-----Original Message-----
From: Clemens Adler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: Wednesday, June 10, 1998 9:34 AM
Subject: Re: Newbe: Partition recommendations?


>Well at home on your personal box this is might be right, but having home
>on a separate partition does make sense if several users are writing data
>on /home earlier or later your system will crash because no place is left,
>and quotas are nice but if you have a lot of users and most of them don't
>really need any place you'll not set them too tight...

But again, we're talking about recommendations to a new user.  I think that
if some guy is popping in here and says he's installing his first Linux
system, and he's never administrated Unix before and has no clue how to
partition things, he probably doesn't have any users at all.  If he does,
it's probably a couple of his buddies.

Yes, there are valid reasons in some installations to have /tmp, /var, or
even a lower level of directory be moved to a different partition.

But with some new guy running Linux at home, we're more likely to seem him
show up in the list 6 weeks later wanting to know how to make /foo larger
and /bar smaller, because /foo is out of space and /bar has 1 gig free
because he followed somebody's advice to create half a dozen partitions, and
he simply didn't have the experience to know he was going to be putting a
lot more stuff on /foo than on /bar.

/tmp is a good example; in the BSD world we see folks posting constantly
wondering why they can't send or receive a large email, and it's usually
because /tmp is too small.

So you have to repartition half your system just to make /tmp larger, when
for a single user system it's probably just vastly better to have as few
partitions as possible.

Yes, somebody can crash you by filling /tmp if it's on /, but if the only
other person logging on the machine is your spouse and your cousin Bob, who
cares?  It's more important that you have enough space on /tmp to get the
job done.

Some of these recommendations I'm seeing are calling for multi-gigabyte
/home partitions.  What the heck does an average newbie user need with all
that wasted space?  He's never gonna use it, everything he installs is going
to be in /usr/local or somewhere similar, and that's gonna fill up quick as
he experiments with various stuff.

If you're paranoid and you're setting up a system that will have lusers
logging into it, by all means isolate partitions.  By all means put / on
it's own partition, so you can mount /usr in read-only mode and fsck without
a floppy.  By all means make a 200mb /tmp partition.  By all means put /home
somewhere else so people can't crash you by farting around with the output
of /dev/urandom.

But if you're setting up a system that nobody's going to be logging into
except administrators, such as a personal home system or a router, what do
you need with all that junk?  It just guarantees you'll have unusable wasted
partition space.

Even if you're building a Samba server, if you're keeping well ahead of your
users you'll have plenty of warning before you fill up and crash.  If you're
worried about it, dust off your Perl manuals and build something that makes
liberal use of system(df) and email, loud noises, pagers, etc.




-- 
  PLEASE read the Red Hat FAQ, Tips, Errata and the MAILING LIST ARCHIVES!
http://www.redhat.com/RedHat-FAQ /RedHat-Errata /RedHat-Tips /mailing-lists
         To unsubscribe: mail [EMAIL PROTECTED] with 
                       "unsubscribe" as the Subject.

Reply via email to