As requested by the chairs, I'm reposting my RTGWG comments on this draft.
Like the other draft, I'd like to hear about your use cases for deployment of more than 3 VRRP routers for the same Virtual Router (same LAN segment and VRID). This draft requires implementation of P2MP BFD (RFC 8562) as a pre-requisite. Who has implemented this draft? The draft shouldn't need to modify the VRRP packets. Given the P2MP BFD and its applicability to a Virtual Router needs to be enabled on the participating VRRP routers, you shouldn't need to modify the VRRP encodings. The BFD encapsulation in the draft can be used and the Virtual Router can be determined by the IPv4/IPv6 source address. If RFC 8562 requires the descriminator, it could configured or your document could modify RFC 8562 to avoid bastardizing BFD. Note that other protocols using BFD for fast failure detection do not require BFD information to be advertised in the protocol packets (e.g., OSPF and IS-IS). The draft in under specified as it doesn't include of the additions need to the RFC 9568 pseudo code specifications. However, I REALLY don't want to see any additions to section 7. Thanks, Acee _______________________________________________ rtgwg mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
