22  601100    Warm    22  601150    Warm    22  621200    Warm    22
> > 641250    Warm    22  641300    Warm    22  660   Warm    23  050
> > Warm    23  0100 Warm    23  0150 Warm    23  6200 Warm    23  18250
> > Warm    23  26300 Warm    23  36350 Warm    23  44400 Warm    23
> > 48450 Warm    23  58500 Warm    23  64550 Warm    23  72600 Warm    23
> >   76650 Warm    23  82700 Warm    23  88750 Warm    23  92800 Warm
> > 23  96850 Warm    23  102900 Warm    23  108950 Warm    23  1141000
> > Warm    23  1181050    Warm    23  1241100    Warm    23  1281150
> > Warm    23  1321200    Warm    23  1361250    Warm    23  1401300
> > Warm    23  1460   Warm    24  050  Warm    24  0100 Warm    24  0150
> > Warm    24  0200 Warm    24  0250 Warm    24  0300 Warm    24  10350
> > Warm    24  16400 Warm    24  22450 Warm    24  28500 Warm    24
> > 32550 Warm    24  36600 Warm    24  40650 Warm    24  44700 Warm    24
> >   48750 Warm    24  50800 Warm    24  54850 Warm    24  56900 Warm
> > 24  58950 Warm    24  621000    Warm    24  641050    Warm    24
> > 661100    Warm    24  681150    Warm    24  701200    Warm    24
> > 721250    Warm    24  741300    Warm    24  760   Warm    25  050
> > Warm    25  6100 Warm    25  10150 Warm    25  14200 Warm    25  18250
> > Warm    25  20300 Warm    25  24350 Warm    25  26400 Warm    25
> > 28450 Warm    25  30500 Warm    25  34550 Warm    25  36600 Warm    25
> >   36650 Warm    25  40700 Warm    25  42750 Warm    25  42800 Warm
> > 25  46850 Warm    25  46900 Warm    25  48950 Warm    25  501000
> > Warm    25  501050    Warm    25  521100    Warm    25  541150    Warm
> >     25  561200    Warm    25  561250    Warm    25  581300    Warm
> > 25  600   Warm    26  1050  Warm    26  18100 Warm    26  28150 Warm
> >   26  34200 Warm    26  44250 Warm    26  52300 Warm    26  60350 Warm
> >    26  68400 Warm    26  76450 Warm    26  82500 Warm    26  90550 Warm
> >     26  98600 Warm    26  102650 Warm    26  108700 Warm    26  112750
> > Warm    26  116800 Warm    26  120850 Warm    26  122900 Warm    26
> > 126950 Warm    26  1261000    Warm    26  1301050    Warm    26
> > 1321100    Warm    26  1341150    Warm    26  1361200    Warm    26
> > 1381250    Warm    26  1381300    Warm    26  1400   Warm    27  050
> > Warm    27  0100 Warm    27  4150 Warm    27  14200 Warm    27  24250
> > Warm    27  32300 Warm    27  38350 Warm    27  46400 Warm    27
> > 48450 Warm    27  54500 Warm    27  62550 Warm    27  66600 Warm    27
> >   72650 Warm    27  78700 Warm    27  82750 Warm    27  86800 Warm
> > 27  92850 Warm    27  96900 Warm    27  100950 Warm    27  1061000
> > Warm    27  1081050    Warm    27  1121100    Warm    27  1161150
> > Warm    27  1201200    Warm    27  1241250    Warm    27  1281300
> > Warm    27  1320   Warm    28  1650  Warm    28  28100 Warm    28
> > 42150 Warm    28  56200 Warm    28  70250 Warm    28  82300 Warm    28
> >   94350 Warm    28  106400 Warm    28  114450 Warm    28  126500 Warm
> >   28  130550 Warm    28  138600 Warm    28  144650 Warm    28  150700
> > Warm    28  154750 Warm    28  156800 Warm    28  158850 Warm    28
> > 164900 Warm    28  162950 Warm    28  1701000    Warm    28  1681050
> >   Warm    28  1701100    Warm    28  1721150    Warm    28  1721200
