On Mar 28, 2006, at 1:08 PM, Allen Gilliland wrote:
David M Johnson wrote:
eeks, now we are working backwards. if these things are still "experimental features" and need to be kept low profile then i am -1 for moving them out of the sandbox.

also, after "Admin protocol has had sufficient review"? that review needs to happen before we move it out of the sandbox and package the code into a release.

If we're going to get help with interop testing, which is very important for these protocols, it would be *really* helpful to have these features built-in but disabled by default.


i am okay with commiting them to the core code if the implementation is complete but may have some changes in the future, but we still need to treat them as if these are fully working and fully functional features. if we don't believe that is true then we can't release them.

now that i think about it, maybe it is not a good idea to squeeze this in at such a late time in the release process.

I see that last point, but these changes are isolated to two Servlets, don't impact any existing features and are disabled by default.

It would be helpful and much more convenient for me and other folks working on this stuff to avoid the custom build setup. I really don't think there is a downside here.

- Dave


Reply via email to