Dear associates, I have begun the review and was pleased with the signup process. However, I have not received the account yet. Aaron, since you already have the account, would you like to handle some of the remaining points? Below are my conclusions so far.
With great honor, Fischers Fritz C0: Pass I registered with w3m. C1: Pass I registered with w3m. C2: Pass Codeberg bylaws section § 3.1 says. > Mitglied kann jede natürliche oder juristische Person oder rechtsfähige > Personengesellschaft werden. https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/src/branch/main/Satzung.md In English this is > Every natural person, legal person or legal partnership can become a member. https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/src/branch/main/en/bylaws.md C3: TODO C4: Pass https://codeberg.org/assets/js/licenses.txt https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/src/branch/main/PrivacyPolicy.md https://codeberg.org/Codeberg/org/src/branch/main/TermsOfUse.md C5: Pass Recommends and encourages GPL 3-or-later licensing at least as much as any other kind of licensing. (C5) > Repository content shall be licensed under an open-source license approved by > the Free Software Foundation (see list of the FSF) or the Open Source Initiative > (see list of the OSI). > Reasonable exceptions are to a very limited extent considered acceptable. For > example, releasing single logo image files of a FLOSS project under no licence > or a separate non-free licence that requires derivative works to use their own > logo that is clearly distinguishable from the original work even in absence of > trademark registration. C6: TODO Support HTTPS properly and securely, including the site's certificates. (C6) B0: TODO Review https://codeberg.org/assets/js/licenses.txt and test with LibreJS. B1: TODO B2: TODO Does not encourage bad licensing practices (no license, unclear licensing, GPL N only). (B2) B3: Pass (See C5.) A0: TODO Signup worked fine with w3m. However, I have not received the account, so I have not tested other functions. A1: TODO I think it passes, but I have not checked thoroughly. A2: Fail (See C5.) A3: Pass (See C5.) A4: TODO I believe Codeberg to fail A4, but I am not sure, because I do not understand the phrase "for practical use". (See C5.) Does somebody know what this means? A5: Todo Does not recommend services that are SaaSS. (A5) A6: FAIL (See C5.) A7: TODO I say pass, but I would like another opinion. A8: Pass I didn't notice references to GNU/Linux, GNU, nor Linux. A9: TODO A+0: Pass A+1: TODO A+2: TODO A+3: TODO A+4: TODO A+5: TODO Codeberg claims to pass this criterion by being a Forgejo instance. According to Codeberg, "[b]y choosing a Forgejo instance, you can easily migrate away from Codeberg in case you don't like it." We can test the claim by exporting a Codeberg account's data and importing it to another Forgejo instance.