> > Warm    28  1721250    Warm    28  1721300    Warm    28  1700   Warm
> >    29  1050  Warm    29  16100 Warm    29  26150 Warm    29  30200 Warm
> >     29  38250 Warm    29  46300 Warm    29  50350 Warm    29  58400
> > Warm    29  64450 Warm    29  70500 Warm    29  76550 Warm    29
> > 82600 Warm    29  88650 Warm    29  92700 Warm    29  98750 Warm    29
> >   102800 Warm    29  106850 Warm    29  110900 Warm    29  116950 Warm
> >    29  1201000    Warm    29  1221050    Warm    29  1261100    Warm
> > 29  1281150    Warm    29  1281200    Warm    29  1321250    Warm
> > 29  1321300    Warm    29  1320   Warm    30  050  Warm    30  6100
> > Warm    30  12150 Warm    30  16200 Warm    30  20250 Warm    30
> > 22300 Warm    30  26350 Warm    30  28400 Warm    30  32450 Warm    30
> >   34500 Warm    30  36550 Warm    30  38600 Warm    30  42650 Warm
> > 30  44700 Warm    30  46750 Warm    30  48800 Warm    30  50850 Warm
> >   30  52900 Warm    30  56950 Warm    30  581000    Warm    30  601050
> >    Warm    30  621100    Warm    30  641150    Warm    30  661200
> > Warm    30  681250    Warm    30  721300    Warm    30  740   Warm
> > 31  050  Warm    31  0100 Warm    31  0150 Warm    31  0200 Warm    31
> >   0250 Warm    31  10300 Warm    31  22350 Warm    31  30400 Warm    31
> >   38450 Warm    31  46500 Warm    31  52550 Warm    31  60600 Warm
> > 31  64650 Warm    31  72700 Warm    31  76750 Warm    31  82800 Warm
> >   31  86850 Warm    31  92900 Warm    31  96950 Warm    31  1001000
> > Warm    31  1061050    Warm    31  1101100    Warm    31  1141150
> > Warm    31  1161200    Warm    31  1221250    Warm    31  1241300
> > Warm    31  1260   Warm    32  850  Warm    32  16100 Warm    32
> > 24150 Warm    32  32200 Warm    32  38250 Warm    32  46300 Warm    32
> >   52350 Warm    32  58400 Warm    32  62450 Warm    32  68500 Warm
> > 32  72550 Warm    32  76600 Warm    32  80650 Warm    32  84700 Warm
> >   32  88750 Warm    32  90800 Warm    32  94850 Warm    32  94900 Warm
> >    32  96950 Warm    32  981000    Warm    32  1001050    Warm    32
> > 1021100    Warm    32  1001150    Warm    32  1001200    Warm    32
> > 961250    Warm    32  761300    Warm    32  620   Warm    33  050
> > Warm    33  0100 Warm    33  4150 Warm    33  14200 Warm    33  18250
> > Warm    33  24300 Warm    33  30350 Warm    33  36400 Warm    33
> > 40450 Warm    33  44500 Warm    33  50550 Warm    33  54600 Warm    33
> >   58650 Warm    33  60700 Warm    33  66750 Warm    33  70800 Warm
> > 33  74850 Warm    33  78900 Warm    33  80950 Warm    33  841000
> > Warm    33  881050    Warm    33  921100    Warm    33  961150    Warm
> >     33  981200    Warm    33  1021250    Warm    33  1041300    Warm
> > 33  1080   Cold    34  050  Cold    34  0100 Cold    34  0150 Cold
> > 34  0200 Cold    34  0250 Cold    34  0300 Cold    34  6350 Cold    34
> >   10400 Cold    34  12450 Cold    34  16500 Cold    34  18550 Cold
> > 34  20600 Cold    34  22650 Cold    34  24700 Cold    34  26750 Cold
> >   34  28800 Cold    34  30850 Cold    34  32900 Cold    34  34950 Cold
> >    34  361000    Cold    34  381050    Cold    34  381100    Cold    34
> >   401150    Cold    34  421200    Cold    34  441250    Cold    34
