> My exact issue when looking at S/N generators -- the analog > part. Which is why I am about to build a 2-3kHz bandpass > filter and switch to looking for low averaged values by less > integration (shorter delta t) and faster sampling in the ADC > to look for "valleys" in a "better" way. Make any sense at all?
Yes, but you will have more immunity to audio level variations between receivers if you do peak-and-valley comparison. Compare the ratio of peaks to valleys rather than valley-only and you'll get a more accurate measurement of short-term S/N. Yes, you'll have two sets of detectors for each channel (one for peaks, one for valleys), and yes, you'll have twice as many inputs to mux into the ADC, but I think you'd end up with a superior-performing product. Something to think about or tinker with. Of course, you could avoid all of the analog nonsense and do it with DSP, that would be a cool project. Wish I had more time for these kinds of projects... --- Jeff WN3A