I have been working with Cisco and Allied Telesyn routers/firewalls for many years. These are at the top end of the security spectrum supposedly. Although it has taken me a l-o-n-g time to get my head around IPTABLES it is FAR superior to any of the other offerings for the following reasons. This is not an exhaustive list but the reasons that appeal to me and are missing from the high end routers. 1) Logging: A properly set-up IPTABLES firewall has excellent logging and accounting to disk, I have not yet come across a router with 200Mb of storage per day/week to keep the records that I keep. 2) Notification of transgressions: Most routers are not capable of the sort of notification options email, pager, flashing lights etc or whatever you wish to configure. 3) You cannot use MRTG to record the in depth level of long term diagnostics on a router: I use mrtg to show monthly SMTP, POP3, WEB site hits and external browsing traffic. I also record DNS traffic, MS Terminal server traffic and just about every other traffic. I can tell from MRTG how may firewall hits there have been and what ports and from what IP addresses they have been. This is just a small subset of the list of features offered by IPTABLES firewall scripts. I use IPForwarding, TOS mutilation, IPSEC among many other features. Most routers are limited to a 2Mb bandwidth, not necessarily so with IPTABLES.
The uses and limitations of IPTables are only in the head of the designer. Mike -----Original Message----- From: Patrick Beart [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Sunday, 17 March 2002 07:45 To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: RE: commercial firewall > > On Fri, 15 Mar 2002, Pieter De Wit wrote: >> >> > Why, what is wrong with ipchains/iptables ? >> > My answer is that it's "software", not hardware. I'm new to the whole "security" thing, but I've learned that a hardware appliance is better than software, if only for the fact that someone is technically already IN the machine when they hit the firewall software. With a hardware appliance there's a physical barrier ahead of your machines. I use the Netscreen products. I think that they're really good at smacking down bad traffic. Moreover, I'm happy that Netscreen CREATES IPSec, it doesn't just pass it on. My $0.02 Patrick Beart ------------- > > > -----Original Message----- >> > From: Keith Morse [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] >> > Sent: 14 March 2002 20:58 >> > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >> > Subject: Re: commercial firewall >> > >> > >> > On Thu, 14 Mar 2002 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >> > >> > > >> > > i'm looking for a commercial firewall to run on redhat linux 7.1. any >> > > recommendations ? >> > >> > > > > Checkpoint's FW-1 might be an answer for you. >> -- ------------------------------------------------ Web Architecture & "iWeb4Biz" 503-774-8280 Portland, OR Internet Consulting, Intelligent Web site Development & Secure site Hosting. http://www.WebArchitecture.com/ "This is an era when nonsense has become acceptable and sanity is controversial." - Thomas Sowell ------------------------------------------------ _______________________________________________ Redhat-list mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list This mail was processed by Mail essentials for Exchange/SMTP, the email security & management gateway. Mail essentials adds content checking, email encryption, anti spam, anti virus, attachment compression, personalised auto responders, archiving and more to your Microsoft Exchange Server or SMTP mail server. For more information visit http://www.mailessentials.com _______________________________________________ Redhat-list mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list