> > 461300    Cold    34  460   Cold    35  050  Cold    35  0100 Cold
> > 35  4150 Cold    35  10200 Cold    35  16250 Cold    35  20300 Cold
> > 35  24350 Cold    35  28400 Cold    35  32450 Cold    35  34500 Cold
> >   35  38550 Cold    35  42600 Cold    35  44650 Cold    35  48700 Cold
> >    35  50750 Cold    35  54800 Cold    35  56850 Cold    35  58900 Cold
> >     35  60950 Cold    35  621000    Cold    35  661050    Cold    35
> > 681100    Cold    35  681150    Cold    35  721200    Cold    35
> > 721250    Cold    35  741300    Cold    35  760   Cold    36  050
> > Cold    36  0100 Cold    36  6150 Cold    36  8200 Cold    36  8250
> > Cold    36  8300 Cold    36  10350 Cold    36  10400 Cold    36  10450
> > Cold    36  12500 Cold    36  12550 Cold    36  12600 Cold    36
> > 14650 Cold    36  14700 Cold    36  14750 Cold    36  14800 Cold    36
> >   16850 Cold    36  16900 Cold    36  16950 Cold    36  161000    Cold
> >    36  161050    Cold    36  161100    Cold    36  161150    Cold    36
> >   161200    Cold    36  161250    Cold    36  141300    Cold    36  160
> >    Cold    37  050  Cold    37  0100 Cold    37  0150 Cold    37  4200
> > Cold    37  16250 Cold    37  20300 Cold    37  24350 Cold    37
> > 26400 Cold    37  30450 Cold    37  36500 Cold    37  38550 Cold    37
> >   42600 Cold    37  44650 Cold    37  46700 Cold    37  50750 Cold
> > 37  50800 Cold    37  52850 Cold    37  54900 Cold    37  42950 Cold
> >   37  401000    Cold    37  361050    Cold    37  381100    Cold    37
> > 281150    Cold    37  301200    Cold    37  381250    Cold    37
> > 321300    Cold    37  280   Cold    38  050  Cold    38  0100 Cold
> > 38  0150 Cold    38  0200 Cold    38  0250 Cold    38  0300 Cold    38
> >   0350 Cold    38  0400 Cold    38  0450 Cold    38  0500 Cold    38
> > 2550 Cold    38  10600 Cold    38  16650 Cold    38  20700 Cold    38
> > 24750 Cold    38  26800 Cold    38  28850 Cold    38  32900 Cold    38
> >   34950 Cold    38  361000    Cold    38  401050    Cold    38  421100
> >    Cold    38  441150    Cold    38  461200    Cold    38  481250
> > Cold    38  501300    Cold    38  540   Cold    39  850  Cold    39
> > 12100 Cold    39  24150 Cold    39  32200 Cold    39  44250 Cold    39
> >   54300 Cold    39  72350 Cold    39  80400 Cold    39  60450 Cold
> > 39  100500 Cold    39  64550 Cold    39  54600 Cold    39  52650 Cold
> >    39  38700 Cold    39  34750 Cold    39  36800 Cold    39  34850 Cold
> >     39  28900 Cold    39  24950 Cold    39  221000    Cold    39
> > 201050    Cold    39  241100    Cold    39  221150    Cold    39
> > 221200    Cold    39  241250    Cold    39  261300    Cold    39  200
> >   Cold    40  050  Cold    40  0100 Cold    40  2150 Cold    40  10200
> > Cold    40  16250 Cold    40  20300 Cold    40  24350 Cold    40
> > 28400 Cold    40  32450 Cold    40  36500 Cold    40  38550 Cold    40
> >   42600 Cold    40  44650 Cold    40  44700 Cold    40  44750 Cold
> > 40  36800 Cold    40  28850 Cold    40  32900 Cold    40  30950 Cold
> >   40  321000    Cold    40  261050    Cold    40  181100    Cold    40
> > 281150    Cold    40  261200    Cold    40  261250    Cold    40
> > 241300    Cold    40  220   Cold    41  050  Cold    41  0100 Cold
