Heiner,
> I have never understood either that inter- and intra-domain routing > architectures have to be such orthogonal. > So whatever I proposed or supported so far was aiming to a consistent > architectural framework, too. > Routing, which is not based on address summarization, would make sense inside > of intra-domain-networks as well. Do these other approaches show how they recurse from the Internet core all the way to a singleton node as the limiting factor for recursion - or even to virtual networks within a singleton node? Do the other approaches provide for discovery and utilization of multiple border routers? Do they have fully-articulated specifications for automatic EID and RLOC address configuration? Do they support multihoming? Provider-independent addressing? IPv6 deployment? Traffic engineering? Secure redirection? Ingress filtering? What about mobility? MTU handling for tunnels? _Do the other approaches have their base mechanisms widely deployed in shipping implementations for many years, and with many millions of users?_ Is maturity important to this group? What about completeness? Fred [email protected] ________________________________ From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2009 12:31 AM To: Templin, Fred L; [email protected] Subject: Re: [rrg] RANGER(S) In einer eMail vom 19.05.2009 01:26:57 Westeuropäische Normalzeit schreibt [email protected]: but in our experience RANGER(S) is the only proposal with a consistent architectural framework that applies recursively in a "network-of-networks" fashion from the global Internet core all the way outward to even the simplest of edge networks. I have never understood either that inter- and intra-domain routing architectures have to be such orthogonal. So whatever I proposed or supported so far was aiming to a consistent architectural framework, too. Routing, which is not based on address summarization, would make sense inside of intra-domain-networks as well. Heiner
_______________________________________________ rrg mailing list [email protected] http://www.irtf.org/mailman/listinfo/rrg