> > 41  4150 Cold    41  14200 Cold    41  20250 Cold    41  26300 Cold
> > 41  30350 Cold    41  36400 Cold    41  40450 Cold    41  42500 Cold
> >   41  46550 Cold    41  50600 Cold    41  54650 Cold    41  58700 Cold
> >    41  60750 Cold    41  64800 Cold    41  68850 Cold    41  70900 Cold
> >     41  74950 Cold    41  761000    Cold    41  801050    Cold    41
> > 821100    Cold    41  841150    Cold    41  881200    Cold    41
> > 901250    Cold    41  921300    Cold    41  960   Cold    42  050
> > Cold    42  12100 Cold    42  26150 Cold    42  38200 Cold    42
> > 46250 Cold    42  54300 Cold    42  62350 Cold    42  70400 Cold    42
> >   76450 Cold    42  84500 Cold    42  92550 Cold    42  98600 Cold
> > 42  106650 Cold    42  110700 Cold    42  118750 Cold    42  124800
> > Cold    42  130850 Cold    42  136900 Cold    42  140950 Cold    42
> > 1441000    Cold    42  1521050    Cold    42  1561100    Cold    42
> > 1621150    Cold    42  1661200    Cold    42  1701250    Cold    42
> > 1741300    Cold    42  1800   Cold    43  050  Cold    43  0100 Cold
> >   43  0150 Cold    43  0200 Cold    43  0250 Cold    43  0300 Cold
> > 43  0350 Cold    43  6400 Cold    43  8450 Cold    43  14500 Cold
> > 43  18550 Cold    43  22600 Cold    43  24650 Cold    43  28700 Cold
> >   43  30750 Cold    43  34800 Cold    43  36850 Cold    43  38900 Cold
> >    43  40950 Cold    43  421000    Cold    43  441050    Cold    43
> > 461100    Cold    43  481150    Cold    43  501200    Cold    43
> > 521250    Cold    43  541300    Cold    43  560   Cold    44  050
> > Cold    44  0100 Cold    44  0150 Cold    44  8200 Cold    44  16250
> > Cold    44  24300 Cold    44  30350 Cold    44  36400 Cold    44
> > 40450 Cold    44  46500 Cold    44  52550 Cold    44  58600 Cold    44
> >   62650 Cold    44  66700 Cold    44  70750 Cold    44  74800 Cold
> > 44  82850 Cold    44  84900 Cold    44  94950 Cold    44  1021000
> > Cold    44  1061050    Cold    44  1121100    Cold    44  1161150
> > Cold    44  1221200    Cold    44  1201250    Cold    44  1241300
> > Cold    44  1300   Cold    45  050  Cold    45  0100 Cold    45  0150
> > Cold    45  0200 Cold    45  8250 Cold    45  14300 Cold    45  20350
> > Cold    45  24400 Cold    45  30450 Cold    45  34500 Cold    45
> > 40550 Cold    45  44600 Cold    45  48650 Cold    45  52700 Cold    45
> >   56750 Cold    45  60800 Cold    45  64850 Cold    45  70900 Cold
> > 45  74950 Cold    45  781000    Cold    45  821050    Cold    45
> > 861100    Cold    45  921150    Cold    45  941200    Cold    45
> > 981250    Cold    45  1021300    Cold    45  1060   Cold    46  050
> > Cold    46  0100 Cold    46  0150 Cold    46  0200 Cold    46  0250
> > Cold    46  0300 Cold    46  0350 Cold    46  0400 Cold    46  0450
> > Cold    46  0500 Cold    46  0550 Cold    46  0600 Cold    46  0650
> > Cold    46  0700 Cold    46  0750 Cold    46  0800 Cold    46  0850
> > Cold    46  2900 Cold    46  2950 Cold    46  21000    Cold    46
> > 21050    Cold    46  41100    Cold    46  21150    Cold    46  41200
> >   Cold    46  41250    Cold    46  41300    Cold    46  40   Cold    47
> >   050  Cold    47  0100 Cold    47  0150 Cold    47  0200 Cold    47
> > 0250 Cold    47  0300 Cold    47  0350 Cold    47  0400 Cold    47
> > 4450 Cold    47  10500 Cold    47  16550 Cold    47  24600 Cold    47
> > 28650 Cold    47  36700 Cold    47  40750 Cold    47  44800 Cold    47
> >   48850 Cold    47  52900 Cold    47  56950 Cold    47  601000    Cold
> >    47  641050    Cold    47  661100    Cold    47  701150    Cold    47
> >   721200    Cold    47  761250    Cold    47  781300    Cold    47  780
> >    Cold    48  050  Cold    48  0100 Cold    48  0150 Cold    48  0200
> > Cold    48  8250 Cold    48  10300 Cold    48  18350 Cold    48  22400
> > Cold    48  24450 Cold    48  30500 Cold    48  18550 Cold    48
> > 26600 Cold    48  34650 Cold    48  26700 Cold    48  26750 Cold    48
> >   30800 Cold    48  32850 Cold    48  28900 Cold    48  30950 Cold
> > 48  381000    Cold    48  181050    Cold    48  301100    Cold    48
> > 221150    Cold    48  261200    Cold    48  221250    Cold    48
> > 181300    Cold    48  280   Cold    49  050  Cold    49  0100 Cold
> > 49  0150 Cold    49  0200 Cold    49  0250 Cold    49  0300 Cold    49
> >   0350 Cold    49  2400 Cold    49  6450 Cold    49  8500 Cold    49
> > 12550 Cold    49  18600 Cold    49  18650 Cold    49  22700 Cold    49
> >   24750 Cold    49  28800 Cold    49  28850 Cold    49  30900 Cold
> > 49  32950 Cold    49  341000    Cold    49  301050    Cold    49
> > 421100    Cold    49  341150    Cold    49  401200    Cold    49
> > 341250    Cold    49  401300    Cold    49  320   Cold    50  050
> > Cold    50  0100 Cold    50  0150 Cold    50  0200 Cold    50  0250
> > Cold    50  0300 Cold    50  0350 Cold    50  4400 Cold    50  14450
> > Cold    50  20500 Cold    50  28550 Cold    50  34600 Cold    50
> > 40650 Cold    50  46700 Cold    50  52750 Cold    50  58800 Cold    50
> >   64850 Cold    50  68900 Cold    50  74950 Cold    50  781000    Cold
> >    50  821050    Cold    50  861100    Cold    50  921150    Cold    50
> >   981200    Cold    50  1021250    Cold    50  1041300    Cold    50
> > 1060   Cold    51  050  Cold    51  0100 Cold    51  2150 Cold    51
> > 8200 Cold    51  14250 Cold    51  18300 Cold    51  22350 Cold    51
> > 28400 Cold    51  32450 Cold    51  36500 Cold    51  40550 Cold    51
> >   44600 Cold    51  48650 Cold    51  52700 Cold    51  54750 Cold
> > 51  58800 Cold    51  62850 Cold    51  68900 Cold    51  72950 Cold
> >   51  741000    Cold    51  781050    Cold    51  801100    Cold    51
> > 841150    Cold    51  881200    Cold    51  921250    Cold    51
> > 961300    Cold    51  980   Cold    52  050  Cold    52  0100 Cold
> > 52  0150 Cold    52  0200 Cold    52  0250 Cold    52  0300 Cold    52
> >   2350 Cold    52  4400 Cold    52  8450 Cold    52  16500 Cold    52
> > 22550 Cold    52  32600 Cold    52  34650 Cold    52  40700 Cold    52
> >   40750 Cold    52  58800 Cold    52  64850 Cold    52  72900 Cold
> > 52  76950 Cold    52  841000    Cold    52  901050    Cold    52
> > 961100    Cold    52  1001150    Cold    52  1061200    Cold    52
> > 1121250    Cold    52  1181300    Cold    52  1220   Cold    53  050
> > Cold    53  0100 Cold    53  0150 Cold    53  0200 Cold    53  2250
> > Cold    53  12300 Cold    53  20350 Cold    53  26400 Cold    53
> > 34450 Cold    53  38500 Cold    53  44550 Cold    53  50600 Cold    53
> >   54650 Cold    53  60700 Cold    53  66750 Cold    53  70800 Cold
> > 53  72850 Cold    53  80900 Cold    53  82950 Cold    53  881000
> > Cold    53  921050    Cold    53  961100    Cold    53  1001150
> > Cold    53  1041200    Cold    53  1081250    Cold    53  1121300
> > Cold    53  1160   Cold    54  050  Cold    54  0100 Cold    54  0150
> > Cold    54  0200 Cold    54  0250 Cold    54  2300 Cold    54  8350
> > Cold    54  16400 Cold    54  22450 Cold    54  24500 Cold    54
> > 32550 Cold    54  36600 Cold    54  36650 Cold    54  42700 Cold    54
> >   50750 Cold    54  56800 Cold    54  58850 Cold    54  64900 Cold
> > 54  66950 Cold    54  721000    Cold    54  741050    Cold    54
> > 781100    Cold    54  801150    Cold    54  841200    Cold    54
> > 861250    Cold    54  901300    Cold    54  940   Cold    55  050
> > Cold    55  0100 Cold    55  0150 Cold    55  2200 Cold    55  10250
> > Cold    55  18300 Cold    55  26350 Cold    55  30400 Cold    55
> > 38450 Cold    55  42500 Cold    55  48550 Cold    55  52600 Cold    55
> >   58650 Cold    55  64700 Cold    55  68750 Cold    55  74800 Cold
> > 55  78850 Cold    55  84900 Cold    55  88950 Cold    55  941000
> > Cold    55  981050    Cold    55  1001100    Cold    55  1041150
> > Cold    55  1081200    Cold    55  1101250    Cold    55  1141300
> > Cold    55  1180   Cold    56  050  Cold    56  0100 Cold    56  0150
> > Cold    56  0200 Cold    56  0250 Cold    56  0300 Cold    56  0350
> > Cold    56  8400 Cold    56  14450 Cold    56  20500 Cold    56  24550
> > Cold    56  28600 Cold    56  30650 Cold    56  36700 Cold    56
> > 40750 Cold    56  44800 Cold    56  46850 Cold    56  50900 Cold    56
> >   54950 Cold    56  581000    Cold    56  601050    Cold    56  621100
> >    Cold    56  661150    Cold    56  681200    Cold    56  701250
> > Cold    56  721300    Cold    56  760   Cold    57  050  Cold    57
> > 0100 Cold    57  0150 Cold    57  0200 Cold    57  0250 Cold    57
> > 0300 Cold    57  0350 Cold    57  0400 Cold    57  2450 Cold    57
> > 10500 Cold    57  12550 Cold    57  14600 Cold    57  16650 Cold    57
> >   16700 Cold    57  20750 Cold    57  20800 Cold    57  22850 Cold
> > 57  24900 Cold    57  26950 Cold    57  261000    Cold    57  281050
> >   Cold    57  301100    Cold    57  321150    Cold    57  321200
> > Cold    57  341250    Cold    57  361300    Cold    57  36
> >
> >
> > *Renato Filogonio*
> > http://lattes.cnpq.br/0339937732653268
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > On Sat, Jul 27, 2024 at 12:13 AM Bede-Fazekas Ákos <bfalevl...@gmail.com
> >
> > wrote:
> >
> >> Dear Renato,
> >>
> >> I've never used this package and you did not attached a reproducible
> >> example, so I cannot test my suggestion. Nevertheless, please try
> >> converting the column "i" to factor before calling the t2way() and
> >> mcp2atm() functions, and replace "as.factor(i)" with "i" in the model
> >> formulas:
> >> khg$i <- as.factor(khg$i)
> >> t2way(formula = fr ~ t * i, data = khg)
> >> mcp2atm(fr ~ t * i, data = khg)
> >> Since you read the khg.txt file with stringsAsFactors = TRUE
> >> parameterization, the factor conversion can be skipped if "i" contained
> >> text. If it contained numbers, then the conversion is needed.
> >>
> >> HTH,
> >> Ákos
> >> ______________
> >> Ákos Bede-Fazekas
> >> Centre for Ecological Research, Hungary
> >>
> >> 2024. 07. 27. 0:23 keltezéssel, Renato Filogonio írta:
> >>> Dear list,
> >>> I used a robust two-way ANOVA using the WRS2 package (R v.4.4.1), using
> >> the
> >>> following code as suggested by Mair and Wilcox (2020)
> >>>
> >>> library(WRS2)
> >>>
> >>> khg<-read.table("khg.txt", h = T, dec = ".", sep = "\t",
> >>> stringsAsFactors=T, na.strings = "NA")
> >>>
> >>> t2way(fr ~ t * as.factor(i), data = khg)
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> This worked fine, so it returned:
> >>>
> >>> Call:
> >>> t2way(formula = fr ~ t * as.factor(i), data = khg)
> >>>
> >>>                      value p.value
> >>> t               133.0420   0.001
> >>> as.factor(i)   3317.8926   0.001
> >>> t:as.factor(i)  150.6804   0.001
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> When I run the pairwise comparison using mcp2atm(), I get:
> >>>
> >>> mcp2atm(fr ~ t * as.factor(i), data = khg)
> >>>
> >>> Error in `[.data.frame`(data, variable.names(mf)) :
> >>>
> >>>     undefined columns selected
> >>>
> >>> So, it is basically the same code for the same dataframe but another
> >>> function from the same package, but now I get an error message. I tried
> >> to
> >>> look at the pairwiseRobustTest() function from the package 'rcompanion'
> >> but
> >>> it is now [Defunct!] as in the last version of 'rcompanion', so I am
> >> afraid
> >>> I am running out of options... Any thoughts on how to circumvent this
> >>> problem?
> >>> I have posted the dataset here:
> >>>
> >>
> https://stackoverflow.com/questions/78800048/error-using-mcp2atm-function-for-robust-pairwise-comparisons-undefined-columns
> >>> Thanks in advance!
> >>>
> >>> Renato
> >>>
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> *Renato Filogonio*
> >>> http://lattes.cnpq.br/0339937732653268
> >>>
> >>>        [[alternative HTML version deleted]]
> >>>
> >>> _______________________________________________
> >>> R-sig-ecology mailing list
> >>> R-sig-ecology@r-project.org
> >>> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-ecology
> >> _______________________________________________
> >> R-sig-ecology mailing list
> >> R-sig-ecology@r-project.org
> >> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-ecology
> >>
> >       [[alternative HTML version deleted]]
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > R-sig-ecology mailing list
> > R-sig-ecology@r-project.org
> > https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-ecology
>
> _______________________________________________
> R-sig-ecology mailing list
> R-sig-ecology@r-project.org
> https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-ecology
>

        [[alternative HTML version deleted]]

_______________________________________________
R-sig-ecology mailing list
R-sig-ecology@r-project.org
https://stat.ethz.ch/mailman/listinfo/r-sig-ecology

Reply via email to